3 ms·
I was working on a project about 15 years ago that could tie a website to a business address. The underlying assumption is that many/most legitimate businesses
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
I was working on a project about 15 years ago that could tie a website to a business address. The underlying assumption is that many/most legitimate businesses that sell products have registered trademarks. The main purpose of a mark is to enable traceability back to a legitimate, non-ephemeral source for a product. If the reader disagrees that reputable products would have associated trademarks, then stop reading here. :)
These trademarks can be represented in a domain name or TLD. IP offices that register the marks generally obtain physical mailing addresses for physical correspondence. The crux of the idea is that the domain name and TLD do not have to be issued by ICANN. As such, it does not have to follow any pre-established conventions. Trademark registration systems already have unique identifiers and classifications that can be represented in the domain name/TLD. Thus we can create a new, collision-free naming system that offers more than ICANN, e.g., a direct association to an IP office.^1 This leverages the work of IP offices to collect business addresses (or at least addresses of the registrant's lawyers/agents who would by necessity have the business address of the registrant). Under this system the perceived legitimacy of the business is reliant on the trademark registration, not a "TLS certificate". The legitimacy of the domain name/TLD becomes dependant on the trademark registration, not an unaccountable, known-to-be-corrupt entity such as ICANN. To put it simply, names require an associated trademark. The system favours businesses that want to enable consumers to trace a product back to an original, legitimate source. It is a naming system for real(TM) business. :)
Personally, if I were trying to assess the legitimacy of a business, I would rather rely on the records of a trademark office versus the records of a TLS certificate provider. But that's just me.
1. ICANN of course, to ensure its own profits, chose to allow disputes to occur and create quasi-legal dispute resolution systems instead.
- Animats 5y agoI used TLS certs, mailing addresses on web sites, purchased commercial business directories, Hoovers (before they were acquired by DNB), SEC filings, and Yahoo Directory (defunct). But not domain info, which was just too low-quality. Snail mail addresses intended for humans were the most useful. Although they could be spoofed, that's very rare, and tends to attract legal attention.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoForgot to mention the key feature. Users can search for entities/products using trademark names and registration classes, i.e., by searching the appropriate name containing the entity/product name and/or classification. Currently, a page of search results from a "state of the art web search engine" can leave one guessing about the sites represented by the domain names listed in the URLs. The searcher trusts that the search engine "knows what she is looking for" and has performed a disambiguation for her, automatically. Whereas under the new system, the domain names unambiguously indicate trademark-protected names of companies or products, including their trademark classifications. This tells the searcher exactly what type of entity/goods the site purports to describe/offer and the source of those goods. No need for the search engine to second guess what the searcher is looking for. For example, a name might be formed as something like productX.companyY.classZ. A user could search for URLs with subdomain "productX" and TLD matching "classZ", or a search for domain matching "companyY" and TLD matching "classZ", or perhaps a more broad search for domain under "classZ".