5 ms·
> Where would we be without Tesla succeeding? Hydrogen Fuel Cells and probably more widespread PHEVs. Which would have been a superior future than where we ar
by dragontamer 5y ago
> Where would we be without Tesla succeeding?
Hydrogen Fuel Cells and probably more widespread PHEVs.
Which would have been a superior future than where we are today.
10-million cars with 200lbs of Li-ion batteries each would save more energy from our transportation network than 2-million cars with 1000lbs of Li-ion batteries each.
------
At this point. Elon is incredibly anti-progress. He's switched into fighting against alternatives and is diminishing progress on legitimate strategies (both H2 and PHEVs) because he wants to hold onto his market advantage.
- peter422 5y agoThere are more PHEVs than there has ever been. I know because I’m researching them to buy one. I can’t imagine how the success of Tesla has possibly not had the effect of speeding up legacy manufacturers to create PHEVs. Tesla led the way to get all this electrical car infrastructure out in the world that everybody else can take advantage of.
- dragontamer 5y agoTalk to any Tesla-fan. "Icky ICE Engine". "Now you have two engines with twice the malfunctions". "I don't like oil changes". Etc. etc. They're incredibly anti-PHEV. Neither Elon nor his gang of supporters are very good for PHEVs. And on stage, Elon still derides them as a strategy. -------- Look: Elon / Tesla are right now arguing __against__ government incentives for PHEVs and EVs. His politics have flipped. He's no longer a supporter of incentives for this industry.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoI mean, the whole two engines thing is true though right? If someone else can get the cost of H2 fuel cells down to a marketable level I'm sure Tesla would be very happy to fit them as optional range extenders to its next line up. In the UK at least, most PHEVs sold are cynically avoiding a bunch of taxes and benefit in kind. Many of them are never plugged into a charger.
- dragontamer 5y ago> If someone else can get the cost of H2 fuel cells down to a marketable level I'm sure Tesla would be very happy to fit them as optional range extenders to its next line up. Hyundai Xcient for one is launching imminently. China / Zhangjiakou is launching 600+ busses on Hydrogen for the 2022 Winter Games. Toyota Mirai existed for __years__.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoYutong and BYD sell ~20k electric busses per year.
- brianwawok 5y agoI am both a Tesla fan and a Tesla driver. I am against PHEVs. When my parents recently went shopping for a new car, I tried to sell BEV. When I failed, I encouraged them to skip PHEV and just buy ICE. PHEV are 2x the complexity and things to worry about and go wrong. You need to stop for gas AND plug in your car every day? You need to change your oil AND potentially replace your battery? IMO PHEV exist because they are a compliance tool to meet green energy standards, but not generally a solid product. I see them vanishing very soon as BEV production capacity increases, and they will be a tiny footnote in the history of the automobile. In fact a salesmen directly told us that the PEV we were looking at (PEV XC90 I think?) was a joke, and we could just throw the plug in the trash when we got home and ignore that it existed.
- olyjohn 5y agoIs a PHEV any more complicated than a regular hybrid car? You still have gas and electric motors, just a bigger battery pack in the PHEV. The Prius has proven that even with a gas motor, they can be super reliable. These cars are beaten and abused by taxi fleets and Uber drivers for over 20 years now, and they still hit over 300,000 miles reliably. The electric motor takes so much work off of the gas motor, the gas motor is still usually in really good condition after that many miles. And if you buy the right PHEV, like as in, you buy the one that fits your commute, you probably don't have to gas up much at all. I know people with PHEVs and they love them. They rarely ever put gas in them, except for long trips. All their commuting is done on electric power. They work great. I don't really get what you are on about. Maybe you are biased as a Tesla fan and Tesla driver. I mean, I'm not even sure why else you would have mentioned that. Maybe as a disclaimer that we will know your post is biased? The fact that you're a fan has nothing to do with the reliability or quality of a PHEV, and is totally irrelevant otherwise.
- dragontamer 5y agoIn fact, PHEVs are arguably simpler, because the engine is tuned to the generator (which has a consistent RPM / Torque curve). Having an engine run at one singular RPM / Torque band is much easier than ICE, which commonly needs to deliver power from ~1500 RPM to 6000 RPM.
- r00fus 5y agoFuel Cells are the scam. The cheapest way to make hydrogen fuel is through fracking. It's dirty under the top-level. So it's "no emissions" but still relies on the planet-killing petroleum fuel chain. If you think PHEVs are somehow constrained by EVs - you have no idea of the patent forests Toyota and others have built on hybrid tech. It's not the lithium that's stopping PHEVs.
- dragontamer 5y agoAnd the cheapest source of electricity is coal. So its not like your EV-powered vehicle (largely using coal to power itself) is much better. In any case, widespread electrolysis of Hydrogen is well researched and well on its way to being achieved: https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-production-electrolysis https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-production-el... There was a good article or two on some systems developed that were direct from solar-power into hydrogen, skipping the inefficient electricity steps.
- r00fus 5y agoCoal isn't the cheapest power anymore. Your information is out of date [1]. Electrolysis or solar hydrogen production still isn't even here, much less cheaper than fracking. [1] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/07/renewables-cheapest-energy-source/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/07/renewables-cheapest-e...
- dragontamer 5y agoForward looking statements are no different than a $39,900 Cybertruck. They're correct as far as my discussion point is concerned. A possibility of the future, the benefits of being forward looking. It may not exist, but the point of the statement is to be parity with Elon Musk's discussion style. Not to be on parity with the actual truth. That's the problem: Mr. Musk imagines the future and his discussions are apparently fine. But snap back to reality and suddenly everyone else (who is working on realistic numbers) is wrong. ----- Electrolysis could exist, and it could be cheap. Much like how a $39000 Cybertruck could exist in enough numbers to warrant customers putting down reservation money on it. Its the name of the game and you know it if you've followed how this discussion evolves. Yes, I feel icky using that kind of logic but its necessary in this age.
- kiba 5y agoHydrogen Fuel Cells and probably more widespread PHEVs. I am unconvinced by the case for hydrogen fuel cells or PHEVs. 10-million cars with 200lbs of Li-ion batteries each would save more energy from our transportation network than 2-million cars with 1000lbs of Li-ion batteries each. The correct answer is the reduction of cars. Taking 10 million cars off the road and switching to public transit and higher density suburban and urban planning would save more energy in the long run. At this point. Elon is incredibly anti-progress. The best car is no car.
- dragontamer 5y agoMr. Musk was pretty integral in his role of killing the California High Speed Rail project. He created a fake solution, the Hyperloop, to steal hype away, and then never built the Hyperloop. Thereby killing the mass-transit solution of California. ------ I stand by my assertion. Mr. Musk is no longer useful for the environmental cause. He is decidedly anti-progress at this point. A few years ago it was somewhat ambiguous, but now its clear.
- diebeforei485 5y agoNonsense. California High Speed Rail practically killed itself.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> California High Speed Rail practically killed itself. Except it's still actively being built.
- dragontamer 5y agoI hope you're right and I wish the project the best. I'm no where near California, but I think rail (and high-speed rail in particular) is one of the most efficient means of transportation devised, and should be deployed and supported. In any case, Mr. Musk has not been helpful to the cause at all.