3 ms·
I’m sure someone would shed a tear for you. Think of how productive thousands of people would be if they weren’t staring down at death or disability daily beca
by Spooky23 5y ago
I’m sure someone would shed a tear for you.
Think of how productive thousands of people would be if they weren’t staring down at death or disability daily because some ambitious motherfucker decided to make a cheap commodity like insulin a monopolized product, essential for life at a usurious price.
- syshum 5y agoI find this example very ironic, given that the reason an " ambitious motherfucker " can take a cheap commodity like insulin and make it a monopolized product is directly a result of government regulations. The very same government you want to take everyone money and believe will spend it wisely
- Werewolf255 5y agoI mean, you act like businesses are gonna spend the money better and not just pump up shareholder earnings... You know, like they do every time? This line of argument seems suspiciously pro-capital, like, are you personally benefiting from government disfunction?
- FredPret 5y agoYou can argue the point but when you say > This line of argument seems suspiciously pro-capital it seems like you think only one side has any moral contribution to make. This isn’t Russia in the 1920’s
- syshum 5y agoIt is pro-capitalism... I am pro-capitalism. I think capitalism is awesome Sure business will do what they can to pump shareholder earning, the check on that is market competition. In this instance various government regulations , and laws prohibit or limit that competition that would emerge in a freerer market Insulin in particular was part of a EO package that was going to open up competition (and lower prices), the EO package was rescinded by Biden
- Spooky23 5y agoThat’s a specious argument. If the problem is that people are frequently running a red light, the root cause isn’t the fact that a traffic light exists.
- syshum 5y agoThat would depend on where you put the traffic light, and the operational state of the light... an Unneeded, nonoperational light (which alot of regulations are) would be the root cause
- jpadkins 5y agoWhat do you think about the Biden Admin rescinding the insulin pricing rules? https://www.policymed.com/2021/10/biden-administration-rescinds-trump-administration-insulin-pricing-rule.html https://www.policymed.com/2021/10/biden-administration-resci...
- Spooky23 5y agoI think it’s a pragmatic, tactical approach that eases human suffering, but rewards the villain with billions of taxpayer and insurance ratepayer dollars. The reality is that the GOP would vote against the sun coming up in the morning if Biden suggested it were a good idea. Such is politics.
- nrdvana 5y agoThink of how dead they would be if the insulin didn't exist. The part of the topic of insulin relevant to a discussion of trickle down economics is whether the insulin could have been researched and invented without letting people become wealthy profiting off of it. The monopoly on insulin that happened recently is one of the evil tendencies of capitalism that needs curtailed with laws, but unrelated to supply-side economics. In the case of insulin, it was in fact invented with nothing more than research grants and the promise of fame and nobel prizes. But it also took 30 years from the first hints of what might solve diabetes until they produced a drug for it. It's an open question whether that could have happened faster with a profit-motivated company pushing the research.
- Spooky23 5y agoI think insulin is yet another great example of why trickle down theories are bunk. Our economic policy for decades has been mostly centered around pumping capital into markets to prop them up or grow them. The problem is there’s too much money pursuing too little novel work. Ironically, making billions of “surplus” dollars available to big companies drives lots of little command economies, not healthy markets. It makes more sense to corner the market on insulin or some foot fungus cream and rip people off than to create a new or improved product. There is very low R&D at improving anything associated with insulin because of rent seeking behaviors. Profits don’t motivate research. Market activity does. I hope we learn from the successful aspects of COVID and pump money at people to make economic decisions for themselves.
- coredog64 5y agoAs I noted upthread, the expensive insulin is a new and improved product that was generated via R&D.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>because some ambitious motherfucker decided to make a cheap commodity like insulin a monopolized product You're talking about the legislators and the bureaucrats, right? Sure, the lobbyists asked them too but you'd think professionals would be a little more responsible than to just do what the lobbyists ask (yes I know they only did so incrementally over a decades long time period but my point stands). This stuff is only a monopoly because we've made it so slow and money consuming to break into these industries that there is not a steady enough flow of new entrants who undercut incumbents and drive costs down to actually keep the costs down.
- coredog64 5y agoAt best this is a misunderstanding of the situation with insulin. Insulin is cheap. Like $25/vial cheap without insurance or even a prescription at Walmart. However, as any diabetic (or anyone who has a loved one who is diabetic) will tell you, cheap insulin sucks. And so capitalist pharmaceutical companies came in, invested in R&D, and created new formulations of insulin that work better. And they're charging more to recover their investment. And when it goes off patent (and if the ass-covering shitheads at the FDA don't fuck it up), those new formulations will eventually be the same $25 at Walmart.
- hairofadog 5y agoAsking out of genuine curiosity: how does cheap insulin suck?
- alfor 5y agoThat is the problem. High regulations that create a quasi-monopoly on products Who make that regulations? The government. The government is just a huge corporation without competition that can use violence legally on people. At each place where the cost of service and product have gone up you will find regulations and monopolistic entreprises who are way too much connected to the government.
- pydry 5y agoCollusion largely drove the price of insulin up, not regulation. There are regulations against price collusion but they are not enforced.