22 ms·
The Theranos Trial Shows Why We Should Be Suspicious of Nuclear Fusion
- Fricken 5y agoWith Theranos it was understood by those qualified to know better that the proposed technology was impossible, well before she was able to round up bajillions in venture capital. Holmes was rejected by all the big SV VC firms (excepting the initial DFJ money), and she was rejected by all the life sciences VC firms. They did their due diligence. I don't hear nuclear physicists making similar dismissals about fusion.
- brudgers 5y agoLikewise alchemists were all in on the philosopher's stones.
- gus_massa 5y ago> But if we’ve learned anything from the Theranos debacle it’s that that we can’t take any company’s claim at face value ... Was this not obvious even before?! > We now realize that media credulity helped build Theranos’ fortunes. I agree. The problem is that many journalist are just cut&pasting the PR from the universities or companies, and in some cases adding even more errors. In many cases, I try to write here a comment explain the error(s) in the article. (Usually about FTL travel or Chemistry.) The Theranos business was too far from my specialty to write something useful, but IIRC there were many skeptical comments here. About fusion: I agree that many timelines are very optimistic and unrealistic. I realy dislike when the article has a paragraph about the new technology and then 10 pages about all the amazing changes in society that fusion will enable.