4 ms·
Yeah, no. I was in Google Patent Litigation. "Treble damages" is just something lawyers like to use to scare the engineers with. Besides the "treble damages" u
by AlbertCory 5y ago
Yeah, no. I was in Google Patent Litigation. "Treble damages" is just something lawyers like to use to scare the engineers with.
Besides the "treble damages" urban legend (more on that below):
* G was putting the patents online as soon as the PTO made them available. There was no delay so G could mine them for those nuggets of valuable IP.
* There are no nuggets of valuable IP to be mined in patents.
* Even if there were, ideas are a dime a dozen. It's execution that matters.
* "Treble damages":
* first of all, the plaintiff hires a "damages expert" to calculate a good number to ask for. These people make a lot of money. "Willfulness" as in "engineer reading a patent" does not even enter into it.
* secondly, "willfulness" comes from the plaintiff writing a formal letter to the defendant informing them of the patent, and asking them to take a license. It's always from discussions with their lawyers, or maybe someone talking about it on email.
* ask yourself: if it *were* from engineers *reading* a patent, how would they even know? From their own web logs? How would they know who at the defendant's company was reading it? Wouldn't that be obscured by the defendant's internet interface?
- kragen 5y agoTreble damages due to willful infringement is not really an urban legend; treble damages are statute law in 35 USC §284, and the willful-infringement standard has been established by over a century of case law. I'm surprised you're not familiar with it if you were in Google Patent Litigation. Knowledge of a patent (or having reason to know of it) is a prerequisite for willful infringement; one way to establish that knowledge is, as you say, a notice letter, but that's far from the only way. In particular, engineers at a company reading a patent does establish knowledge of that patent. And of course knowledge is not the only prerequisite for willfulness. But sometimes it's the only thing saving you. You imply that the plaintiff's damages expert decides whether to request enhanced damages, but in fact the enhanced-damage multiplier is a decision made by the district court after the damages have been decided. Since you're evidently not familiar with the sordid history of the standards the courts apply to establish willful patent infringement, I suggest reading Underwater Devices v. Morrison-Knudsen, 717 F. 2d 1380, 1389-90 (Fed Cir. 01983), which imposed an egregious affirmative duty to consult counsel to avoid findings of willfulness; Kloster Speedsteel v. Crucible, 793 F. 2d 1565, 1579-80 (Fed. Cir. 01986), which strengthened it; Johns Hopkins v. CellPro, 152 F. 3d 1342, 1354, 1363-4 (Fed. Cir. 01998); Knorr-Bremse v. Dana, 383 F. 3d 1337, 1343 (Fed. Cir. 02004); In re Seagate, 497 F. 3d 1360, 1371 (Fed. Cir. 02007), which, among other things, eliminated the duty to consult counsel, four years before the AIA codified that elimination in §284; SSL v. Citrix 769 F. 3d 1073, 1082 (Fed. Cir. 02014); MobileMedia v. Apple, 780 F. 3d 1159, 1164 (Fed. Cir. 02015); and most of all Halo v. Pulse, 136 S. Ct. 1923 (02016), which substantially loosened the standard for willfulness again. I can particularly recommend Ending Patent Law's Willfulness Game by Lemley and Tangri from 02003 for an overview of the legal landscape at the time: https://btlj.org/data/articles2015/vol18/18_4/18-berkeley-tech-l-j-1085-1126.pdf https://btlj.org/data/articles2015/vol18/18_4/18-berkeley-te... It's worth mentioning that Lemley and Tangri weren't just "in Google Patent Litigation"; they are actual patent litigators, partners in a patent law firm, and law professors (Lemley at Berkeley and then Stanford, Tangri at Berkeley). Tangri has actually represented Google, and Lemley is the author of a book on intellectual property. They say: > The complex rules of the game... discourage engineers and companies from reading patents in the first place, thereby undermining the disclosure function that is at the foundation of the patent system. ... Defendants may become aware of a patent in several ways. ... A corporation can find a relevant patent during a patentability search for a new invention; or if one of its engineers regularly reads new patents in her field, observes a patent number marked on a competitor’s product, or even peruses a news article. ... Finally, a patent owner can put a competitor on notice of the existence of a patent by sending the competitor a letter identifying the patent and giving some indication of how it relates to the competitor’s business. Fortunately, as I explained above, the situation has improved somewhat since their writing, but not in ways relevant to this discussion. But it's true that establishing willfulness is not just a matter of finding a line in your HTTP server logs, and to my knowledge such a thing hasn't been offered as evidence in a patent case yet. Your other points are irrelevant to my comment, since it did not allege that there was a delay, that there were nuggets of valuable IP to be mined, or that ideas mattered. As it happens, my opinions differ from yours in many ways, but I would rather not get sidetracked by irrelevancies. I want to emphasize that I am not an expert in the field of patent litigation, but such expertise is not required to discover the flagrant and reckless falsehoods in your comment.
- AlbertCory 5y agoLeaving aside the tone of your post: I did it; you did not, AFAIK. You're talking about what might happen; I'm talking about what does happen. Please point us all to some case where: 1) an engineer read a patent and took no other action, e.g. commenting on it 2) the plaintiff never notified the defendant in any other way, putting them on notice 3) the plaintiff discovered it (and tell us how they discovered it) 4) the damages were trebled as you've insisted So can you do that?
- kragen 5y agoClearly not; no damages can be awarded without the plaintiff notifying the defendant. You've gone from posting falsehoods to posting logical contradictions. Perhaps you are not aware of the contradiction because you believe that allegations of willful infringement are limited to cases where notice was given before a lawsuit was filed. They are not. I don't think you should try the "I did it, you did not" defense when you're flatly contradicting a law review article about patent law by Lemley and Tangri. Instead, you should apologize for posting misinformation, and then you should stop doing it.
- AlbertCory 5y agoYou seem to have a grudge. I think we're done here.
- AlbertCory 5y ago> Your other points are irrelevant to my comment, since it did not allege that there was a delay, that there were nuggets of valuable IP to be mined, or that ideas mattered. OK, then what are you saying? You said "The unfair advantage, I suspect, may have been that Google could look to see which patents were popular, or which ones were popular at a particular company, or which ones were becoming popular at a particular university" If Google only looks when the whole rest of the world can also look, then it has no advantage. Right?
- kragen 5y ago
- kragen 5y agoTo anyone else who's reading this thread later on, you should be aware that my comprehensive, factual rebuttal, full of citations to caselaw, law-review articles, and statute, demonstrating the egregious falsehood of the parent comment, has been "flagged" and so is not visible by default; it's at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29505838 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29505838, and you can see it by signing up for an HN account and turning on the "showdead" setting in your profile. Please, please do not base your strategy for dealing with patents on the dangerous falsehoods "AlbertCory" is spreading here. It could destroy your company or your career. Don't be fooled by his claims to expertise. Don't take my word for it either. Read the law review article I recommended in my other comment, written by two of the top patent litigators in the world: https://btlj.org/data/articles2015/vol18/18_4/18-berkeley-tech-l-j-1085-1126.pdf https://btlj.org/data/articles2015/vol18/18_4/18-berkeley-te...