3 ms·
From an epistemological point of view, nobody has access to facts. Facts are the things that are. A fact isn't a true statement, but the thing that a true state
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
From an epistemological point of view, nobody has access to facts. Facts are the things that are. A fact isn't a true statement, but the thing that a true statement corresponds to. You're up on a very high horse if you conflate what you think or say with the facts.
"I'm showing them truth and they aren't listening" should be "I'm listing things I believe are true, and they believe different things are true". If you put it that way, it's fairly obviously a naive and solipsistic way to think.
You get into these bizarre pokemon battle-discussions where both sides are throwing out "facts" but it's never effective.
"But I'm showing them science!", you say. Let's be honest here. It's demonstrably true that science isn't guaranteed to be correct. May the ghost of Karl Popper haunt and expound the ideas of scientific fallibilism to anyone who doesn't agree with this. It is perfectly reasonable to doubt scientific claims until you are convinced by them--not by who is saying it, but what they are saying. This is central to the scientific principle to do so.
A prerequisite for knowledge isn't merely being correct, but understanding why things are correct. "Because it says so in this abstract" is not sufficient. If you do not understand why a statement is true, you do not know it is true.
If anything, the reason people get stuck in these intellectual trenches is because they too are conflating the existence of an abstract with sufficient reason for knowledge. They too conflate their opinions about the truth for facts. All these fringe science groups like anti-vaxxers and 5g-conspiracists almost always have "sources" for their claims, and a superficially plausible story about some big cabal of mainstream science trying to suppress them.