4 ms·
The Strong Towns people want to go back to 1950s midwestern America - small towns strung out along roads, with farms in between. What were all those small town
by Animats 5y ago
The Strong Towns people want to go back to 1950s midwestern America - small towns strung out along roads, with farms in between.
What were all those small towns for? They were built, mostly, as service centers for the surrounding farms. Today, only 1% of the workforce works on farms, and they can get their stuff from Amazon and Walmart. The need for most of those towns is gone. So they're decaying and disappearing.[1]
That's the problem. The Strong Towns vision no longer matches what people do.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ghost_towns_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ghost_towns_in_the_Uni...
- wetpaws 5y agoTokyo is not a small town by any measure, and neither is the most of Europe.
- Animats 5y agoTokyo does not look like the ideal in the article, of small towns strung out along roads.
- danny_codes 5y agoI'm not sure where you got this model. It's not that small towns are strung out along roads. Rather, the town itself becomes a nexus for walk/bike-ability. Instead of every trip to the grocery store, movie theater, and gym being taken by car, the vast majority of trips are taken by walking or biking. This isn't to say there aren't cars in town: on the contrary, roads exist, ideally going around heavily trafficked areas. This lets the roads focus on being roads (getting people from place to place) and the streets focus on being streets (allowing people to walk, bike, and "experience the world", in the parlance of "Not Just Bikes". Of course, the next town over (let's say it's 20 miles away) will be "down the road", with a both a road and a train connecting them.
- foobiekr 5y agoI'm so confused by the idea that Tokyo is somehow bike-centric. Perhaps there's another Tokyo somewhere in Japan that is not a subway-and-taxi centric metropolitan area where bikes are rarely seen. It's a pedestrian-friendly city, though, I'll give you that.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoTokyo has a far higher bike rate than any major American city: https://cityclock.org/blogs/cycling-mode-share-data-700-cities-40-countries https://cityclock.org/blogs/cycling-mode-share-data-700-citi... Keep in mind that "Tokyo" isn't just the super dense, most central area of the metro. Tokyo technically covers a huge swathe of land, including towns that are basically suburbs. And while Japanese cities don't usually include much bike-specific infrastructure, in practice many of the narrow roads are pretty bike friendly anyway, just due to their very narrowness.
- foobiekr 5y agoI have spent a ton of time in Tokyo. I am fascinated by this. I actually suspect they are including the delivery bikes, which are not really the same thing, and the cited study, which I will try and track down, has poor data hygiene.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoHmm, I don’t really see why that wouldn’t count. Do car/truck work vehicles not count for car mode share?
- foobiekr 5y agoBecause they are basically strictly mopeds and not used for ordinary people. The cited study there is unknown because it’s not actually cited.
- masswerk 5y agoMind that Strong Towns isn't about picturesque communities, but about sustainable economics in the face of rising costs of extensive infrastructure and low income generated per area.