4 ms·
Warning: anecdotal evidence from a limited perspective. I did a biochem undergrad and was surrounded by premed students. Every single one of them was a North F
by echelon 5y ago
Warning: anecdotal evidence from a limited perspective.
I did a biochem undergrad and was surrounded by premed students. Every single one of them was a North Face-wearing, click-y, "there to get the grade" student. They didn't display the same kind of awe for the amazing biological processes we were learning about, and they certainly didn't put in any legwork into undergrad research projects. They weren't nerds. They wanted a job with prestige and money. Several of them were bullies that talked bad about us and were not fun to be around.
I spent my time thinking about human regenerative cloning, transfecting biochemical synthesis pathways into things, the metabolome, connectome, etc. They used flash cards and socialized and would quickly change the subject when talking about biology topics. The material didn't matter one bit to them.
Complex things were gamed even more. They spent their time memorizing o-chem reactions rather than following the electrons.
My experience led me to believe that there are doctors that are only after the title and wage. They're not domain material geeks like us. I just question how many are actually like that, because my school was loaded to the brim with these people.
- vkk8 5y agoExactly what I also wrote. The only people who are really good at any complex topic are huge geeks with some level of obsession for it. I've met plenty of programmers, mathematicians and even some finance people (those people work in trading) who are like that, but never a doctor.
- titanomachy 5y agoI've met internists who are like this. Encyclopedic knowledge of their field, excited about theory, obviously spending a lot more time on literature than they're strictly required to. It kind of makes sense that the "true nerds" would end up in these jobs, because specialized internists spend tons of extra time in training but make less money than "procedural" specialties (surgeons, mostly). The best family doctors I've met aren't mega-nerds but at least seem to genuinely care about helping people.
- tralarpa 5y agoThat's funny because something similar happened to a friend of mine. He was the only biochemist in a class that was mandatory for med students. It was about drugs and their (side) effects. The professor was so happy that there was at least one student in the room who could answer his (mostly rhetoric) "why" questions, while the other students were just memorizing.
- ianmcgowan 5y ago"like us". It seems like the developer field has its share of Brogrammers and other non-traditionally nerdy types. Speaking as a super-nerdy science geek, it's probably not all bad that the field has widened - along with the bro's you get more women, non-compsci, and people-of-color entering the field, if some of the gate-keeping is relaxed. There are MD/PhD doctors out there at the cutting edge, but most docs are more like PC repair techs - swap things out until the problem goes away, have a basic understanding of the underlying tech. You don't have to be a chip designer to swap a motherboard, or follow the electrons to prescribe some meds :-)
- maxerickson 5y agoHow many of them made it? Of the people I knew in college that wanted to go to medical school afterwords, like 1/8 of them actually got in. (I went to a good school, these were intelligent people)
- dotancohen 5y ago> My experience led me to believe that there are doctors that are only after the > title and wage. They're not domain material geeks like us. I just question how > many are actually like that, because my school was loaded to the brim with these people. There's a quick way to tell if a field is staffed _mostly_ by enthusiasts or mostly by money. Does the field have an active after-work topic community? There exist active lawyer forums, and the things they discuss might as well be philosophy for the depth of analysis they invest. Software forums by the ton. Nurses seem to have active forums, though I haven't really looked at them. Vehicle mechanics, musicians, agriculture, teachers, pilots, scientists, authors, truck drivers, engineers, even construction. I could go on. Which major top-dollar professions do not seem to be represented? Doctors, office administration, bankers. These are professions that seem to have very few enthusiasts working in the field. I'm sure they exist, but they are rare. I should go tell my physician how much I appreciate her. I have a good one.