2 ms·
> Only above a certain population number. Many smaller cities and towns don't have this issue. So only every place where it matters then. Not having restricti
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Only above a certain population number. Many smaller cities and towns don't have this issue.
So only every place where it matters then.
Not having restrictions on 20 story buildings in farm country where nobody has any incentive to build 20 story buildings is irrelevant.
> Only if you own land. And only if your ideals support it. With a sufficient renting population there can be change.
This is another instance of "only where it matters" -- you have an area zoned exclusively for single family homes and nobody is renting because nobody who has to rent can afford to live there.
Also, this is "solved" by the scam of rent control. You bring just enough of the existing renters into the "screw the new guys" fold to prevent changes adverse to landlords.
> If this is true, then why even have a discussion? I mean, it's settled then - this is a democracy and the voting base will not support changes.
The question is at which level of government it should be decided. You do it at the state level instead of the town level and now there are a lot of people willing to remove zoning restrictions in the places they want to move to.
- giantg2 5y ago"So only every place where it matters then. Not having restrictions on 20 story buildings in farm country where nobody has any incentive to build 20 story buildings is irrelevant." This brings us to the root of the issue - job location and density. There's no reason companies can't move to existing small cities or towns. They don't have to cluster together in places like SF. It's tough to influence those choices, just like the preference of people to want low density housing. Some of it occurs naturally, at least for the worst offenders, like CA to TX in recent years. "You do it at the state level instead of the town level and now there are a lot of people willing to remove zoning restrictions in the places they want to move to." Are there though? I haven't really seen this. It also ignore local concerns. Maybe in low density places they don't care about higher density housing going in because the setbacks are naturally large. This changes if you go to a medium density area.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> There's no reason companies can't move to existing small cities or towns. There is. They put their offices where they can find workers. You can staff a Google office from the people who already live in San Francisco, not from the people who already live in Tuscon. And people don't want to live in a company town. If you live in a major city which has offices for every major company in your industry, you can buy a house there and not worry about what happens if you switch jobs. Are you going to want to buy a house some place you'd have to sell it if you ever wanted to work for a different company? > Some of it occurs naturally, at least for the worst offenders, like CA to TX in recent years. That only happens when the offenders are extraordinarily egregious. And even then, they're not moving from San Francisco to a thousand separate little towns. They're pretty much all going to Austin -- which has a higher population than San Francisco. > Are there though? I haven't really seen this. Have they actually moved zoning control to the state level anywhere? There are proposals to do it in California but I'm not sure that any of them have been implemented.
- giantg2 5y ago"Have they actually moved zoning control to the state level anywhere? There are proposals to do it in California but I'm not sure that any of them have been implemented." Not just implemented, but even studied/surveyed.