3 ms·
I'm not sure your argument works here. When people complain about gentrification, they don't mean (as far as I can tell) tearing down high-rise apartments to b
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
I'm not sure your argument works here. When people complain about gentrification, they don't mean (as far as I can tell) tearing down high-rise apartments to build a McMansion. They mean first-ring suburban homes being driven up in price. So it seems to me that densification is the cure for the complaint about gentrification. Create enough higher-density housing to overcome the price increase of the gentrification.[1][2]
[1] This presumes that the gentrification complaint is a good faith one. Instead, it could amount to "I want my neighborhood to be remain one of small, single-family homes, but I don't want it to rise in price." I guess it's fine to want it, but I'm not sure that it's a problem that policy should solve.
[2] Increasing density in this way may also hinder gentrification. People who are causing gentrification by buying up homes in such neighborhoods are looking for that style of neighborhood. If some of the houses get replaced by high-rise apartments, well, do the gentrifiers really want to live in that neighborhood?
- nemothekid 5y agoI took the gentrification complaint at face value as I understood the point he was trying to make. As I understand it, gentrification isn't a "high density" argument, it's a NIMBY one (much like "environmental concerns" and "shadows"). While I believe that increased housing could ease gentrification, I personally believe that (1) gentrification is not a problem worth addressing and (2) it's most often used a tool to prevent the addition of new housing which worsens the symptoms of gentrification.