4 ms·
Back in the 1990s you could buy a big IBM mainframe with 8 CPUs, and they'd ship you one with 16 CPUs and if you decided to upgrade later, they just sent a guy
by michaelt 5y ago
Back in the 1990s you could buy a big IBM mainframe with 8 CPUs, and they'd ship you one with 16 CPUs and if you decided to upgrade later, they just sent a guy to flip a secret switch.
This was never popular with the Free Software crowd, who believe in the principle that the owner of the hardware has the right to do whatever they like with it. They would say you have the right to flip the secret switch yourself.
This is the same idea, but updated for the 21st century. My laptop came with hardware support for virtual machines - In a few years time, perhaps features like hardware-accelerated virtual machine support will be separately licensed premium features, instead of being stock features.
Some companies already do this - for example, some Teslas have autopilot and long range batteries, but they're disabled in software. And if you buy a Tesla with those features second-hand, Tesla can disable them until you pay them.
- bee_rider 5y agoSo, free upgrades in a couple years when this inevitably gets broken in to?
- monocasa 5y agoI don't think it's inevitable that this'll be broken into. Public/private crypto in high end process nodes has a pretty good track record.
- RHSeeger 5y ago> And if you buy a Tesla with those features second-hand, Tesla can disable them until you pay them. Everything I've seen says this is not the case. As I understand it, the story in the news about "something like this" was misleading. The car went through a dealer and was sold certified pre-owned; and it was sold as not having those features. It turns out they forgot the disable those features. I you buy one from a third party that already paid for the feature, it stays with the car. At least, that's the understanding I was left with.
- DebtDeflation 5y ago> The car went through a dealer and was sold certified pre-owned; and it was sold as not having those features. Was the car sold to its original owner with those features enabled? If so, it's effectively the same as the original story reported, meaning that Tesla expected to be paid twice for the feature.
- RHSeeger 5y agoAs I understand it, - Car was sold to original owner, who enabled the features - Car was sold back to dealer/Tesla (presumably a trade-in?) - Car was sold to second owner, with information that it did not include the features - Turns out the car had the features enabled (they mistakenly forgot to turn them off) - Features remotely disabled There's nothing inherently wrong with Tesla charging both the original and second buyer for the features, as those features make the car worth more. Conceptually, its the same as paying more for a car with a better entertainment system, then the person who buys it next (from the dealer after you trade it in) pays more for it than they would for one without that system.
- detaro 5y agoIn the story that made the big splash, after > - Car was sold back to dealer/Tesla (presumably a trade-in?) a used-car dealer bought the car from Tesla and was given (legally required) documentation about the car, which indicated the car had the features. Then Tesla removed the features remotely while the car was owned by the dealer, without informing them (because they decided during an audit that it shouldn't have had them). The dealer then showed the documentation to the customer (as required) and sold the car, both sides in the understanding it had the features as documented (because why wouldn't it, if Tesla documented it as such). The final customer then found the features disabled (or being disabled on an update/sync).
- grishka 5y ago> if you decided to upgrade later, they just sent a guy to flip a secret switch So what prevented you from finding and flipping the secret switch yourself? Or is it that merely being a business you couldn't afford to take this risk and lose IBM support?
- tpetry 5y agoLawyers, an army of lawyers. You don't want to get letters from Oracle, IBM, Intel and Co. because you infringed some of their EULAs. They may be invalid, but it will be a very costly decade long court case. And the other part will pump thousands of times more money into it than you can afford, because when they loose they will loose a big income stream in the future.