2 ms·
There's already a system that does the whole job of flying, for emergency use only - Garmin Safe Return.[1] In the plane, there's one big red button. If pushed,
by Animats 5y ago
There's already a system that does the whole job of flying, for emergency use only - Garmin Safe Return.[1] In the plane, there's one big red button. If pushed, the plane finds an airport and lands, all by itself. It picks the nearest suitable destination airport, using info about fuel state, weather, and airport status. It starts squawking with the emergency transponder code. It plays emergency messages to ATC. There's also pilot incapacitation detection. If the pilot doesn't do anything for a long time, the system sounds warnings, then takes over.
Everybody else has to get out of the way, though, when it declares an emergency. It can't really communicate with ATC. So it's strictly an emergency system, for now.
This is really just integrated control of the existing avionics. The existing systems are good enough that you can input waypoints and have them followed, and do an automatic instrument landing on a designated runway. This mostly sets up a flight path. It can't deal with traffic. There are no new sensors. The additional hardware just lets it lower the landing gear, apply the wheel brakes, and shut down the aircraft after landing. After which you're blocking the runway until someone comes out and moves the aircraft. Again, emergency use only.
It's intended for the "sick pilot, healthy airplane" case - the pilot is out of action, but the hardware is fine. It's not helpful in making hard decisions when the aircraft is having problems.
[1] https://youtu.be/d-ruFmgTpqA https://youtu.be/d-ruFmgTpqA
- coredog64 5y agoAllegedly the B-2 bomber has had “go to war” and “return to base” buttons for 30 years. The latter is for exactly the same reason you note: Plane is good, pilots are not. Not quite sure about the value of the former.
- hotpotamus 5y agoI'm not sure I buy the existence of such buttons, but if the pilots are incapacitated in a nuclear bomber with a target in mind, then I can think of a use for the go to war button.
- Buttons840 5y agoSo the modern remake of those "pilot incapacitated, help me land" shows can be shortened to "push the big red button, then have a snack"?
- t0mas88 5y agoIt's a great system, but it is very far from replacing pilots in any useful way. As you said it's mostly a nice integration of the existing autopilot functions. Real world flying with the 10^7 or 10^9 kind of scale for safety isn't in need for a better autopilot. That would be like making a more precise cruise control while you want a self driving car. What it needs is better decision making and problem solving skills. And those are very much lacking from these current systems. I have an instructor rating. We can teach an average human in 5 to 10 hours how to control a plane. Then we spend an additional 40 to 60 hours on how to make the right decisions, solve problems, deal with weather, traffic etc. And humans are really good at that. What is needed if you want autonomous flight is really good AI decision making, not aircraft control.
- Animats 5y agoRight. Good decision making when in trouble is a hard problem. AI is still very bad at "common sense", which I sometimes define, for robotics, as "getting through the next 30 seconds without screwing up".