5 ms·
Seems to lay the blame very squarely with The Guardian. You can read the Guardian's rebuttal here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/sep/01/unredacted-us-e
by peteretep 15y ago
Seems to lay the blame very squarely with The Guardian.
You can read the Guardian's rebuttal here:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/sep/01/unredacted-us-embassy-cables-online http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/sep/01/unredacted-us-em...
Guardian's quote:
"Our book about WikiLeaks was published last February. It contained a password, but no details of the location of the files, and we were told it was a temporary password which would expire and be deleted in a matter of hours.
"It was a meaningless piece of information to anyone except the person(s) who created the database.
"No concerns were expressed when the book was published and if anyone at WikiLeaks had thought this compromised security they have had seven months to remove the files. That they didn't do so clearly shows the problem was not caused by the Guardian's book."
- schrototo 15y ago> "No concerns were expressed when the book was published and if anyone at WikiLeaks had thought this compromised security they have had seven months to remove the files. That they didn't do so clearly shows the problem was not caused by the Guardian's book." That's a pretty bullshit excuse. Wasn't the insurance file on PirateBay? How exactly should they have removed that once it was out there?
- peteretep 15y agoFrom what I've read, I've been given the idea that the files transferred to The Guardian were encrypted for them only - that the password they had worked against that file alone. Presumably (hopefully?) the insurance file uses a different password. I was also under the (perhaps wrong) impression that no-one actually knows what's in the insurance file.
- schrototo 15y agoI can't imagine the insurance file being little more than the full uncensored cable archive. What else could it be? If Wikileaks had a gigabyte of compromising information on the US government or some other powerful entity, surely they would release it? Isn't that their stated mission?
- cookiecaper 15y agoWikileaks has demonstrated a propensity to keep things close to chest. Perhaps the insurance file contains private documents not yet released that are personally embarrassing to important individuals (e.g., those likely to be involved in the extradition and/or untimely demise of Assange) but not particularly relevant from a national standpoint. Not sure, but I definitely don't think that the cables are the only potential information contained in the insurance file. Wikileaks, especially after their bout of airtime last winter, got a lot of data from a lot of different sources. There's a lot of stuff there to collate.
- TheCapn 15y agoFrom what I gather it sounds like they're trying to redact important info from cables prior to release so they don't get their asses burned any more than they have. They've got a collection of cables they haven't yet processed and are now being leaked.
- guelo 15y agoThe details are confusing but apparently it wasn't the insurance file, it was the full cables archive which for some unexplained reason was being served over bittorrent by someone.
- a3_nm 15y agoI read the book in question. A password to an encrypted file is given at some point, but it is presented as a one-time thing to transfer a specific private file. If Wikileaks reused this password for something else, then it's pretty stupid of them.
- RuadhanMc 15y agoSomeone, somewhere, screwed up. It's quite odd. Certainly Assange is quite technically savvy -- he's a reformed (genuine) hacker -- after all. So I just can't imagine him re-using passwords. Similarly, I would have thought that he'd be enough of a control freak to, you know, check this stuff out himself.
- jarin 15y agoTo be fair, he may not be sitting around running port scanners and wardialers anymore, but I'd hardly call him reformed.
- xtracto 15y agoWhat does it mean to be a "reformed hacker" anyway? Does it mean that he does not black-hat hack anymore? Or that he does not "hack"? How do we know he does not "hack"? maybe he doesn't do it publicly but he still "hacks" to his OSX/Linux box.
- RuadhanMc 15y agoWell in the 80's and 90's when Assange did the illegal hacking, that we're aware of, hackers weren't what we call hackers today. So a reformed hacker in my books is someone who no longer illegally hacks into property that is not theirs. In "Hacker News" existed a decade+ ago then it would have been filled with black-hats.
- indrax 15y agoHack is orthogonal to legal. Hack is orthogonal to personal gain.
- jarofgreen 15y agohttp://www.abc.net.au/technology/articles/2011/09/01/3307488.htm http://www.abc.net.au/technology/articles/2011/09/01/3307488... says "According to Der Spiegel: At the end of 2010, Domscheit-Berg [former worker at Wikileaks and founder of rival, OpenLeaks] finally returned to WikiLeaks a collection of various files that he had taken with him, including the encrypted cables. Shortly afterwards, WikiLeaks supporters released a copy of this data collection onto the Internet as a kind of public archive of the documents that WikiLeaks had previously published. The supporters clearly did not realize, however, that the data contained the original cables, as the file was not only encrypted but concealed in a hidden subdirectory." So The Guardian deliberately leaked the password and Wikileaks accidentally leaked the file. Personally, I think both sound like pretty stupid things to do ...
- sp332 15y agoRumor points to Daniel Domscheit-Berg, the OpenLeaks guy. http://pastebin.com/SBq9Xpsr http://pastebin.com/SBq9Xpsr
- panarky 15y agoThe password is publicly accessible using Amazon's "search inside" feature - see http://i.imgur.com/9euXr.png http://i.imgur.com/9euXr.png