2 ms·
> The core idea is that we see the market as a means to an end, not some end in itself. The market was never an end to itself. Literally go back and read anywh
by panick21_ 5y ago
> The core idea is that we see the market as a means to an end, not some end in itself.
The market was never an end to itself. Literally go back and read anywhere from Smith, Hume to Hayek. That is just a straw-men argument.
> When the market is incompatible with societal good, the market needs to change, not society.
And who and how is it determined, what the social good is? Are bureaucrats loosely connected to politicians loosely connected to voters a better an more reliable form of social preference allocation then the price mechanism under the same law? Not by any existing evidence in social science.
But the core of your argument is basically the government whenever it feels like it can just intervene in the market directly and put its finger on the scale. Not by fundamentally changing the rules, just be direct intervention whenever they don't like something. Often that is a foreign competitor and some vague hard to prove claims about market power. And often it is the citizens of that country that end up having higher prices or higher taxes. French book market being a good example.
Many times it has been shown historically that the monopolies far, far, far more often are government created then market created. And laws to establish 'fair competition' are usually strongly sponsored by the very competitors who get crushed in the market, often for good fundamental reasons.
The first Anti-Trust law in the US was by local butchers to prevent centralized butchers with refrigerated rail-cars. Would it really be 'fair competition' to give money to local butchers to prevent them from this 'unfair competition'. No, its how you get a stagnate economy depended on subsidies.
Very often its just governments doing what they want for the political clients that they have. French publishers, German news organization.
A perfect example is Germany where German Newspaper have fought tooth and nails for years against 'Google News' and basically want to monetize every link to their sites. This is all done in the name of 'fair competition' while introducing laws that are really the opposite and hurt user freedom in the process.
> It's the root cause why inequality is so much worse in the US, why you have a much bigger housing crisis, why health care in the US is such a mess, why there's homeless people everywhere etc etc.
If you think housing and health care are examples of 'free market fundamentalism' then you are very badly informed.