6 ms·
Hubble has been accomplished completely without SpaceX, as is James Webb and almost all other amazing advances in space. What do you think about the organizatio
by wolverine876 5y ago
Hubble has been accomplished completely without SpaceX, as is James Webb and almost all other amazing advances in space. What do you think about the organizations and people that actually accomplished these things?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Causality1 5y agoWith the retirement of the shuttle, Starship is the only vehicle in or near operation capable of bringing Hubble back to earth intact.
- wolverine876 5y agoLots of other capabilities are unique to lots of other systems (especially NASA - most of what they do is a unique capability!). What do you think of those?
- selectodude 5y agoSure, SpaceX doesn't have a Hubble Space Telescope in space and NASA doesn't have the capability to return it to Earth. I'm not sure where you're going with this.
- ChefboyOG 5y ago...they're also great? The parent comment was just that it would be cool to bring Hubble back eventually, and that Starship seems promising towards that end. It's not a diminishment of all other space-focused organizations.
- Causality1 5y agoI can't figure out what your point is. I'm saying Hubble is such an incredible achievement and pillar of the spirit of space exploration it's worth spending the money to bring it home even if doing so doesn't generate any scientific data in and of itself.
- irjustin 5y agoI wouldn't worry about it. Their point seems to dogmatically be "SpaceX bad" without open to reason. It's okay others have already agreed w/ you that no other launch vehicle in development has the ability to bring Hubble home intact.
- yabones 5y agoI think what GP is mostly referring to is that since the shuttle retired, we have no way to return payloads to the ground without "lithobraking". Starship may potentially have enough return capacity to place the Hubble telescope inside a payload bay and safely land it. No other vehicle being developed right now has that capability (that I'm aware of); it has nothing to do with the politics of NASA and Spacex.
- wolverine876 5y agoSo what? Lots of organizations deliver lots of unique capabilities. Hubble is actually up there, real things are happening, people have accomplished amazing things, yet again we hear SpaceX promoted - a hypothetical capability about a hypothetical need of dubious value.
- ramidarigaz 5y agoSure lots of organizations have unique capabilities, and SpaceX is one of those! Better to bring home Hubble than let it burn up once it's no longer operational. I definitely rate inspiration much higher than 'dubious' :)
- tobylane 5y agoWhy is that better? It sounds like a contract for no purpose, much like the previous companies deals that are the issue of comments upthread.
- wongarsu 5y agoMaybe the comment would have been better off just saying "Wouldn't it be great if at the end of it's life we could bring Hubble back to earth to put it in a museum". Because that's how I read it, it's something I completely support (just like putting ISS into a parking orbit instead of letting it burn up when that decision comes). Hubble is an important part of history and deserves to be preserved; to inspire current and future generations. Dragging a specific method of accomplishing that into it was kind of unnecessary from GP.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoNot the OP but are you talking about Lockheed, Rockwell, etc.? I think they're criminal arms traffickers and war profiteers who did achieve some amazing things, but only as a means to extract vast amounts of the nation's wealth. In other words, they did as little constructive work as they could with each tax dollar given to them. SpaceX at least doesn't appear to be building a business model based on being a barrel for pork with a board that functions as a pension fund for military generals.
- newbie789 5y agohttps://futurism.com/the-byte/spacex-building-military-rocket-to-ship-weapons-anywhere-world https://futurism.com/the-byte/spacex-building-military-rocke...
- rtkwe 5y agoSpaceX has been doing a number of NRO secret launches and wouldn't exist without NASA contracts like CRS and Crew Dragon. They may not be boarded by ex military but they're part of the same industry surviving the same way.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoGreat, they're destroying the pork barrel industry's monopoly in space and providing a service at competitive prices that's exactly what we want. From my comment, you didn't suppose I believed government space capabilities and projects should be entirely shut down, or that they should be left to old space companies to continue extorting taxpayers, did you? Providing a service to the government is not a problem. This is not some kind of libertarian purity test I'm concerned about. It is about ripping off tax payers with lobbyists and the military industrial political revolving doors.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhy is SpaceX any different than the other companies, and why will they be any different?
- yosito 5y agoI can only speak for myself, but as someone who worked at NASA, my question is, how does working together with SpaceX in any way detract from the amazing things humanity has accomplished by working together? NASA doesn't have exclusive bragging rights on accomplishing things in space, and I for one am happy to celebrate and cooperate with others. In fact, one of the most inspiring things about NASA's accomplishments is how people from all over the world have come together and cooperated for the betterment of humanity.
- wolverine876 5y ago> how does working together with SpaceX in any way detract from the amazing things humanity has accomplished by working together? Who said it did? I'm not sure what you are responding to. However, working with an entity that perverts merit-based decision-making with public pressure could certainly be harmful, and Musk acts by manipulationg the public. Other NASA partners don't do that. The Europa Clipper, for example, will take years longer to reach its destination - a critical milestone that will delay the exploration of life on Europa for years (if I understand correctly)- due to being switched to a SpaceX launch. It was switched for technical problems later determined to be meritless.
- jccooper 5y agoOfficially, it was switched because SLS is unavailable. The program had been trying to get away from it due to its enormous cost, but was only able to get this change through Congress when the inability of SLS to fly more than once a year became obvious. The vibration issues were also very real.
- hourislate 5y agoDon't want to speak for OP but I think you have misinterpreted the meaning of his comment. I'm pretty sure he meant it has too much meaning and one day bringing Hubble back instead of abandoning an old friend to the abyss.
- dylan604 5y agoBut why? Just take one of the extra satellites provided to NASA by NRO to hang in musuems. Slap a NASA and Hubble sticker on it, and the tourists will flock to it. Let the actual one burn up on re-entry and save everyone billions of dollars.
- Causality1 5y agoThat's a great argument if it required a shuttle launch at 1.5 billion a pop. But modern rockets like Starship are a lot cheaper. Musk's $2 million number is probably horseshit but according to David Todd, the Seradata satellite market analyst, Starship launch cost could come in at $10 million. I'd say $10 million to bring Hubble home is worth it.
- kortilla 5y agoYes, James Webb has been quite the “amazing advance in space”.
- hoseja 5y agoWhy are you mentioning the (still not through launch and subsequent zillion step unfolding sequence btw) catastrophically late and utterly pork-barrelled JSWT?
- simonh 5y ago>What do you think about the organizations and people that actually accomplished these things? Presumably the OP thinks of them what they wrote about them in the comment - that they explore and inspire. To address your later comments as well, there was no specific promotion of SpaceX in the OPs comment, no implied criticism of any other space tech company or reason to believe the OP thinks anything but good things about them. Just a space enthusiast enthusing about space. But no, you have to turn it into an argument.