3 ms·
Not disagreeing with what Thiel is saying here, but it's pretty hypocritical for him to be criticizing here considering he's the co-founder of Palantir, a compa
by kelnos 5y ago
Not disagreeing with what Thiel is saying here, but it's pretty hypocritical for him to be criticizing here considering he's the co-founder of Palantir, a company that feeds some tasty tasty morsels to the surveillance state and military-industrial complex.
- gonehome 5y agoI can’t go into it, but this is a misunderstanding of what Palantir does.
- wolverine876 5y agoI can't go into it, but ...
- brandall10 5y agoIt seems he's drawing a distinction at domestic vs. foreign actors. The criticism at Google here is against working to enable the US military vs. what is a thin veil of enabling the Chinese military hiding behind a veil.
- gonehome 5y agoIt’s also about a defense of the west and western liberalism over China and the CCP authoritarianism. It’s Google leadership capitulating to the (imo naive) politics of its workforce to not work with the USG, while continuing to support the governments of adversaries (because largely American politics ignores the plight of people in places like KSA and China under a weak kind of moral relativism).
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoPointing out someone else's hypocrisy isn't an inconsistency. If someone says doing business with a military is unacceptable and then proceeds to do business with a military, they're a hypocrite. That's still true even if the person telling you this does business with a military.
- Eelongate 5y ago> "If someone says doing business with a military is unacceptable" Thiel hasn't even done that. His position seems to be that American companies should work with the US Military, but shouldn't work with the Chinese military. Such a position is certainly partisan, but it isn't hypocritical.
- smithza 5y ago> Such a position is certainly partisan Try patriotic, or more cynically nationalistic.
- Eelongate 5y agoPartisan fits. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/partisan https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/partisan 1. An adherent to a party or faction. 2. A fervent, sometimes militant, supporter or proponent of a party, cause, faction, person, or idea. Maybe that word isn't judgemental enough for you, but it fits and I used it carefully.
- robotresearcher 5y agoBoth of these are instances of partisanship.
- CountSessine 5y agoIs it hypocritical to work with the US military, and not the Chinese military?
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoIs your justification for not working with the Chinese military that working with a military is unacceptable?
- CountSessine 5y agoClearly it isn't Peter Thiel's justification. So kelnos is wrong in calling this hypocrisy.
- philwelch 5y agoIt’s only hypocritical if you find the American and Chinese governments morally equivalent.
- simonh 5y agoThiel seems to genuinely believe the USA, and the west in general, is in an existential struggle with forces intent on destroying it. I can’t speak for him, but maybe Islamic fundamentalists, authoritarian autocracies like Russia, Chinese communism, etc. If you genuinely believe that, then putting ever more powerful intelligence gathering tools in the hands of western governments, even at some risk of threats to freedoms in the west, might seem reasonable. That’s especially true if you have good confidence in the checks and balances in the free west to prevent the worst abuses of such tools, and that the threats are truly dire.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Thiel seems to genuinely believe the USA, and the west in general, is in an existential struggle with forces intent on destroying it. As much as I dislike Thiel, he does have a point there: Russia is actively funding misinformation campaigns with the aim of splintering Europe (e.g. by funding far-right political parties like the AfD in Germany or the Brexiteers in the UK), and China is a threat on a geo-political level (New Belt Road) as well as a military threat (e.g. Taiwan), not to mention their Third Reich-inspired genocide against the Uyghurs and Tibetans. The world is in a "war of cultures" indeed - the remnants of the Western democracies versus strong authoritarian governments. And we haven't found a way to counter Russian or Chinese political ambitions yet. > That’s especially true if you have good confidence in the checks and balances in the free west to prevent the worst abuses of such tools, and that the threats are truly dire. Under normal circumstances, that confidence would be valid. Unfortunately, we have our own actors who have an interest in tearing down these "checks and balances" for their own gains (e.g. the Republicans systematically destroying trust in public institutions, from elections to the integrity of the FBI, or Poland and Hungary where the rulers want to stay in power and enrich themselves and their friends)... which means we as Western nations are in a "lose-lose" situation. We can't combat propaganda effectively for a variety of reasons, and as a result of that the propaganda tears down our societies.
- microtherion 5y ago> Thiel seems to genuinely believe the USA, and the west in general, is in an existential struggle with forces intent on destroying it. I can’t speak for him, but maybe Islamic fundamentalists, authoritarian autocracies like Russia, Chinese communism, etc. I believe such a struggle exists as well. But I have my doubts whether one would find him fighting AGAINST the authoritarians.
- xyzzyz 5y agoIt is no more hypocritical than US government supporting US military, and opposing Chinese military. Thiel is just on team USA, that’s all.
- notJim 5y agoHe's not opposed to the surveillance state or military-industrial complex (in fact, he's in favor of them in the US), he's opposed to China's government.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoHe's not against national and state power; rumors or accusations of him being a libertarian are greatly exaggerated, for sure. He's just pro-Western civilization and pro-US.