3 ms·
Ah, don't get me wrong, I don't have a very high opinion of Elon. I think Tesla is over-valued as a simple car company and selling it as a tech company is borde
by hef19898 5y ago
Ah, don't get me wrong, I don't have a very high opinion of Elon. I think Tesla is over-valued as a simple car company and selling it as a tech company is borderline charlatan. And yes, he fails at a lot of, let's call them non-core, products. And usually misses timelines for core products. Anyone else trying this would be nailed to the wall, Elon pulls it off. That alone is quite a skill. With the effect that Tesla now is a viable car manufacturer, regardless of market cap.
Personally, I hate that approach to business. I don't even talk about the Solar City bail-out, his Tesla goes private tweet and all that. For some reason that really avoids me, it works...
- dragontamer 5y ago> Anyone else trying this would be nailed to the wall, Elon pulls it off. That alone is quite a skill. PT Barnum, Elon Musk, Edison. More people pull it off than you'd think. Its an age old strategy of simply never admitting mistakes and hoping the American population ignores the mistakes. ------ Its what we like to call a "conman", you know... people who are really good at "confidence games" (what "conman" stands for in short). You hit people with a lot of confidence, and people then give you money. It works on small scales, it works on large scales. This isn't an attribute you should be praising. This is just how humans work, and people who abuse other humans with this tactic are immoral.
- hef19898 5y agoI wouldn't limit it on America, so. I'm not praising it, all things considered this behavior causes much more damage that it does, maybe, good. but even when it comes to conmen, there are bad ones, mediocre ones, good ones and really good ones. Musk absolutely is part of the latter group...
- slibhb 5y agoCalling him a conman given what he has achieved with electric cars and rockets is absurd. That's coming from a place of envy or resentment. Musk over-promises, and often, but what he delivers is impressive even if it doesn't meet his promises. Therefore he's no conman. The more interesting question is whether the over-promising is necessary if you want to achieve something substantial. Politicians certainly seem to think so.
- hef19898 5y agoWell, he can be both. With his conman stunts he is buying time for hos companies to finally achieve something. Sad part is, since something is done, he could just work with realistic timelines. He doesn't, and this results in Tesla et al having an unfair advantage over competitors who are measured against Elon's BS promises. Politicians are probably the worst group to measure against when it comes to honesty and decency.
- slibhb 5y agoI've seen every David Mamet movie and Musk is no conman by any fair definition. Politics works like this: 1. Politician "shares a vision" 2. People buy into that vision by voting politician into office 3. Politician never achieves vision but makes progress towards it or fails to The vision can be something like "everyone should be able to go to college," "a good job for every American," "no more homelessness," "healthcare for every American" and so on. Is this lying? In some sense, yes, but I would say we should judge politicans by how they change the world (for better or for worse) rather than whether they actually achieve their vision. Is it possible to make progress towards some goal without an unrealistic ideal providing inspiration?
- dragontamer 5y agoThis strategy is called "The old Razzle Dazzle": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YW3MIixEps4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YW3MIixEps4 Its well known to work. We all know it works, and there are a myriad of examples throughout US history (and maybe even in other countries). Just because it works doesn't mean its moral. ------- Leverage your popularity, start fights in the public, get the common people low-key interested (but not interested enough to actually look at the facts, just interested enough to follow the fun stuff) and give them a show. Suddenly you get a ton of supporters. Politicians, Lawyers, and yes, CEOs / Businessmen commonly do this. Call it whatever you want, its not something I think we should b glorifying as a society.
- slibhb 5y ago