3 ms·
The post didn't use the word scarcity. Land isn't even scarce, most land is effectively uninhabited compared to the population densities most people live at. Hu
by roenxi 5y ago
The post didn't use the word scarcity. Land isn't even scarce, most land is effectively uninhabited compared to the population densities most people live at. Humanity at large is not short of land.
Land is quite unique. It is the resource with the weakest argument that humans produce it. Gold, for example, requires human labour to be dug up. Bitcoin requires humans to run machines. The Mona Lisa requires humans to paint. Land behaves differently.
- amablue 5y agoFor what it's worth, it's not uncommon for Georgists to also favor extraction taxes for natural resources like gold.
- kesselvon 5y agoLand isn't scarce, but economically viable and productive land is scarce. Economic viability is a moving target, but for the most part pretty steady.
- epistasis 5y agoI agree 100%. Originally land taxes were conceived as a correction for a more subtle bit of economic inequality: productivity of fields. In today's world, where access to a city can dramatically change one's earning potential far far more, they are even more relevant. The issue is both about the scarcity of access to a resource, such as the economy of a city, but also about where that resource comes from. With urban land, that resource is not the product of the individual land owner, but rather all the other land owners that made the city so prosperous and with so much opportunity.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Land isn't even scarce Yes, it is (or, at least important subsets of land are.) If it wasn't, it would have zero value. Nonzero market value requires, and therefore proves, scarcity.
- whakim 5y agoThe post I was responding to makes the distinction between things we can't create more of (land) and things we can (paintings). I used scarcity as an (erroneous) proxy for this distinction, even though obviously there are scarce things that we can create more of. > Land is quite unique. It is the resource with the weakest argument that humans produce it. I mean, not really. What about water or oxygen? What about carbon taxes insofar as they're related to the inherent value of the earth's climate? There are plenty of resources that don't require any human effort to produce, but that doesn't make them better suited to taxation. It just seems like an entirely arbitrary distinction to make.