5 ms·
The Tsar Bomba was the practical limit for what could be dropped by an airplane. In fact, the Tsar Bomba had a large parachute, to ensure that the airplane cou
by dragontamer 5y ago
The Tsar Bomba was the practical limit for what could be dropped by an airplane.
In fact, the Tsar Bomba had a large parachute, to ensure that the airplane could fly away in time.
---------
Allegedly, the Tsar Bomba weighs 27 tons, which is a little bit beyond what a modern C-130 could carry. (But maybe a modified C-130 could carry such a weapon).
EDIT: Bigger bombs could be made, but the question of "how to deliver" the weapon to our enemies becomes a significant question. There's always the Dr. Strangelove approach of building an infinitely huge bomb in your own country, and hoping the bomb is big enough to blow up the world... but that was a joke / sarcastic movie and not an actual plan (I hope).
- mithras 5y agoI think Starship could deliver a 150 metric ton bomb.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoWhat about delivery by ship? I wonder what are the limits for cargo ships. Personnel could evacuate and remotely detonate.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trhway 5y agoModern Russian “Tsar Bomba” in an autonomous nuclear powered 10000+ miles range mini submarine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Status-6_Oceanic_Multipurpose_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Status-6_Oceanic_Multipurpose_... . They are already being put into service.
- ethbr0 5y agoThe problem with nuclear UUVs is that they don't solve any tactical problems Russia actually has. Want to nuke Jacksonville, Norfolk, New London, San Diego, and Puget Sound? Russia can already clobber them with enough ICBMs. So... first strike? In which case the silos in the Great Plains launch on you, followed shortly thereafter by any SSBN on patrol. It only makes sense as a defensive weapon. And while Russia is paranoid, I don't think they're strategically expecting the US to be able to neutralize their road/rail mobile forces and submarines and strategic bombers in a first strike. In which case it only makes sense as a propaganda device. Good use of limited funding, there.
- effie 5y agoIt's obviously another unkillable deterrent weapon, similar to submarine ICMBs, Perimeter, etc.
- trhway 5y ago> a propaganda device. that is of course. Another way of building an even bigger d.ck. >And while Russia is paranoid, I don't think they're strategically expecting the US to be able to neutralize their road/rail mobile forces and submarines and strategic bombers in a first strike. Russia has been losing on high-tech weapons - high precision, stealth, global and battlefield awareness/connectivity and now on the drones (which is for example why Russia so conspicuously amassed so many basically WWII style forces right now on Ukraine border - to show that if Ukraine uses its Turkish drones - the current huge, yet carrying a kind of expiration date, strategic advantage Ukraine got over Russia in Donbass - to "solve" the Donbass issue like Azerbajan did in Nagorny Karabah using the same drones a year ago in a big facepalm to Russian weapons - the Russian forces will strike behind Ukraine Donbass forces cutting them from the rest of Ukraine somewhat similar to the Ilovaysk battle of August 2014, only at the much larger scale this time), and it is pretty feasible that US would get a hold on the sufficient intelligence and would have the capability to use low yield (even non-nuclear) precision first strike to disable most of the current Russian MAD assets, and the good anti-ICBM missile can do the rest. I'm not saying that US is going to actually do the strike - just having credible capability would adjust the situation severely. So Russia not being able to match in the high tech, goes wider and larger scale - like those nuclear powered cruise missile and that gigantic torpedo "wunderwaffe".
- SkittyDog 5y ago> that is of course. Another way of building an even bigger d.ck. I don't think it's appropriate to deride the security motivations of modern Russia, so casually. In the 20th century, Russia was very nearly wiped out, by surprise attack, TWICE. Their casualties were staggering, more than any other nation on earth has ever endured. And the trauma to their politics, economy, and culture will probably persist for decades, if not centuries. In the direct aftermath of WWII, a huge swath of top US & UK military and political leaders publicly insisted that the West should re-arm and continue Total War against the USSR, and completely dismantle their military capabilies. I don't mean to excuse ANYthing the Soviets or Russians have done, as a result of the national character they've been left with. But if we fail to fully understand how the world & its history look, from their perspective, we will be actively participating in the extinction of the human race.
- SkittyDog 5y agoThe Russians are way ahead of you, buddy: • https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Status-6_Oceanic_Multipurpose_System https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Status-6_Oceanic_Multipurpos... I live in coastal Los Angeles, and I regularly look out at the Santa Barbara Channel, and wonder if one of these nightmares is already out there.
