2 ms·
News has always enjoyed / suffered a tricky carve-out in our understanding of the interaction between the first amendment and copyright because (by its nature)
by shadowgovt 5y ago
News has always enjoyed / suffered a tricky carve-out in our understanding of the interaction between the first amendment and copyright because (by its nature) its value to the public is in dissemination.
So while it's generally not okay to wholesale-copy a news article, it's always been okay to quote it (and, in the concrete and particular case of Google and Facebook, it's also always been okay to point people to it).
So the disruption of the revenue model (surprise; turns out people were only getting the ads as a consequence of buying the paper, they weren't why they bought the paper) is particularly tough because the core activity that is disrupting the model (making news universally accessible and useful) is by itself a public good.
(It's worth noting that the newspapers in this story have to go through the anti-trust door on this topic specifically because [I assume] there isn't any meat on the bones of claiming ownership of the news Facebook / Google are aggregating.)