3 ms·
Ok, so you assumed they moved to a city. "So prohibitions on dense housing screw over people that want a rural life, but are forced to take jobs in a city." A
by giantg2 5y ago
Ok, so you assumed they moved to a city.
"So prohibitions on dense housing screw over people that want a rural life, but are forced to take jobs in a city."
According to the article in this post, people prefer lower density housing. I don't see how adding more higher density housing will meaningfully change that. Because as you make the commutes shorter, etc you entice more people to move there.
- cheriot 5y agoPeople prefer housing they can’t afford. Allowing housing of different densities allows people to optimize their trade offs.
- giantg2 5y agoCities do allow housing of different densities depending on location (zone). Why would mixed density make it any better, especially when the article/study already says people prefer low density housing?
- cheriot 5y agoNot really. In practice, there's a small area for apartment complexes and then a huge area for single family exclusive housing. In places without strict zoning, there's a whole spectrum of things https://missingmiddlehousing.com https://missingmiddlehousing.com The goal is that when prices go up, there should be a way for people to build more homes that have a reasonable commute.
- giantg2 5y agoThat depends on which cities we're looking at. We also have to look at percentage and not just area. If we're packing people in 10:1, then the space can be 5-10% of the area and hold a large portion of population. This may be sufficient based on the desires of the people (back to the article).we "The goal is that when prices go up, there should be a way for people to build more homes that have a reasonable commute." If they can't, then that should encourage employers to look elsewhere and move.
- cheriot 5y ago> If they can't, then that should encourage employers to look elsewhere and move. It doesn't. That's why the most prosperous American cities have the longest commutes and least affordable housing. If a metro area decided they don't want job growth and limited new office construction I'd be fine with that. But when a municipality allows new offices and prohibits new housing it hurts a lot of people.