6 ms·
I was just thinking this morning that Intel segments their market by the class of person that is their customer. "You're a consumer, you don't need error corre
by jiggawatts 5y ago
I was just thinking this morning that Intel segments their market by the class of person that is their customer.
"You're a consumer, you don't need error correcting memory! Only the upper class, I mean... your superiors... err.. sorry, enterprise customers need that feature. It's reserved for them, it is not for the likes of you."
Meanwhile AMD basically sells silicon by unit area. It's like buying gelato at the ice cream shop. You can ask for one scoop, two scoops, or three. You get to decide how hungry you are, that's it. There isn't a flavour with broken glass in it[1] served only to the working class stiffs, and with the glass-free gelato reserved only for the gentry.
[1] This is pretty much what a CPU without ECC is. It randomly crashes and corrupts your data. Look. Not every bite of ice cream has glass in it! There's very little glass in the ice cream. It's super rare, and Intel Pty Ltd tells you that this is an acceptable amount of risk for you to take, because you aren't as important as other people.
- woah 5y agoIntel's cost is designing the circuits and the means to etch them, not buying the sand.
- my123 5y ago> and Intel Pty Ltd tells you that this is an acceptable amount of risk for you to take AMD does the same thing too. Ryzen APUs don't have (even unofficial) ECC support, except if you pony up for a Ryzen Pro one. (and so do many other SoC providers...)
- StillBored 5y agoOfficial support, doesn't mean it doesn't work. Although your right AMD does a bit of product segmentation here/there. The laptop space while considerably simpler is not only segmented by core count, but threading, and TDP. I've been expecting them to just simplify to a core count/memory channel/socket matrix for a while because they are so close. There really isn't any reason these days to segment by frequency beyond maybe a couple golden parts where all the cores run at the peak frequency.
- my123 5y ago> Official support, doesn't mean it doesn't work For Ryzen CPUs (ones without an iGPU), they don't fuse it off, and as such it can unofficially work. For Ryzen APUs (parts with an iGPU), they fuse it off, and as such it will never work there.
- kllrnohj 5y agoSlightly different in the AMD case as the Ryzen Pro are the same socket and not really much more expensive (eg, https://www.amazon.com/Ryzen-4750G-Processor-3-6Ghz-Threads/dp/B08XYTM5QS https://www.amazon.com/Ryzen-4750G-Processor-3-6Ghz-Threads/... ). So as a consumer you can make a fairly straightforward value prop tradeoff there. Well, you could except AMD throws in the complication that they no longer sell APUs directly to consumers, not officially anyway. These are all technically "OEM only" parts.
- Dasateam 5y ago5600G and 5700G are sold directly to consumers, the Pro variants aren't. Only the 4000G series was completely OEM-only for some reason.
- defaultname 5y ago"I was just thinking this morning that Intel segments their market by the class of person that is their customer." Just about every company in the world that sells things (including AMD) engages in market segmentation. A classic - https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-duckies/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-... It has nothing to do with the "class of person" -- that whole notion seems pejorative in this context -- but maximizing how much you can extract in the aggregate. In the case of Intel, for years (decades?) they were their own primary competitor. They wanted to be sure that for a given customer they could extract the maximum amount possible, and they did this by gating some features (ECC, AVX, etc) to try to avoid business customers deciding to get by on "lesser" processors. And the simple truth is that the overwhelming bulk of consumer products will never, ever have an ECC relevant error event, which is how businesses managed to get by without it.
- charcircuit 5y ago>It randomly crashes and corrupts your data My PC doesn't have ECC memory and it isn't crashing and corrupting my data. I think you are vastly over exaggerating.
- squarefoot 5y agoNot that it happens frequently, but if it does and your application scenario is critical, how do one knows if say the corrupted data is a minor color component in an image or frame of a movie, or a variable in a spreadsheet cell buried somewhere? Would anyone notice? If a bitflip happened in a location containing the target address of a jump then the software or the OS would likely bomb immediately telling there's something wrong somewhere, but (unfortunately) there are subtle errors that can go unnoticed until it's too late. ECC is meant to protect also from those.
