3 ms·
> I linked an example of such a drone up-thread; $5k So that's what? 150 CIWS bullets per drone for cost-equivalency? ($30 bucks per CIWS bullet). Seems like a
by dragontamer 5y ago
> I linked an example of such a drone up-thread; $5k
So that's what? 150 CIWS bullets per drone for cost-equivalency? ($30 bucks per CIWS bullet). Seems like a good trade, the CIWS can shoot down 500mph missiles, it will take out the much slower drone with far less ammo and far cheaper.
You also know that warships would be stationed 1000km away, with an E-2 Hawkeye looking over the horizon (300km range radars). So the first thing the drone will see is the E-2 Hawkeye. The drones wont even know where the ships are, and the Carrier is already deploying a mass of fighters at the drone swarm.
-----
Once the numbers are figured out by the E-2 hawkeye, the Carrier probably will deploy F18, which will use a 20mm Gatling gun to kill all the drones and return home.
The drones won't even see where the ships are in practice. The best they'll ever discover is the E-2 Hawkeye through line of sight. All the ships would be "too low" and hidden away by the horizon itself. The CIWS won't even get a chance to shoot because the drones never even made it to the horizon (ie: 50km) of the ships. All the drones are killed 300km out.
-----
There's a reason why China is mass-producing Destroyers. Because Destroyers work. Mass drones aren't really a strategy.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> 150 CIWS bullets per drone for cost-equivalency? Sure. The scary bit of drone swarms is not the individual basis, but the fact that shoot down ten drones and your CIWS is empty. > There's a reason why China is mass-producing Destroyers. You don't think they're also playing with drones?
- dragontamer 5y agoChina is playing with DF-21 missiles and relying upon them. 200km/hr drones (or slower) won't be effective against any of the US Naval forces. There's a reason China is spending billions developing 5000km/hr homing "ship-killer" missiles. If a $5000 drone could even pose a threat against any US Warship, China wouldn't have bothered with 5000km/hr hypersonic speeds or research. ---------- The goal of China's naval forces is to search for the US Fleet. Once China finds the US Fleet, it shoots the DF-21 ship-killer missile at it, hoping that the Chinese Fleet can stay in the game long enough to provide accurate targeting against the US ships. That's called A2/AD, Anti-access area denial. This works because the missiles move very, very fast, so the US ships need to kill the enemy Chinese ship within 15 minutes or so (ie: the time it takes for the missile to travel from China to 1000km out and hit a US ship).
- dragontamer 5y ago> Sure. The scary bit of drone swarms is not the individual basis, but the fact that shoot down ten drones and your CIWS is empty. It takes 4 minutes to reload a CWIS and the horizon is like 50km out. How fast are your drones again? Do you really think that a mass of drones will spend 15 minutes flying towards a group of warships and actually survive to make contact? How many drones? How did they not get picked up by radar and killed 300km out by E2 Hawkeye eye-in-the-sky + F18 fighters?
- ceejayoz 5y agoThis whole discussion has serious "Biplanes? Taking out our battleships? Hahahahaha!" vibes for me. The state-of-the-art for drones has moved forward immensely in the last few years. F-18s don't always hit enemy fighters, let alone uncrewed much smaller targets able to do extremely high-G maneuvers.
- dragontamer 5y agoThis discussion from my perspective is more like you're the guy arguing for the use of armored bicycles, when I'm already aware of the development of Tanks. https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b4/97/05/b497058ef6f0a0af5a30189ed812a27d.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b4/97/05/b497058ef6f0a0af5a30... Just because some people thought it was a good idea, doesn't mean it was in fact... a good idea. --------- Large-masses of suicide explosives work. We just call them cruise missiles. There's a particular strategy: you fly low to the ground so that radar don't pick you up, you fly as fast as possible (500mph / subsonic is one cutoff), and you throw a bunch of sensors onto it to auto-aim / home into the target. Deciding to go from 500mph down to 200mph (or slower) just so that you can make it work with quadcopter technology has the big issue that you're suddenly easier to shoot down. Our guns / AI systems are designed to shoot down 500mph missiles. Letting your mass of bots get shot down on purpose is... a strikingly odd strategy to say the least. ------ Similarly: the armored bicycle might have worked in WW1. But it turns out that the Armored Tank was a better weapon more suited for invading no-man's land. ------ The best argument you have against the CIWS is "hope the Aimbot-Gatling Gun runs out of ammo", ignoring the fact that it reloads in 4 minutes and that a typical Cruiser has two of them, and you're facing a fleet not just a single gun. ------- And you haven't even told me how the drones know where to go yet. How did the drones find the ships to begin with? > The state-of-the-art for drones has moved forward immensely in the last few years. F-18s don't always hit enemy fighters, let alone uncrewed much smaller targets able to do extremely high-G maneuvers. That's not a $5000 drone anymore and you know it. In any case, no quadcopter drone is going to have the high-G maneuverability of a jet or rocket. If you make a "rocket drone with an explosive payload", that's just a cruise missile. And yes, I'm aware that cruise missiles are a good idea. They also cost nearly $2 million each.