6 ms·
> And he ultimately delivers product, something most Musk-wannabes fail to do. Where's are the solar roof? Battery swaps? And "coast-to-coast full self drivin
by dragontamer 5y ago
> And he ultimately delivers product, something most Musk-wannabes fail to do.
Where's are the solar roof? Battery swaps? And "coast-to-coast full self driving", $35,000 Model 3?
Do you think the personal assistant robot will ever be a delivered product?
-------
Musk has mastered the ability to make the public forget about his promises. He doesn't deliver on these promises at all. I think we're generally wising up to his game: Musk carefully SEO's his words and public image to make the internet itself forget about these claims.
Only people who actually rely upon their own personal memories (ie: the Battery Swap demo from 2013) can pull this information out. Otherwise, they're fogotten.
----
In any case, this video-games while driving thing is just more of the 2016 claim of "coast to coast full self driving by 2018". He hasn't delivered upon the promise and needs to muck up the waters even more on the subject.
https://futurism.com/elon-musk-teslas-autonomous-car-will-drive-coast-to-coast-by-2018 https://futurism.com/elon-musk-teslas-autonomous-car-will-dr...
> [Elon] said that the coast-to-coast test is still on track to take place at the end of the year, and that all Tesla cars built since October 2016 would be updated. The plan, announced in a Ted Talk last month, is to “go all the way from a parking lot in California to a parking lot in New York with no controls touched in the entire journey.”
- toomuchtodo 5y agoSolar roof was on a brewery in New England I recently patroned. You can buy it if you want to pay and wait for it. Battery swaps were to fully capture California ZEV credits until Tesla could grow large enough to not rely on them. The market for Teslas has flourished without them, relying only on Fast DC chargers for consumer range anxiety. Personal assistant robot is a cheap marketing effort to drive recruiting of talent. Laugh and point fingers. The methods work, regardless of the feelings about them.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Laugh and point fingers. The methods work, regardless of the feelings about them. No. "Battery Swap" was a lie that was never delivered and frankly just stole money from California. We all know that __lying__ works. The last few years have made it abundantly clear that the general population is far more accepting of these lies than I'm comfortable for. So I'm going to keep pointing them out.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI will accept some lies for desperately needed progress. And, as you mention, lying works. Where would we be without Tesla succeeding? Definitely not where we are today. Legacy automakers are still making half hearted efforts at electrifying transportation while Tesla increases production 100% YoY. Legacy auto would’ve made no effort without Tesla coming at them hard, versus the little bit of effort they show today. Are you willing to sacrifice morally or ethically if the change needed to mitigate climate change is going to require some less than total honesty? Consider we, again, as you mention, live in a post truth world. One must adapt to the operating environment to increases chances of success.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Where would we be without Tesla succeeding? Hydrogen Fuel Cells and probably more widespread PHEVs. Which would have been a superior future than where we are today. 10-million cars with 200lbs of Li-ion batteries each would save more energy from our transportation network than 2-million cars with 1000lbs of Li-ion batteries each. ------ At this point. Elon is incredibly anti-progress. He's switched into fighting against alternatives and is diminishing progress on legitimate strategies (both H2 and PHEVs) because he wants to hold onto his market advantage.
- peter422 5y agoThere are more PHEVs than there has ever been. I know because I’m researching them to buy one. I can’t imagine how the success of Tesla has possibly not had the effect of speeding up legacy manufacturers to create PHEVs. Tesla led the way to get all this electrical car infrastructure out in the world that everybody else can take advantage of.
- dragontamer 5y agoTalk to any Tesla-fan. "Icky ICE Engine". "Now you have two engines with twice the malfunctions". "I don't like oil changes". Etc. etc. They're incredibly anti-PHEV. Neither Elon nor his gang of supporters are very good for PHEVs. And on stage, Elon still derides them as a strategy. -------- Look: Elon / Tesla are right now arguing __against__ government incentives for PHEVs and EVs. His politics have flipped. He's no longer a supporter of incentives for this industry.
- tbabb 5y agoWhat was the requirement that was satisfied by the battery swap?
- dragontamer 5y agoCalifornia wrote an idiotic tax credit that gave +tax credits to vehicles that demonstrated a capacity to charge in under X minutes. Elon Musk shows off a battery swap demo on stage to "prove" it, and then grabbed the tax credit. Then he threw away the battery swap demo and never talked about it again. Its a combination of idiotic governance + a conman / liar at work. The government tax credit is a decent idea to spur innovation, but only if the government actually rewards money correctly. If it gives out money too freely, then the companies will just eat the government's face... they'll take the money but never actually develop the technology.
- wumpus 5y agoThat's about 1/3 of the story of the battery swap experiment. Tesla put engineering behind making the battery easily removable in all Model S cars, but actual customers (like me) didn't want to use battery swaps. I'd rather supercharge. p.s. can you stop name-calling?
