3 ms·
Once the US had railroad companies that laid rail at a mile per day (mostly crap rail, but enough to count), that was when the incentives were all aligned, and
by mikewarot 5y ago
Once the US had railroad companies that laid rail at a mile per day (mostly crap rail, but enough to count), that was when the incentives were all aligned, and a huge amount of resources were mobilized and ready to deploy.
Once the US pulled of the completely absurd task of putting a man on the moon and then returning him safely to earth, in less than a decade. All the incentives were aligned, it had public support, and a huge amount of resources were mobilized and ready to deploy.
We're not deploying huge resources on our infrastructure projects, we're piecemealing them. I've got a branch rail line going in at the end of my street. [1] The public input/planning process went on for years, and only now are they starting to relocate utilities, put up fences, etc. There's no one entity in charge of all the layers of the project, it's all hired contractors and inter-agency cooperation. It will be done, likely in 3 years or so. This line is a total of about 9 miles long for about $945 Million.
The worst part about it for me is the insidious nature of the funding they're using. They're doing "Tax Increment Financing" which means that any increase in property tax revenues theoretically caused by the "improvement" of my house go to pay off the construction bonds.
Let's say there is NO improvement, but inflation doubles taxes in the next decade. The town now gets the same dollar amount, but half of the funding it used to get, and the rest goes to the bond holders. This will strangle our schools which depend on local real estate taxes.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Lake_Corridor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Lake_Corridor
PS: Just across the state line is a defunct Country Club, which is in close enough to the station to qualify for "TIF" improvements, and the husband of the local State Representative pushing for the project, just happens to be the a real estate developer interested in said property.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- OldHand2018 5y agoAnd don't you just love that the trains they'll be running will consist of end-of-life Metra coaches that they're paying to have refurbished? https://www.chicagotribune.com/suburbs/post-tribune/ct-ptb-nictd-meet-double-track-st-0126-20210125-vslmopf7j5f55pkx3uiedgoecm-story.html https://www.chicagotribune.com/suburbs/post-tribune/ct-ptb-n... These are the new Metra coaches, BTW: https://chi.streetsblog.org/2021/01/13/metra-board-chooses-new-modern-passenger-rail-cars-to-replace-1950s-gallery-cars/ https://chi.streetsblog.org/2021/01/13/metra-board-chooses-n...
- caeril 5y ago> pulled of the completely absurd task of putting a man on the moon and then returning him safely to earth, in less than a decade At a congressional allocation level, this was all pork, too. The vast majority of this project went to politically-connected contractors, subcontractors, etc. Not much has changed, except for one critical factor: We were competent in the 20th century. All of the engineers, machinists, metallurgists, and yes, even management of the Apollo project had a job to do. Their personal political opinions, sexual proclivities, or social media clout had nothing at all to do with accomplishing the mission. And so, it got done. We're not that people anymore.
- zdragnar 5y agoPutting a man on the moon was relatively simple in comparison, actually. All the resources focused down to a single task, a single vessel, and a single mission. In comparison, there are countless jurisdictions and hundreds of millions of lives being effected, plus well established property lines that need to be redrawn all over the place. I'm not saying I approve of how much it costs to do reasonable infrastructure related projects at all, but the meme of "things were so much better back then" has never not been old.
- mikewarot 5y agoAt its peak, the Apollo program employed 400,000 people and required the support of over 20,000 industrial firms and universities.
- zdragnar 5y agoPurchasing goods and services from companies and universities who seek to be a part of the program is, logistically, a hell of a lot easier than buying millions of property rights across thousands of different municipalities from people who don't want to be displaced for what would likely be below market value.