5 ms·
Elon Musk says civilization will crumble if more people don't have more children
- LinuxBender 5y ago"And yet, so many people, including smart people, think that there are too many people in the world and think that the population is growing out of control. It's completely the opposite. Please look at the numbers..." Is that really the only thing holding smart people back from having kids? Asking because this place is a decent representation of intelligent people in my opinion.
- v0iD7 5y agoElon is a joke nowadays. Seems that he is an EXPERT at everything!
- version_five 5y agoIt's funny you say that, I always found him overrated but have heard him say a lot more inciteful or at least funny stuff recently. After years of dismissing him I'm starting to become a fan.
- v0iD7 5y agoWeird how the stats were just of the US. Elsewhere in the world there are children being born at a high rate. Wonder if Elon would choose to address the main issue of Fertility in the Western World. Since more and more Men and Women are having difficulties conceiving. With the increasing costs of Fertility and IVF treatments citizens are finding it hard to come up with money to have children. Meanwhile the US and Canadian governments are not dealing with this problem. Perhaps leadership should start to address the problems that their citizens cannot have children and do something financially to assist families in need. Instead it seems that Canada is continuing to just fill the population with refugees and immigration.
- rogerkirkness 5y agoThis is the natural consequence of choosing to have kids late to focus on status from work.
- version_five 5y agoAgreed. The parent talks about IVF and fertility treatment, which I support. But I think it would be interesting to explore social programs that provide an easier path to having kids earlier, rather than just deal with the fallout of delaying it. I have no idea what this would look like, but it's a good conversation to have. How - in a way that doesn't provide the wrong incentives or penalize people who make different choices, can we remove the downside of having kids in say late twenties?
- quantified 5y agoOr a life. Lots of people have a life that’s not work.
- retrac 5y ago> Weird how the stats were just of the US. Elsewhere in the world there are children being born at a high rate. In pockets, yes, mostly in the world's poorest nations. But the global birthrate as a whole has been falling since the 1970s: https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/cpsprodpb/108A/production/_104243240_global_fertility_rates_gra640-nc.png https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/976/cpsprodpb/108A/production/... It is now only a bit above replacement. Even a conservative projection of the trend has us at a shrinking global population in a few decades. Also, if Nigeria's population quadruples and China's goes down by nearly half, on paper it looks approximately break-even. But that would hide a great deal going on there, in terms of economic, social and political consequences, for both countries, and the world.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI agree with everything you said but this: >Even a conservative projection of the trend has us at a shrinking global population in a few decades. I have not seen this in any of the projections. We are past peak fertility, and past peak births, but total population has a long lag time, as lifespans are long and increasing. The projections I have seen show total population peaking ~2100.
- shams93 5y agoThey call it Facebook because they don't allow us to talk about anything that goes on below the neck.
- poetically 5y agoWorld is projected to have 10B people by 2050 (I think). There are plenty of people. He should be more worried about the famines in Afghanistan and Madagascar if he cares so much about people.
- stevespang 5y ago[dead]
- quantified 5y agoYeah, all civilization needs to survive is about another 20 billion more, 10 billion of them on Mars and 10 billion more here to lead the life worth living. I thought any supply/demand believer would recognize we have more supply than ever, and the marginal need for any is less than ever before.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think population decline is a serious issue, but perhaps for different reasons than listed. The most significant are political instability and economic downturn. North America and Europe will become majority minority leading to much more divided politics. At the same time China will suffer economic stagnation with a huge elderly population to support. This will put them in a similar situation to Japan, but without Japan's level of development. Last, the countries that are projected to see large population growth (sub-Saharan Africa) are not on track to be able to support themselves and will likely be hit hard by climate change. Edit: As an interesting aside, it is worth noting that the world has already passed peak births/year and is now on the decline. The remaining gains between 8 billion now and 10 billion peak population will be made up by people living longer. This ultimately means fewer and fewer working aged individuals and more elderly to care for. Today, about 28% of the world is over 65. in 2100 it is projected to be ~40%
- quantified 5y agoWhen demands outstrip resources, historically we get depopulation by famine and war. Probably good to figure out living sustainably on a finite earth sooner than later.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoYou can also have resource shortages, famine, and war from an upside-down population pyramid. Like landing a plane, a controlled descent is more important than how fast you get to your destination.
- quantified 5y agoYes, 100%. Needs to be part of a social ethic, societal changes. Because there will still be competitive pressures, I’m not hopeful. Your social group says “we’ll glide down by X%” and my group will say “great, we’ll maintain or grow and in a generation we’ll dominate”. Often religiously driven (think competition imperatives in thr Middle East, or [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quiverfull https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quiverfull])