3 ms·
Both failure to vaccinate as well as smoking causes direct and proximate damage to those around you. Say what you will about bodily autonomy, but there isn't a
by sneak 5y ago
Both failure to vaccinate as well as smoking causes direct and proximate damage to those around you.
Say what you will about bodily autonomy, but there isn't a double standard. The right to swing your fist, et c.
Abortion doesn't count under this scheme because of the postulate that a fetus is not a human being yet.
- nodesocket 5y agoExcept that if you get vaccinated, why does it matter if hypothetically I am not vaccinated? True story, I got Moderna, three months later I got Covid along with a group of my friends all vaccinated with either Moderna or J&J. Anyway, don't want this to diverge into a covid shitshow argument. The problem is that the US government is trying to mandate if you don't get vaccinated then you lose your job. That's an issue for me.
- HarryHirsch 5y ago[flagged]
- sneak 5y agoThe simple answer? Vaccinated people, while they can spread covid from a breakthrough infection, spread much less covid than unvaccinated people, and they have a shorter period of time while they are contagious. You significantly reduce the risk of transmitting covid to others (should you become infected) by being vaccinated. They're not trying to mandate that you lose your job, they're trying to mandate (as they already do - see OSHA's current body of regulations) that workplaces are safe physical environments for people to be in. It's the same story with workplaces without fire exits being illegal. Even if you don't agree with it, it is definitely logically coherent. As much as I don't want unvaccinated people around, I also disagree with violent coercion, so I'm not sure that I am 100% philosophically on board with the state's right to regulate trade between private parties whatsoever - but if they can rightfully require fire exits or building safety codes, they can require vaccinations in a work environment.
- totony 5y agoParent is confusing liberalism with socialism. So is the US. Being liberal would mean embracing freedom. But socialist liberal is a mostly self contradicting ideological position, because you always have that "freedom until I decide that freedom affects me too much."
- michaelsbradley 5y agoAnd plenty of us around the world understand the “postulate that a fetus is not a human being yet” to be the height of absurdity and insane, frankly, and therefore abortion is a matter of grave injustice: the murder of innocent and defenseless human persons.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sneak 5y agohttps://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/amp/english/postulate https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/amp/english/postulate Postulates are inherently subjective. They are not put forward as truths, but as a basis of coherent logical reasoning, ie: IF you accept postulate x as true, BASED on logical reasoning y, THEN you must logically accept conclusion z as true as well. I didn't offer support or denial of the postulate - just that the logic applied thereupon is consistent and coherent.
- hugsby 5y ago[dead]