3 ms·
A simple flat tax is clearly a far superior system in every single way. If you are really hardcore about richer people paying even larger part then simply make
by panick21_ 5y ago
A simple flat tax is clearly a far superior system in every single way.
If you are really hardcore about richer people paying even larger part then simply make the curve slightly progressive.
If you want poorer people to pay even less make the minimum number required for max tax higher.
This would make the overall tax system 1000x simpler releasing a gigantic amount of labor and would allow IRS to actually check effectively if people are lying. It would make all fraud much harder.
- spurgu 5y agoI tend to agree, and definitely on the surface of it. But what about for example incentives to cut down on carbon emissions, how would you achieve those? Or stopping investors for buying up all the great real estate in an area and boost up the rent prices? I believe that there needs to be some "punishment" taxes, to regulate things that might otherwise go out of hand (which is important in order for capitalism to function well). But I do recognize the issue that it's probably what has lead most governments down that exact path towards an overly complex taxation system. Also I don't think you have to be "really hardcore" to support progressive taxation. It just makes sense. As long as it's not "overly progressive". Edit: A too simple of a system makes it too easy to game the system. I wish there was a clear way out of it.
- panick21_ 5y ago> I believe that there needs to be some "punishment" taxes, to regulate things that might otherwise go out of hand (which is important in order for capitalism to function well). First of all I don't think that actually is true. Second, even assuming this is true. Using the tax system is about the worst possible way of achieving these things. Making the tax system complex to micromanage all possible situations on a federal level is just not a smart way of achieving almost anything. For really big picture issues, I would make revenue neutral taxes. So if you really want a carbon tax, it would be revenue neutral. Meaning all the money made from the carbon tax would be used to reduce the taxes for everybody (or alternative use it to raise the minimum income line so poorer people have to pay less. If you just want to give a general reward or punishment for doing the right or wrong thing, those should be individual acts of congress or from bureaucracies based on their executive power, and not somewhere in 6000 page of tax code. > Also I don't think you have to be "really hardcore" to support progressive taxation. It just makes sense. As long as it's not "overly progressive". Well its % based so its already progressive as in you pay far more if you are richer. So if you want to also pay higher % if you are richer. > Edit: A too simple of a system makes it too easy to game the system. I wish there was a clear way out of it. Its the opposite. A simple system makes it incredibly hard to game the system.
- spurgu 5y ago> Well its % based so its already progressive as in you pay far more if you are richer. So if you want to also pay higher % if you are richer. This is just flat out wrong. With a flat tax you don't pay a higher % if you are richer, you pay a higher amount. It stings just as much to lose 10% if you make 1k/month as when you make 100k/month. Whereas with the latter you're left with 90k, arguably much more than needed for a comfortable life, so you could easily pay 30% without a noticeable change in your life quality (or future business endeavors). Of course if you have a shitty government then subjectively any tax is gonna go to waste and this is a pointless discussion. We're talking about an imaginary society here where we're making things better through a simpler system and the government can actually get things done fairly efficiently. I simply believe the answers lie somewhere in the middle. I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree. Redistributing the taxes sounds like a good idea whenever we're talking "punishment taxes", but... you also need to consider who has to take care of and pay for the mess created (if someone pollutes a river). So from that perspective the opposite makes sense, that the "punishment taxes" goes to the state, to fix things. Ultimately I think it's a question of size of society/government. A small enough society is self-organizing. The larger it becomes the more structure/regulation it needs to not break apart, and at some point it becomes inefficient. We just need to watch out for increasing complexity, and make active efforts to reduce it (that's something few world governments are doing right now).
- panick21_ 5y ago> With a flat tax you don't pay a higher % if you are richer, you pay a higher amount. That's literally what I wrote. The Flat tax is not fixed. Its incremental up to a a limit. So you only pay the full amount once you reach a certain level. Below that you pay increasingly less. And as I suggested, if you want higher % you can make that slightly slanted as well.
- spurgu 5y agoOk maybe we're getting stuck on definitions here. When I think "progressive taxation" I'm thinking something like: < 10k 0% 10-30k 20% 30-60k 40% 60k+ 60% Whereas "flat tax" is just a set percentage, for example 20% (like what Estonia has), regardless of how much you make.
- yonran 5y agoI think in principle, an income tax is similar to a land value tax in that both of them are trying to capture monopoly rents. Compared to the property tax, the land value tax exempts investing in improvements, just as the income tax exempts capital investments and interest. The important differences are in what they exempt from taxation. America’s income tax exempts imputed rent, so a business or household who happened to buy land that has appreciated gets a discount on their taxes compared to their younger neighbors (who have to pay inflated prices). Whereas a land tax would capture imputed rent, so old landowners are on a more even playing field with new businesses/households, incentivizing young people to compete, making land value tax better than income tax. The land tax’s major additional exemption is labor. A bakery’s land taxes don’t go up at all if he puts in twice as much effort, whereas his income taxes would at least double. So LVT incentivizes work, making land value tax better than income tax. On the other hand, progressive taxation automatically taxes other monopoly rents, whereas the land value tax depends on the government assessing the value of land and any other important monopolies.
