4 ms·
I think the difference is that Teamviewer/AnyDesk is intended mostly for corporate usage. Their software is optimised for images that are mostly static, letting
by jeroenhd 5y ago
I think the difference is that Teamviewer/AnyDesk is intended mostly for corporate usage. Their software is optimised for images that are mostly static, letting them get away with much less bandwidth without making text blurry or illegible. Standard H.264/H.265 encoded video needs sharpening and extra filters to be both low bandwidth and legible in many cases.
Parsec and friends use more bandwidth and hardware resources to get a stream going, but that stream is of much higher quality. You probably won't be running a fully-staffed remote support company over DSL or basic cable with Parsec, but with Teamviewer you just might. I've made several remote support connections at the same time on ≤8Mbps down on a simple Core i3, you just can't get that done with a game streaming solution like Parsec. Modern streaming services also require hardware encoding support or their CPU requirements are huge, and the endpoints support software often connect to isn't that powerful.
Microsoft's RDP solution in excellent on all fronts, though. Normal H.264 encoding for moving content and static-optimized codecs for office machines, all with heuristics to switch codecs on the fly. Sadly, this is all locked away behind licenses for consumer devices, but the technology is there.
- martinald 5y agoYes, RDP is mind blowingly good compared to VNC and most other tools for "office" applications. I'm fairly sure for non video/game content it just sends the "vectors" of the UI over which get rendered on your local machine instead of compressed bitmaps (I could be wrong on this though).
- acoard 5y agoYou're basically correct. RDP can model and transfer data semantically - i.e. it's not just pixels, but higher order objects like toolbars, buttons, and the like. VNC and most others just do raw image/video transfer, with whatever codecs and compression they choose. Of course, RDP can only use semantic data for apps that support it, and it makes sense these would be official MS apps first.
- gruez 5y ago>Microsoft's RDP solution in excellent on all fronts, though. Is it? Even on gigabit LAN there's a noticeable amount of latency. For web surfing it's mostly passable, but for text/code editing it's very annoying.
- jrace 5y agoThat has not been my experience, I regularly RDP to a workstation and code from there. We even ran our Dev machines in Azure over RDP/WAN. Only those on <30Mbps connections had noticable issues
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoi use rdp over zerotier and it works like magic. the "server" is having a 30mbps connection so i'm limited by that. still, the experience of over 15 concurrent users is not bad. i do excel, word, Libreoffice, firefox, heck employees even watch youtube on firefox over rdp and its "slightly" difficult to have it desync video and audio sometimes but it works. my only problem is getting rdpwrap to patch every 3-4 months. i run ltsc so i should be getting less updates but what do you know, it messes up and all hell breaks loose.
- stedaniels 5y agoJust to add to the anecdotes.. I regularly run RDP over VPNs and web gateways all over WiFi and only occasionally feel a little bit of lag, otherwise it's so fast I forget it's not my local device. I largely use CLI's, IDE's, Office, web browsing, and often tell myself off for watching YouTube videos over the RDP connection instead of locally.
- emteycz 5y agoHuh? Something must be seriously wrong with your network. I did everything via RDP (including watching movies) for years, over ADSL, with no issues whatsoever.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agowhy isn't there a free implementation similar to what microsoft does with rdp? i mean vnc is not it. terminal services. people are stuck with either paying microsoft/citrix or using rdpwrap