4 ms·
That's because people like their cars. You may not, but many people do. And I've traveled in many countries and it's not like cars are uniquely American.
by refurb 5y ago
That's because people like their cars. You may not, but many people do. And I've traveled in many countries and it's not like cars are uniquely American.
- Scott_Sanderson 5y agoYes but designing roads that are hostile to anything other than a car, thus forcing people into cars, is very common in America.
- adrianN 5y agoPeople like their cars because the city design makes all alternatives comically impractical.
- refurb 5y agoNope. I live in a country with high quality transit and the first thing people buy when they can afford it is a car. Why? Convenience, flexibility, ability to haul a family. Cars certainly aren’t a requirement if you have good walkability and/transit, but given the choice many people prefer cars.
- dont__panic 5y agoI have a car, and was excited to get one when I moved out of NYC a couple years back. But I hate using it for day-to-day tasks. For me, it's a machine that lets me take fun trips on the weekend, or go see family in their car-dependent towns and cities. If I want to go to a brewery, or stop by the post office, or shop for a few small items, or just go to a park, I would literally always rather do it on my bike or on foot. Driving around cities is miserable.
- adrianN 5y agoThere is a big difference between buying a car and doing literally every trip in a car because the only connection from the place you sleep to anywhere is six lane road with speeds exceeding 40mph. Of course cars are convenient for some things. I live in a city where the majority of households has access to a car, but only a quarter of the trips (accounting for 40% of the traveled distance) are made by car. I still consider the city to be built very car-centric, but it's a wholly different world from what I experienced when visiting the US.
- refurb 5y agoSure, but in the Strongtowns models there is not space for cars - at least everyone owning a car they only use for weekends. Only the rich own cars. Or those that live outside the urban core. Welcome to our future if Strongtowns has a say.
- adrianN 5y agoThere is plenty of space for cars if you stack them. That's a rather successful model in Japanese cities. Free surface parking has an outsized negative impact on cities. BTW, it's already kind of true that only the rich own cars, car ownership correlates very strongly with household income.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>BTW, it's already kind of true that only the rich own cars, car ownership correlates very strongly with household income. Of course it correlates. Rich households can afford more cars per person and can indulge in specialized vehicles (e.g commuter car). Rich families have a sedan for each commuting parent and maybe another less specialized car (e.g. minivan or 3-row SUV) that only sees weekend use. Poor families pile into a Saturn. That the ability of the poor family to own and operate that Saturn confers a far greater standard of living jump than cars 2-N do for the rich family. It also has a much greater impact on the health of the broader economy. To intentionally place monetary constraints on vehicle ownership would be unwise because you have to price out all the poor before you start making meaningful dents in the (relatively) wealthy professionals who commute across the inner suburbs and into urban environments.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>There is a big difference between buying a car and doing literally every trip in a car because the only connection from the place you sleep to anywhere is six lane road with speeds exceeding 40mph. This is a massive over-generalization that pretty much only applies to the suburbs that were built out in the 1950s and 1960s mostly in the southern half of the country. As those suburbs have densified over the decades (where allowed by law, so not the southwest) some of them have become pretty darn walk-able.
- princeb 5y ago> Nope. I live in a country with high quality transit and the first thing people buy when they can afford it is a car. I, too, live in a country with high quality transit and also got a car when i had a family and i could afford a car. i have about 1400 km per year on it. having a car and driving it are two different things.
- mithras 5y agoIf you have high quality transit, you might also have "share" cars available, doesn't that come out way cheaper if you only use it so little?
- p_l 5y agoIf I had a car, my yearly distance might have been similar. But that's because a car would give me most utility in areas that aren't handled by the "shared" car systems, i.e. longer trips outside of public transport system, especially with cargo that can't be reliably transported on a personal trip on train and the like. And I'd probably still keep to taxis in the city, can't be arsed to drive :D
- refurb 5y agoSo you want to live in a dense, urban walkable core, but also allocated space for everyone to own a car they drive for 1400 km per year. Nope.
- mcv 5y agoI have a car too. But when the opportunity exists, I will always prefer to go by bike. My kids ride bikes too, and my 7-year old son prefers to ride to his swimming lessons on his own bike. The car is only really for when we leave the city, or occasionally when we quickly need to go to the complete opposite end of the city and it's close to the motorway. When given the choice between bad bike/walking infrastructure and cars, people prefer cars. But when you give them good infrastructure, many prefer bikes.
- harpersealtako 5y agoI find this is true nearly anywhere you go in the world, even in countries with excellent public transit (e.g. Korea, Japan, Taiwan). The moment people have the money to afford a car, they buy one. The only places I've seen that this is not the case are isolated, hyper-dense city states (Hong Kong and Singapore).
- bllguo 5y agoof course they do, that's the whole issue. in many situations it is better for the whole if people don't get everything they want. that's where regulation should come in. "people like it" is shortsighted thinking, prone to local optima, and should not be the sole criterion for policy decisions
- refurb 5y agoSure, but don’t act like it’s better when it’s not. Just admit to people they can’t have the better option so they should just deal with it.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoCars are nice, but I don't think people like being forced to drive because the other options all suck shit. People like being able to walk and bike places too, IF the walk and bike options are actually decent (in terms of safety/comfort and distance). And people certainly don't like getting fat, and yet there's a strong link between car-dominant infrastructure and weight. Surprise surprise, getting exercise as part of your transportation is a lot more reliable than getting exercise as leisure.
- cjfd 5y agoThe question is not whether people have cars (they do) or whether they like them or not (some do and some don't). The question is whether the infrastructure forces people to use a car for every single errand. Much less road space is needed if cars are not required for everything. And if one actually likes cars one is more likely to enjoy driving through the mountains than going grocery shopping by car.
- JeremyNT 5y agoIs this a chicken and egg thing though? Do people like their cars because the world they live in requires cars, and thus they become part of their identity?
- robben1234 5y agoMost people don't like driving. People might like their cars for the freedom of movement they provide - like being able to transport cargo without a headache; being able to go on a weekend trip with family; etc. But they certainly don't like their cars for having to spend 2 hours a day just to get to their workplace and back home. They tolerate it. That's why manuals are dying, that's why cars now HAVE to have things preventing distracted drivers from dying, that's why autopiloted car manufacturers are swimming in money thrown at them by everyone despite showing no results. Should you ask why they tolerate it - the reason is very simple. The alternatives - cycling and public transport - have seen close to none of investments in the past decades all over the world. And therefore provide a horrible and humiliating experience to its users. Also, the focus on cars allowed many cities and even countries to get lazy at planning and providing equal infrastructure to all districts. Having a smaller school in your neighbourhood is better for the kids - they could go there by themselves with friends and not spend much time doing nothing in traffic everyday. But because everyone has cars government will do the cheaper thing and build a bigger school that isn't convenient to anyone. People shouldn't have to drive everyday. All neighbourhoods should have adequate commercial and infrastructural exposure on the spot. No driving to school, groceries or GP. And when you have to commute, alternatives to driving should provide a better experience. Then many people would opt not to drive even if commute is needed, and therefore people like me - who like to drive - would have the roads free of traffic jams and distracted drivers, and be able to actually enjoy the experience.