4 ms·
I look forward to reading the second part, especially if it’s going to argue that tenants will somehow be able to use the land without paying the land rent. In
by sokoloff 5y ago
I look forward to reading the second part, especially if it’s going to argue that tenants will somehow be able to use the land without paying the land rent.
In any case, I believe a land value (or other property) tax would face significant (possibly insurmountable) Constitutional challenge to levy this federally in the US absent an amendment.
https://constitutioncenter.org/interactive-constitution/interpretation/article-i/clauses/757 https://constitutioncenter.org/interactive-constitution/inte...
- klipt 5y agoYou'd really need to combine land tax with zoning reform to make it work properly. The idea is that since the land under a house and under a skyscraper is taxed the same, more valuable land (eg in city centers) would be built up, which means the tax per tenant could still be very low. Also you don't need to do it federally, states could do it fine too.
- kiba 5y agoIf we're talking about no political restriction, I would go even further. Get rid of the mass market cars and implement trams as the basic suburban and urban feature. It could even carry some light freight for last mile logistics. As for the rest, it's bicycles, even velomobiles.
- tormeh 5y agoTrams suck, IMO. The only good thing about them is they often get right of ways, which can also be given to busses. Subways are where it's at. Long trains that don't have to deal with traffic lights.
- kiba 5y agoSubways are expensive to construct, and only make sense once density become high enough. So, in my conceptualization, towns start out with trams, which then connect to larger urban center.
- lmm 5y agoBuses can be rerouted at the stroke of a pen, so it's difficult for people to build their lives around them. Trams are often overrated (and don't get me started on tram-trains), but they're a good fit for small towns or corridors that don't have the traffic to justify a subway.
- hammock 5y agoWhy does everyone assume new policy has to be enacted at the federal level? Whatever happened to states rights? This is a perfect use case, have a couple states try it and a couple not and see what happens.
- sokoloff 5y agoIn part because the article makes the very common argument “[LVT would raise] a bunch of revenue that can lower or even eliminate other less efficient taxes, such as sales and income taxes.” It’s often argued (more strictly than above) that LVT could replace or substantially reduce income taxes and that pretty much means it’s federal or it won’t offset much.
- reducesuffering 5y agoThere are plenty of states with 0 income taxes. Plus, the article mentions benefits that are orthogonal to tax revenue, like more efficient resource allocation. A trial run at the state level could be a 0 income tax state keeping their tax revenues equal by substituting property tax with LVT. Building structures will be taxed less and the land underneath taxed more.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoThere is no federal sales tax. There are states that have income taxes, too.
- pasquinelli 5y agoJust have them do it!
- moriwara 5y agoNot pure LVT but Pennsylvania does have a two-tiered system where land is taxed at a higher rate than improvements https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2019/3/6/non-glamorous-gains-the-pennsylvania-land-tax-experiment https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2019/3/6/non-glamorous-g...
- runnerup 5y ago> In any case, I believe a land value (or other property) tax would face significant (possibly insurmountable) Constitutional challenge to levy this federally in the US absent an amendment. I'm really quite sure this would be a state-level thing.
- epistasis 5y agoFurther, I think such a tax would provide absolutely huge economic benefits to the states that passed them. Much like California's restrictions on non-competes allowed a much more dynamic tech industry to develop than what developed in Massachusetts.
- ghaff 5y agoPeople moved between computer companies all the time in Massachusetts--albeit at a time when engineers job-hopped much less than today. I never had a non-compete until EMC bought the company I worked for and that non-compete was pretty reasonable and didn't keep me from getting a job elsewhere. I don't like non-competes and MA has fairly recently made some worthwhile (although insufficient) changes. But the differences between CA and MA (which still has some of the highest VC investments in the country, albeit less than CA) are hard to square with being primarily about non-competes.
- runnerup 5y ago> tenants will somehow be able to use the land without paying the land rent. I believe proponents of Georgist Land Taxes generally believe that rents are already as high as they can be. This seems reasonable for areas with housing shortage, as housing is a very inelastic commodity as far as commodities go. However, it might not be a good assumption for areas with a surplus of housing. I do know (multiple!) people who each have multiple properties in Austin (e.g. a suburb house and a downtown condo) who are not renting them out after moving to California. Currently the property tax is offset by rising property prices and its not worth the hassle/risk to put tenants into the properties. A higher property tax would absolutely cause them to either rent out the units or sell them, increasing housing supply. Saudi Arabia finally created their first tax ever while I was there. It was a tax on un-developed land inside city limits. Saudi oligarchs would buy empty land and just leave it barren, because the property value would go up and there was no cost to hold it. This led to a big housing shortage. By taxing unimproved land, Saudi was able to encourage a big boom in condominium development. I believe proponents of higher land taxes are trying to do something similar, but instead of taxing "undeveloped" land, they are aiming to tax "under-developed" land to try to spur additional unit construction.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Currently the property tax is offset by rising property prices and its not worth the hassle/risk to put tenants into the properties. Depending on the local laws, leaving properties empty can actually be riskier than having them occupied. I had a friend struggle to evict squatters who moved into his rental property while it was vacant for a few weeks between tenants for upgrades. He lost months trying to get them evicted and they did a lot of damage to the house because they didn’t have anything to lose. Houses are also tough assets to just sit on because they slowly decay over time and require periodic maintenance and updates, even if nobody is living there. An empty house can actually accumulate damage faster than an occupied house because nobody is there to notice leaks or other problems. Leaving a property empty is definitely not a normal situation outside of maybe a few select markets with outlier (bubble) levels of appreciation and speculation. Building an entire tax system around this possibility doesn’t seem like a good idea.
- sokoloff 5y ago
- pasquinelli 5y agoJust make it a constitutional ammendment. I mean, obviously nothing of significance is going to change in terms of public policy, at all. This should be obvious after Obama->Trump->Biden, and covid, and on and on really. So, given that fact, it's a little funny to poo-poo a public policy thought experiment (which is all it is) on the grounds that the courts would strike it down-- as if any change of any significance will survive to that point. But if we're talking thought experiment, just make it a constitutional ammendment.
- runnerup 5y agoIndeed! Thank you. Too many people don't see the constitution as the living document it was intended to be. It's so weird to me to keep hearing "that would be unconstitutional" as if it's some ultimate argument-ender for these thought experiments. Also, in real life, I'd be happy to see a constitutional convention to resolve quite a few things - 2A, 4th amendment, abortions, 100-mile constitution-free-zone, etc. Seems like having a well-defined constitution that we can actually follow would be much better than our current situation where we largely seem to ignore the constitution text in favor of byzantine court precedence/interpretations. I mean, on the face of it, people should see it's strange that alcohol prohibition required a constitutional amendment in 1920 but marijuana/drug prohibition in 1970 did not (Controlled Substances Act).
- tormeh 5y agoThat's just how common law works. If you want to get rid of the power of precedent, it's not gonna really happen, but civil law would relax it a little bit, at least. Civil law is, in practice, also using precedent, but it's given way less weight
- harimau777 5y agoHow would we go about actually changing the constitution? It seems like there's too much polarization and entrenched interests for that to happen.
- runnerup 5y ago
- pydry 5y ago>I look forward to reading the second part, especially if it’s going to argue that tenants will somehow be able to use the land without paying the land rent. Tenants already pay a 100% land value tax. They just pay it direct to landlords. All an LVT would do is redirect this flow of wealth into community/city/state coffers rather than to land / mortgage backed security owners.