7 ms·
>the folks who earned It's quaint that there are people out there who believe that income at the top strata of society is primarily earned. Those dividend pay
by pydry 5y ago
>the folks who earned
It's quaint that there are people out there who believe that income at the top strata of society is primarily earned.
Those dividend payments, rents and capital gains (realized) that make up the bulk of top earner incomes happen while they sleep.
A minimum wage is earned. A doctor's wage is earned. A golden parachute after a CEO ruins a company? Somebody with a trust fund? A person living off dividend income? Not so much.
It's one in a series of ways the .1% try to rhetorically conceal themselves. Another is that article the other day that complained about an overproduction of "elites" (referring to college degreed starbucks baristas).
- syshum 5y agoSo if I worked as a doctor for 20 years, invested most of my income in that 20 years in to dividend paying stocks, then at age 45 or so retire to live off my dividends that my hard work paid of, I did not earn any of that?
- pydry 5y agoA lot of people have retired on a large S&P nest egg, spent relatively frugally relative to their wealth and ended up even wealthier after 5 years. It's not that uncommon. How would you say that money used to support them and grow their wealth was "earned" if they didnt work? The truth is it was earned. Just not by them. It's glaringly obvious if you think about it for just one second but we maintain a polite fiction all the same.
- Werewolf255 5y agoI mean, no? In this specific example, the doctor is buying instruments which derive their interest from exploiting the labor and capital of those in the offering company, and after 20 years, the doctor is just living off others work because he 'earned it'. Plus, of course, in this perfect market scenario, no crashes or corrections can ever occur.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoSo say the doctor fronts someone money so they can invest in a business, say buying more garbage trucks for their garbage truck fleet or something. Surely the return on that is earned income? Throwing the money at your preferred wall street instrument of choice is the same thing but with half a million layers of abstraction and redirection all of which involve middle men who either take cuts or otherwise get paid for sorting and bundling, matchmaking, providing liquidity, etc, etc.
- pydry 5y ago>Surely the return on that is earned income? No. Why would it be? Those layers of abstraction cut out the risk such that in many cases cash is the riskier instrument.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>No. Why would it be? Because the doctor had to evaluate the investment opportunity and risk what they invested. >Those layers of abstraction cut out the risk And that's why you only make pennies on the dollar doing it that way vs the risky way of picking specific things with high growth potential to invest in.
- pydry 5y ago>Because the doctor had to evaluate the investment opportunity and risk what they invested. Unless it's the doctor's hobby somebody usually does this on the doctor's behalf in exchange for a %. This is one of the functions of a well oiled financial industry. If nobody was willing to do this for < expected rate of return then yes, that suggests all the money is earned. >And that's why you only make pennies on the dollar doing it Can you guess the average yearly S&P return over the last 30 years?
- FredPret 5y ago
- esarbe 5y ago> I did not earn any of that? >> A doctor's wage is earned. Your wage is earned. > invested most of my income in that 20 years in to dividend paying stocks Whether that one is 'earned' is debatable. From a neoliberal economists perspective you probably 'earned' it by risking your income. Although I always have to chuckle a bit of someone says that speculation is 'investment'. Investment is buying machinery, investment is specialization training of workers, investment is research and development. Playing roulette on the stock market is hardly 'investment'. From a moral perspective you probably didn't 'earn' it. You didn't work for it and - since you were able to put it aside for a later use - you didn't actually 'need' it. So from a moral and societal point of view, that money should have rather gone to pay for teachers wages, for infrastructure or anything else that was of immediate necessity. By investing in the stock market, it probably just went to some banker's bank account.
- syshum 5y agoAt its core companies sell stocks to buy machinery and other things to invest in their business. >>You didn't work for it and - since you were able to put it aside for a later use - you didn't actually 'need' it. So from a moral and societal point of view, that money should have rather gone to pay for teachers wages wow. just wow. So morally a person should only be paid what the need to live that is your honest position.. If so I certainly hope people that think like you never attain any real power
- esarbe 5y ago> wow. just wow. So morally a person should only be paid what the need to live Do you want me to hold that strawman while you give it a real good bashing? It can be satisfying, strawman bashing. It would however be more productive it you honestly tried to understand the argument I'm making. What do you think, do you want to give it a try? [0] > If so I certainly hope people that think like you never attain any real power Well, don't worry. The con-artists, faudsters and moochers from the swamp have everything under control and from what I see the populace-at-large is not interested in mitigating the pain and suffering and damage that crony-capitalism is brought upon us in or in correcting the course towards societal collapse which that entails. The hucksters meanwhile will continue to squeeze every last dollar of profit everyone else while their bought-and-paid-for politicians make sure that nurses and teachers and - well, everyone else, there a theme for you - pays a higher share of their income in taxes than their masters, while they themselves gorge on the ill-gotten gains their corruption, leaving behind the soiled and despoiled corpses of land and people. The only alternative is raising taxes, the horror. But hey, all power to you. [0] https://constantrenewal.com/steel-man/ https://constantrenewal.com/steel-man/
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoWorse - those dividends are primarily "earned" by interest rates being lowered.
- esarbe 5y agoThe frustrating thing is that this kind of rhetoric actually works. They call themselves "the makers" and "job creators" while all they are doing is leveraging their upbringing in a wealthy social environment that provided them with the necessary connections to get a comfy job. Their actual added value is minimal, but they sell it so good that (almost) everyone actually believes the myth. Sad.
- pydry 5y agoIt's a natural function of a parasite to trick the host into thinking it is necessary. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/141031-zombies-parasites-animals-science-halloween https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/141031-zo...
- esarbe 5y agoThat's probably a good part of it, yes.
- foverzar 5y agoI think your logic is flawed in the part where you consider "added value". Obviously, managers never actually "add" value. All they do is organize, so that value can be generated in the first place. And obviously they are the ones who gain the most profit if succeed and loose the most if not. Anyone can verify it by founding a startup, but surprisingly people prefer comfy jobs. Try organizing something and it will be immediately evident how hard it is to actually make people work effectively towards the same goal. I have actually left a position of a team lead in favor of a linear software development job -- it's just SOOOOOO much simpler and less nervous than any kind of organizational stuff.
- UncleMeat 5y agoA manager is a laborer like any other. A CEO being paid a wage is not bad. They are doing labor too. The problem is when people are obtaining a large amount of their wealth through means other than labor.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]