4 ms·
That sounds like a retaining wall failure waiting to happen. Thin galvanized cages are providing short term structure, but they have relatively short lifespan
by Retric 5y ago
That sounds like a retaining wall failure waiting to happen. Thin galvanized cages are providing short term structure, but they have relatively short lifespan underground. Fine for knee high walls, but if your covering it with soil it’s not obvious these these things are going to become unstable.
- ethbr0 5y agoApparently the answer is "it depends on the soil chemistry." DURABILITY OF REINFORCED EARTH STRUCTURES: THE RESULTS OF A LONG-TERM STUDY CONDUCTED ON GALVANIZED STEEL. M DARBIN, JM JAILLOUX, J MONTUELLE, and ROMANOFF Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers 1988 84:5, 1029-1057 https://www.icevirtuallibrary.com/doi/abs/10.1680/iicep.1988.508 https://www.icevirtuallibrary.com/doi/abs/10.1680/iicep.1988... (pay article) Others here https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=galvanized+soil https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=galvanized+soil The following appear to be true: (1) HDG (or equivalent) has an order of magnitude greater resistance to corrosion in soil than uncoated steel, (2) corrosion rates are highly influenced by presence (or lack) of chlorides, sulfate, and citric acid in the soil, as well as temperature. Given the above, the suitability of galvanized steel in soil, at standard steel diameters and coating thicknesses, is either suitable (for low aggressivity soils) or non-suitable (for high aggressivity soils) over an example span of 20 years. Tl;dr: test and characterize the soil it's going to be in.
- gerdesj 5y agoI'm 51 years old. I built one to stop bank erosion in a stream at a change in level and direction at my parent's house about 30 years ago. All units are fine. They sit at least 1/3 height in water all the time and have soil/subsoil behind. They have a thin pour of mortar with gravel on top to make a path and have integrated into the bank and grass. Galvanized steel is surprisingly rust resistant and that's the key. These gabions do get quite a bashing when it rains hard. The stream in question is in Devon, Woodbury (Salterton), near Exeter (UK), which is popple land. Popples are rounded stones found in the streams thereabouts. They make ideal gabion fill. They also destroy things downstream if the flow is fast enough to rouse them! That's one case study that I've chosen deliberately to show that they work for DIY.