- diebeforei485 5y agoNot true, they did have a real battery swap station just off i-5 (between SF and LA) near Kettleman City. I don't think many people used it, however.
- dragontamer 5y agoThat was only open to select members and required a reservation. It never was a viable model, or even open to public service. And we all know that swapping $15,000 batteries out for free ain't a valid business model and never will be a valid business model. It was a project designed to maximize the California incentives and minimize the costs to Tesla for obtaining that money. ------ I hope that the citizens of California learned their lesson. But even if they refuse to learn, I've learned very much from that episode.
- hef19898 5y agoAh, don't get me wrong, I don't have a very high opinion of Elon. I think Tesla is over-valued as a simple car company and selling it as a tech company is borderline charlatan. And yes, he fails at a lot of, let's call them non-core, products. And usually misses timelines for core products. Anyone else trying this would be nailed to the wall, Elon pulls it off. That alone is quite a skill. With the effect that Tesla now is a viable car manufacturer, regardless of market cap. Personally, I hate that approach to business. I don't even talk about the Solar City bail-out, his Tesla goes private tweet and all that. For some reason that really avoids me, it works...
- dragontamer 5y ago> Anyone else trying this would be nailed to the wall, Elon pulls it off. That alone is quite a skill. PT Barnum, Elon Musk, Edison. More people pull it off than you'd think. Its an age old strategy of simply never admitting mistakes and hoping the American population ignores the mistakes. ------ Its what we like to call a "conman", you know... people who are really good at "confidence games" (what "conman" stands for in short). You hit people with a lot of confidence, and people then give you money. It works on small scales, it works on large scales. This isn't an attribute you should be praising. This is just how humans work, and people who abuse other humans with this tactic are immoral.
- hef19898 5y agoI wouldn't limit it on America, so. I'm not praising it, all things considered this behavior causes much more damage that it does, maybe, good. but even when it comes to conmen, there are bad ones, mediocre ones, good ones and really good ones. Musk absolutely is part of the latter group...
- slibhb 5y agoCalling him a conman given what he has achieved with electric cars and rockets is absurd. That's coming from a place of envy or resentment. Musk over-promises, and often, but what he delivers is impressive even if it doesn't meet his promises. Therefore he's no conman. The more interesting question is whether the over-promising is necessary if you want to achieve something substantial. Politicians certainly seem to think so.
- Retric 5y agoThe current base price of $39,490 is is 34,997$ in 2017 dollars when it was introduced. So not only where they selling at 35k for a while, in real terms they still are. https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/ https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/
- dragontamer 5y agohttps://www.tesla.com/model3/design#overview https://www.tesla.com/model3/design#overview I'm seeing $44990 as the base price right now. There's no $35k Model 3, not in 2021 dollars, not in 2017 dollars. Not in inflation-adjusted dollars. Not available at all in any capacity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deelowe 5y agoIt was always 35k with incentives.
- dragontamer 5y agoThe website quotes $4300 in "gasoline savings". A number that's suspiciously higher than I remember before. I wonder if Tesla has been changing the calculation on their "gas savings" to match marketing needs. In any case, "gasoline savings" is not an incentive.
- Retric 5y agoThat or gasoline is currently expensive, it’s up 60% over the last 18 months though closer to 50% from 5 years ago. https://www.gasbuddy.com/charts https://www.gasbuddy.com/charts I find including the gas savings number a poor choice even if you see the real price well before buying the car. It simply varies to much both over time and based on driving habits for any general number to be very relevant, also nobody shows the impacts of say insurance costs on different car models.
- literallyWTF 5y agoDon’t bother man. No matter what you say people will come up with excuse after excuse after excuse. “I love the car but…”
- dragontamer 5y agoEach discussion I have, my arguments grow stronger. I see what works and doesn't work, and prepare for the same discussion to happen say... 2 or 3 months from now. Everyone else forgets about the discussion, and I hold onto my strengthened arguments to hit them again. It takes a few years, but over the long term, my arguments evolve into a stronger form, and people start to listen. ------ I've learned that while the Internet's memory is long, people's individual memories are short. You have plenty of opportunities to improve your arguments over time. Its no different from what Elon is doing here: leveraging the shortness of the typical person's memory to make his marketing tricks work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- manicdee 5y agoWhere are the electric cars from all the traditional manufacturers? Lucid and Rivian are starting to roll out production vehicles after years of failing to deliver more than vapour and promises. Solar roof has been deployed and you can read any number of stories about failed certification (certain utilities are not interested in certifying connection of rooftop solar). Battery swap was only ever a compliance technology which Tesla abandoned as soon as the regulatory requirements were removed.