- handrous 5y ago> EDIT: Bigger bombs could be made, but the question of "how to deliver" the weapon to our enemies becomes a significant question. There's always the Dr. Strangelove approach of building an infinitely huge bomb in your own country, and hoping the bomb is big enough to blow up the world... but that was a joke / sarcastic movie and not an actual plan (I hope). I could absolutely see a country planting too-big-to-drop nukes along potential invasion routes. Especially during the Cold War, but even now.
- dragontamer 5y agoNuclear artillery did the job just fine though. When you have a gun that can deliver nukes 50km away (ie: standard M777 Howitzer), it makes more sense to shoot the nuke at the enemy rather than plant a bomb in an expected path. That way, you remain flexible. Artillery guns like the M777 can be fired roughly 10-times per minute (depending on the skill of its crew). Give them nuclear rounds, and they'll deliver. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_artillery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_artillery
- handrous 5y agoSure, but heavy artillery might not survive a loss of air superiority over "friendly" territory. A deep-buried super-heavy nuke does, and forces the invaders to slow down and try to deal with it while using other, worse routes that aren't in its blast radius, or else risk having it go off at a very inconvenient time. Like the ultimate scorched-earth plan.
- dredmorbius 5y agoA chief function of mines isn't so much where they are as where they aren't, but that the enemy thinks they might be. Navigating minefields takes either time, a total disregard for consequence, or ignorance. None are especially effective countermeasures in heat of battle.
- moffkalast 5y agoAssuming your naval gun doesn't misfire and delete your ship.
- echelon 5y ago> The Tsar Bomba was the practical limit for what could be dropped by an airplane. > Allegedly, the Tsar Bomba weighs 27 tons, which is a little bit beyond what a modern C-130 could carry. Turn a C-5 Galaxy into a drone and then you have 140+ tons to work with.
- dwighttk 5y agoI mean. Drop the bomb and just don’t let it go off until the plane is far enough away. You’d miss out on the airburst, but it’s big enough that probably wouldn’t matter. Or throw it out and give it some sort of self propulsion that keeps it at the airburst height until the plane is far enough away. C-130 is just a little guy… looks like a C5 could carry at least 3 of those bombs (if I’m doing my math right.)
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoThe use of tactical nuclear weapons in Europe by both sides would have left the USSR conquering ruins and ghouls.
- irrelative 5y agoThere was a sort of doomsday device built by the Soviets: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=113242681 https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=113242... > If there's a crisis, somebody in the Defense Ministries has to turn it on, so that's the first step. It then tries to find evidence that there's been a nuclear hit on the Soviet Union. If it determines that there has been a hit, then it tries to communicate back to the Defense Ministries. And if it can talk to them, it says, okay, humans are still alive. I don't need to work. I'll shut off. > But if it can't communicate with them, then it knows there's been a crisis. We've been hit by a nuclear warhead and all the lines of communications with the Defense Ministries have been taken out. So now, we need to bypass all the traditional layers of command authority, and suddenly, the ability to launch a nuclear retaliatory strike is given to some junior official in a bunker.
- Animats 5y agoOh, Perimetr. That was one of the Soviet Unions's better ideas. The goal was that the Premier of the USSR was not allowed to have the authority to order a nuclear first strike. Only the Politburo could do that. This was post-Stalin, and the leadership didn't want one person to have too much power. The USSR earlier had a dual-custody system - the military controlled the delivery systems, but the KGB controlled the warheads. They had to cooperate. Again, no single person could start a nuclear war. This is very Soviet. Padlocks that require two different keys are a popular USSR antique. The Premier could activate Perimetr in a crisis. But that didn't do much. Only if Moscow were destroyed, for which there are sensors, and the system could not communicate with the underground bunkers of either the leadership or the General Staff, would the system activate. Several locations could stop the process. Even if triggered by the destruction of Moscow and the silence of higher authority, Perimetr just released the codes that allowed regional commanders to use nuclear weapons at their discretion. It didn't launch an attack automatically, although some articles claim it did. This is much more restrictive than the US system. The US president has the authority and the codes to launch a nuclear first strike. This was a very real concern in the last days of the Trump administration, enough that the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the Speaker of the House met to discuss what to do if attack orders were issued.
- lr1970 5y ago> The Tsar Bomba was the practical limit for what could be dropped by an airplane. The design was for 100MT. Tsar Bomba was a reduced yield variant where some of uranium was replaced by lead to reduce the yield to 50MT. The 100MT variant had the same weight and dimensions and was deliverable by the same airplane.
- sgillen 5y agoTrue, but the airplane still needs to leave the blast radius before the bomb impacts the ground, the 50MT version still needed a large parachute to meet that requirement.
- smegsicle 5y ago> Dr Strangelove Colossus: The Forbin Project (1970) follows a US-made doomsday machine, with a little more care taken to explain/defend its creation. nb spoilers abound if you try to read anything about it