10 ms·
A city only "encompasses" suburbs because suburbanites drive to the city to work. Functionally I'd say that the urban space ends where mass transit ends.
by nine_k 5y ago
A city only "encompasses" suburbs because suburbanites drive to the city to work.
Functionally I'd say that the urban space ends where mass transit ends.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 5y ago> A city only "encompasses" suburbs because suburbanites drive to the city to work. I didn’t say that a city encompasses (it's associated) suburbs, I said that the term “city” encompasses, within its meaning, suburbs, to the extent that these are often literally their own cities. The term does not only refer to metropolitan cores. When the source article refers to “virtually every city in the USA bans single family homes...”, you have to understand that virtually every city in the USA is not a metropolitan core city. The vast majority of cities in the USA are suburbs or isolated small cities in rural areas that are exurbs of or even not associated tightly with a metropolitan core. Weighted by population things are different, but that's not what is referenced.
- nine_k 5y agoI agree; this is why I have hard time calling many agglomerations cities proper. They are like parts of Silicon Valley, just giant interconnected suburban tissue with some spots of urban space. Naturally, people living in suburbia mostly do so willingly, and resist attempts to erect cities on the middle of that tissue. If they wanted to live in a city, they'd move to one!