5 ms·
> you've avoided the counter-battery issue in your response, and it's a bit unfortunate as the biggest issue with missiles is “how do you protect the missile la
by dragontamer 5y ago
> you've avoided the counter-battery issue in your response, and it's a bit unfortunate as the biggest issue with missiles is “how do you protect the missile launcher from being taken down before they fire”
No, I haven't. My point is whatever launcher mechanism you have for your hypothetical drones has the exact same issue.
> Ideally, from scattered units operating with light vehicles (say, a pick-up with a trailer).
Yes. These are called MLRS when they're rockets or cruise missiles. If you think a cruise missile platform can be "counter-battery fired", then these light pickup trucks you're talking about have the same exact problem.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> My point is whatever launcher mechanism you have for your hypothetical drones has the exact same issue. Not exactly, even it shares some. First of all they are much less expensive, and you have much more of them, making them harder to destroy. They are actually likely to be cheapy than the cost of the missile used to shoot them, which is never the case with cruise missile platform). Then you don't need an open field to launch a drone, sending cruse missiles from dense urban area is more of a problem. And in any case I think you moving goalpost a bit here, since when talking about counter battery, I initially responded to your suggestion to put the MLRS lined up, in plain sight on a highway… Now if you told me you're going to put your MLRS in isolated barns in the countryside, then it's of course the same situation whether it's launching drones or missiles, the number being the only significant difference.
- dragontamer 5y ago> First of all they are much less expensive Rocket / Missile launchers are just a tube. The launcher itself isn't expensive, its the programmer and truck platform that costs money. > and you have much more of them, making them harder to destroy. The PLARF has plenty of missiles. We can't destroy all of them anymore. > They are actually likely to be cheapy than the cost of the missile used to shoot them Drones are so slow you wouldn't use a missile. You'd use a CIWS, a $30 bullet. Counter-missiles are extremely expensive, because the counter-missile needs to move faster and be more maneuverable than the original missile.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> Rocket / Missile launchers are just a tube. The launcher itself isn't expensive, its the programmer and truck platform that costs money. You must have forgotten the missiles in it… > The PLARF has plenty of missiles. We can't destroy all of them anymore. I don't know why you keep bringing China in this conversation, really. Drones have the power to make ships almost useless even against small army forces, the Millennium Challenge already proved that cruise missiles were very good against fleets. But deploying them efficiently against the US Navy would be a challenge for most army (but, as I said earlier, not China nor Russia). Drones could give the Houthis Yemeni faction the ability to sink a US carrier, and this isn't a good thing for the US Navy. > Drones are so slow you wouldn't use a missile. You'd use a CIWS, a $30 bullet. Their slow speed is actually a feature. It's really easy to make them have a completely unpredictable trajectory. Good luck shooting that with bullets. Also, because they are slow, they can also deploy some sorts of decoy to fool the aiming systems. Shrapnel is going to be extremely effective against them though, so it's completely possible to design dedicated defence mechanism, but hoping that a defence designed to stop ancient weapons against a new one isn't usually a good strategic move.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Drones could give the Houthis Yemeni faction the ability to sink a US carrier, and this isn't a good thing for the US Navy. Read up on the "USS America", a former Aircraft carrier built on 1960s technology and armor. As part of a retirement exercise, the USS America was subject to a number of bombs and explosions to test the armor of the old ship. So these drones you're talking about... how much explosives can they carry? Do remember: F18 regularly crash-and-burn on a carrier deck, with no real long-term damage to the carrier. I have my doubts that a small drone carries enough firepower to damage a carrier. There's a reason why these cruise missiles carry 1000lbs of high-explosives (*per missile*), and no one seriously expects just one missile to sink a carrier. EDIT: A more recent test was the Iranian 2015 public test: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/26/world/middleeast/in-mock-attack-iranian-navy-blasts-away-at-replica-us-aircraft-carrier.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/26/world/middleeast/in-mock-... Iran had to hit a fake aircraft carrier (a big boat they bought and dressed up to look like a carrier), and Iran was basically unable to sink it with just missiles. You need a lot of explosives to kill a boat of that size, let alone an armored / compartmentalized, well-studied, computer-simulated $13 Billion war-version. > It's really easy to make them have a completely unpredictable trajectory. Quadcopter motors aren't known for thrust. You know what is known for thrust? Rockets. Without thrust, you won't have an unpredictable trajectory. Rockets can push 2Gs laterally while traveling at 500mph and still end up on the target that they're aiming at. You ain't gonna get that kind of behavior from quadcopter drones. You just won't. ------- > I don't know why you keep bringing China in this conversation, really. Because I do think that China's strategy is a good one on face value. I hope that the US strategy is better, but I think the Chinese are making enough moves here that proves that they know what they're doing. EDIT: When you have a rocket that achieves 2G of thrust and hypersonic speeds, its not too difficult to use that thrust to start erratically dodging CIWS. In fact, that's the expectation: you need that amount of thrust to break the sound barrier anyway, so might as well put that rocket to good use dodging bullets.