3 ms·
> I have my doubts that a small drone carries enough firepower to damage a carrier. There's a reason why these cruise missiles carry 1000lbs of high-explosives
by littlestymaar 5y ago
> I have my doubts that a small drone carries enough firepower to damage a carrier. There's a reason why these cruise missiles carry 1000lbs of high-explosives (per missile), and no one seriously expects just one missile to sink a carrier.
Carriers are notoriously difficult to sink. But there's a well known strategy: 1) you destroy the carriers defence, 2) you target the direction (not the propulsion) of the carrier so it cannot flee 3) you send a shit ton of whatever you have to sink it.
Drones are obviously unable to do 3), but they are completely apt for 1 and 2. Small boats controlled remotely (which are drones, as a matter of fact) loaded with TNT would do the job eventually when all defences are lost. And even if 3) never happens because the Navy still manages to prevent those small boats from approaching (this is pretty likely, with air support), CNN looping on live footage of USS Gerald R. Ford stuck sailing in circle in the Gulf of Aden after a drone attack would be pretty humiliating for the US Navy to say the least.
Also, as I said earlier, cruse missiles are awesome against ships, and it is a well know fact nobody discusses. Nowhere in this thread am I arguing that drones are superior to cruise missiles. The question is: can a state with limited cruse missile capability piss the US Navy off with drones, and I'm convinced the answer is a big yes.
The US army would likely not taking a single casualty from a single cruise missile targetting air carrier convoy. But they are much less prepared against few hundred drones swarming upon them.
- dragontamer 5y agoThe carriers are steered by a 50-ton rudder made out of solid steel. How many drones do you think it will take to break and/or significantly damage that rudder? ------- You're avoiding the hard question. How many lbs of explosive do these drones carry. 100lbs of explosives? 500lbs? 1000lbs? These war machines are measured in the hundreds-and-hundreds of lbs of explosives it takes to deal serious damage. Its not going to be a cheap drone that can steer / move agile while carrying an explosive payload of that weight. That's why we use missiles: because rocket engines have a superior thrust-to-weight ratio. Quadcopters cannot carry 100lbs of explosive, let alone 500lbs or 1000lbs. Not cheap quadcopters anyway.
- littlestymaar 5y agoSo after attacking the “Drones are better than cruise missile” argument that I never held, you are now aiming at the “quadcopters” I've never talked about? I'm gonna end this discussion here because I've made my points and you look way too determined to fight against straw men than discussing them.
- dragontamer 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29474199 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29474199 Look, this is the root of this thread. > I've no doubt a modern warship can shoot down a lot of drones, but at a few thousand bucks a pop, an adversary can field a lot of drones. "A few thousand bucks a pop" per drone sounds like a quadcopter drone to me. That's not a jet-drone or a rocket-drone. Now if you are saying that a bunch of Predator drones shooting a bunch of missiles at a carrier can probably disable it... well... sure. I can agree to that. That probably will work. But such a drone will be rather expensive, and you wouldn't want those drones shot down by a CIWS.