- StillBored 5y agoA long while ago, I worked on part of a memory system that during development we knew was corrupting RAM. The amazing thing, is just how high the error rates could get before the machine would actually crash. That is largely because so much of RAM is code that doesn't get executed and data structures that are resistant to random corruption. Even actual dat corruption when it happens is frequently subtle because it flips a transaction timestamp by one digit in the midst of millions of transactions/etc, or the data is transient a video frame with a miscolored pixel, etc. Its really like playing Russian roulette with a revolver that has a few (b/m)illion chambers. Generally by the time you see actual program crashes or notice data corruption your system is really good and screwed. That is part of why people in the know are so afraid of RAM corruption. It can be persisted and exist silently for a very long time before someone tries reading some file/transaction that was corrupted during a write years back, or the database suddenly starts crashing after it updates some index as part of a GC pass/whatever, while the actual bug/HW failure will never be reproduced.
- charcircuit 5y agoI've had my own experience with a bad stick of RAM, but that just caused Firefox to crash.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> This is pretty much what a CPU without ECC is. It randomly crashes and corrupts your data. I use ECC RAM in systems with error counters. Error correction is an extremely rare event, if it happens at all. This idea that non-ECC computers are crashing all the time due to memory errors isn’t true. I've also had unstable systems with ECC RAM and no error correction events, so it's not a magic bullet. You can run something like memtest86 for days on end. You shouldn’t see any errors at all, unless your memory is bad. The reality is that the average consumer doesn’t really want to pay the extra amount for ECC RAM. As you said, ECC has been available on AMD consumer platforms for a long time and there’s barely any uptake outside of people building servers and workstations with consumer-grade AMD CPUs. The AMD (Consumer) ECC story isn’t perfect, either. It’s not officially supported so there’s a lot of debate around whether or not it’s actually working on certain consumer motherboards. It’s definitely not equivalent to the official ECC support of their higher-end parts. Intel, on the other hand, actually did roll out a lot of i3 processors with full, official ECC support. These are (or were) a favorite for low-cost servers for this reason. It worked well and the support was great.
- lambdaba 5y agoAs someone who has been aware of ECC RAM for a long time could you briefly explain a concrete case where that is useful? Like, in all my time using computers I don't think I've yet encountered an error caused by RAM, or.. Did I?
- jiggawatts 5y agoYou probably didn't even realise it was a memory error. A lot of the instability of Windows can be attributed to the use of non-ECC memory in typical home PCs. Linux tends to run on servers with ECC memory, so at least some of the perspective of it being "more stable" comes from this anecdotal evidence. The parent comment saying that they never see ECC errors in the wild is missing a few things: - Server memory tends to be clocked lower than consumer memory, so errors are less frequent to begin with. - The errors are not evenly distributed. Some memory sticks have a high error rate, others are virtually zero. There's batch-to-batch variations. - I've done my own tests on hundreds of servers. We run burn-in tests for about 24-48 hours. About 95% have zero errors of any kind, but 5% have a high enough rate that putting them into production would be a mistake. ECC allows us to catch those bit errors instead of silently accepting them and allowing data corruption to creep in. - I've personally had 3 different personal computers experience high memory error rates, to the point of multiple BSODs per day and data corruption. They all started off "good" and slowly turned "bad". The only reason I knew to look for memory corruption as the root cause is because of my extensive industry experience. A grandma using the same PC would have just blamed Windows for being unstable. - Vendors like Microsoft simply ignore all crash error reports sent back by telemetry with only 1 or 2 samples, because those are virtually guaranteed to be caused by memory corruption, not programmer error. I've done similar memory dump collection and found that easily 30% of all crashes were unique in this way, suggesting that ECC memory could improve PC stability significantly. - Suggesting that ECC memory is not needed because "good" memory doesn't need it and only "bad" memory is a problem is missing the point. All memory is bad, it's just that the bit error rates are different!
- ahupp 5y agoDo you think every price should be set according to marginal cost? Since the marginal cost of a chip is extremely low after you've paid for the fab and design costs, should those be free as well?
- snowwrestler 5y agoIn general you want to get more money from people who have more money. Everyone does this, including nonprofits and governments. There are lots of ways to wrap it up in things like value, status, or features and benefits, but ultimately that’s the basic goal.
- jayd16 5y agoSeems like a pretty heavy analogy for offering a cheaper SKU with a cut feature.