3 ms·
> It's the root cause why inequality is so much worse in the US, why you have a much bigger housing crisis, why health care in the US is such a mess, why there'
by sneak 5y ago
> It's the root cause why inequality is so much worse in the US, why you have a much bigger housing crisis, why health care in the US is such a mess, why there's homeless people everywhere etc etc.
I don't think a single part of this claim a) logically follows from the previous paragraphs, or b) is actually true.
For just one example: the housing crisis is a lack of supply, which is the result of the exact same kind of status-quo-maintaining, market-forces-secondary-to-regulatory-aims (NIMBYism by property owners and their representatives) thing you describe as being the European norm.
To say that these philosophical differences are the root cause of failures in very complex systems is of course the popular and prevailing European narrative about the USA. (There is another, equally popular and equally false (but self-congratulatory) one in Europe about gun violence in the USA.) I just don't see much evidence to substantiate it.
- malermeister 5y agoCounterexample to your housing crisis claim: Vienna, Austria. 44% of the housing stock is in public ownership, two thirds of the population live in public housing. Rent is affordable and housing stock is of high quality. Market forces would not have solved this, as there is very little profit to be made with low-cost housing - so the lack of housing was fixed by state intervention and Vienna has the highest quality of life in the world [1] as a result. [1] https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/vienna-best-city-live-quality-life-ranking-mercer-australia-europe-a8820396.html https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/vienna-...
- sneak 5y ago> as there is very little profit to be made with low-cost housing I’m fairly certain that this is not correct.
- malermeister 5y agoHow do you explain the lack of low-cost housing in most US cities then?
- sneak 5y agoProhibitions on adding supply, mostly driven and incentivized and rewarded by existing landowners who directly profit from constrained supply and high prices.