3 ms·
> There are some multi-boot tools, that enable putting many ISO files on the one USB-stick. I have never used them, and don't see the point of them, unless you
by zamadatix 5y ago
> There are some multi-boot tools, that enable putting many ISO files on the one USB-stick. I have never used them, and don't see the point of them, unless you are a crazed disto-hopper.
If the author had taken a bit of their own advice and went out of their comfort zone they might not have been having so many issues finding where to put the save file years ago! Overall though I get it and image distribution is easier for 99% of cases. I have found it more difficult in 2 cases though, both are cases of "the tooling knows ISO".
The first is on IP KVM's, even when they support non-ISO based virtual drives you'll often be wishing they did. The last I remember trying to futz with this was a Lantronix Spider and it wanted to pass through an entire drive letter but it wasn't working for whatever reason and I eventually just made an ISO with the files in it and mounted the file with 2 clicks.
The second is virtual machines with a similar story but this time it's usually possible to qemu-convert or extract and put into a virtual disk of the right format and you're good to mount the disk - or maybe you get lucky and the packaged format is just a click or config line away from natively mounting like assigning an ISO to a virtual CD drive is. A good example of the latter was just today I wanted to boot a live Linux environment to run gparted on an existing guest VM on an M1 Mac Parallel's guest. I had 0 knowledge (or desire) to investigate how to get an ARM64 image of my preferred distro to be in whatever format Parallel's expects just to use for 5 minutes then never use that virtual disk again so I found Fedora shipped ARM64 ISOs and was able to easily mount it with a few clicks in the GUI and do my work.
I don't think either of these are at the forefront of Puppy's use cases but worth mentioning in a universal call to retire ISO. It may be an old hodge-podge at this point but most everything understands how to work with it as boot media already vs whatever disk image format you choose instead.
- nyuszika7h 5y agoFunny how the author complains about how ISOs make the rest of the drive unusable and then say they see "no point" in multi-boot tools. That is exactly one of the use cases multi-boot tools like Ventoy support, being able to store other data on the drive. (The only caveat is that you must format the whole drive to install Ventoy in the first place, but after that you're free to store both ISO and non-ISO files on it.)
- DarkUranium 5y agoVentoy even explicitly supports persistent data for the ISOs, defeating his argument of being unable to store the OS' data on the flash drive: https://www.ventoy.net/en/plugin_persistence.html https://www.ventoy.net/en/plugin_persistence.html
- nsonha 5y agothe point is that you should use a mechanism that allows it, without some magical tool. Ventoy wasn't a thing until recently and what they said was true and is still true for people who just go to some homepage, download an ISO and flash it. Not a lot of people know about Ventoy, they would be stuck with a non persistence backup media.
- nyuszika7h 5y agoPersistence isn't anything new or revolutionary. Rufus and other tools have supported persistence with ISOs just fine for ages. Ventoy may support persistence too, but its main selling point is being able to put multiple ISOs and whatever other files you want on the USB.
- nsonha 5y agoHaving usable free space on the drive is not the same as having persistence on the live OS. You still have to manually copy files from the RAM disk to your drive. I think Ventoy even supports actual persistence but its not the same as getting it by simply flashing an image.
- nyuszika7h 5y agoIt depends on your use case. The author first goes on talking generally about the rest of the drive being unusable, and only then mentions persistence. But Ventoy supports both, so either way the point is moot.
- nsonha 5y ago