- panick21_ 5y agoI don't know about the specifics of the US tax code. > I think in principle, an income tax is similar to a land value tax in that both of them are trying to capture monopoly rents. I don't know what that means. An income tax simply a uniform tax does not distinguish for type of income. "Monopoly rents" or whatever else. You can read the details in "The Flat Tax: Updated Revised Edition" > A bakery’s land taxes don’t go up at all if he puts in twice as much effort, whereas his income taxes would at least double. So LVT incentivizes work, making land value tax better than income tax. What it actually does is make totally arbitrary value judgments on different types of income and totally distorts who pays what in totally random way based on a huge number of factor unique to each industry or trade. Its a harmful distortion of the price system. The justification for that are some 19th century theories about the special place for land that doesn't make sense. The whole point of a flat tax is to not distort capital allocation. Anybody that earns more, pays more. That's it.
- yonran 5y ago> I don't know what that means. In Henry George’s terminology, he decomposed income into three components based on the three factors of production. Income from competitive labor is called wages, income from competitive capital is called interest, and income from land and other noncompetitive monopolies is called rent. He proposed to tax land and other monopolies heavily, while exempting labor and capital from tax. What I meant is that a progressive income tax has higher rates for people and companies with high profits while exempting capital and labor expenses, which is similar to the Georgist idea of taxing monopolies more heavily than capital and labor. > You can read the details in "The Flat Tax: Updated Revised Edition" Thanks for giving the reference to Hall and Rabushka https://www.hoover.org/research/flat-tax https://www.hoover.org/research/flat-tax. Previously you mentioned making the curve progressive, which is not a flat tax so I just assumed you meant income tax. In comparison to the current income tax, it seems that Hall and Rabushka do not exclude business interest expenses or personal mortgage interest, but they still do exclude wage expenses. Wages are progressive at the low end (due to the personal allowance) but their tax is not otherwise progressive. And they totally exclude personal capital gains from taxation (such as the sale of your house) (although the current income tax is not very good at taxing capital gains of real estate). Basically, the point of the flat tax seems to be to eliminate complicated deductions, credits, and depreciation, and they are skeptical of progressivity which they see as “redistribution”. Note that they themselves admit that their flat income tax should be combined with property taxes: “We believe that taxing housing is properly ceded to local governments under our federal system. Local property taxes capture part of the value of the services of a house.” (from Chapter 5: Q&A) > Its a harmful distortion of the price system. I disagree that LVT (tax on scarcity rents) is a harmful distortion on prices. Chapters 1-4 of Rethinking the Economics of Land and Housing is a good book on this topic. https://www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Economics-Land-Housing-Ryan-Collins/dp/1786991187 https://www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Economics-Land-Housing-Rya... As you note, the whole point of prices is to incentivize capital investment. But the difference with land is that it has a vertical long-term supply curve, so more money in land does not result in the creation of any more land; it’s just a transfer payment to the old owner. Ownership of natural resources is a major undeserved source of inequality. We see the inequality playing out in San Francisco: residents who happened to own land became rich, whereas residents who did not own land became impoverished, just as Henry George wrote: “it is as though an immense wedge is being driven through the middle. Those above it are elevated, but those below are crushed” https://www.henrygeorge.org/pchp0.htm https://www.henrygeorge.org/pchp0.htm. It is better for the poor and better capital allocation to “distort” the economy to prevent extreme inequality between rentiers and laborers+capital.
- pydry 5y agoThe flat tax was designed to be regressive. Why take a regressive tax and then try to patch it with 1000 difficult to implement hacks to make it progressive? Why not just use taxes that are naturally progressive? The flat tax is the most transparently self serving idea from the rich since trickle down.
- panick21_ 5y agoLol, so if you change a fixed number into a slanting line its '1000 difficult to implement hacks'. That literally replacing a fixed number with a simple function(income) -> %. However there are also good reasons not to do that. And the tax is not regressive, you clearly haven't read about it other what other people who have not read about it.
- pydry 5y agoUnder flat tax you spend more you get taxed more. Who spends the greatest % of their income + wealth? The poor. Who spends the lowest % of their income + wealth? Jeff Bezos. It's really not that complicated to see how it shifts the tax burden. Steve Forbes pushed it like a religion for a reason. It wasnt because he loved poor people or hated tax avoiders.