4 ms·
Ineffective dive bombing at Midway? It was the only thing that was effective! And, why do you say that "the defense of the Philippines was a disaster"? It wa
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
Ineffective dive bombing at Midway? It was the only thing that was effective!
And, why do you say that "the defense of the Philippines was a disaster"? It was a battle against hopeless odds, but are you saying it was bungled? If so, how?
And, what was poor about the navigation at Midway?
- csours 5y agoSOME of the dive bombing at Midway was effective, a lot of it was not. This was the first combat mission for many US pilots and so their dives were slow and shallow. Yes, it was bungled. The odds were hopeless at a certain point - which is what makes this operation so interesting to me. When did the odds become hopeless? October 1941 or December 7th or 10th or ... 1941? For poor navigation - it's not all on the pilots, this was hard throughout the war for all sides, but specifically I mean that different groups went different places. For Midway, I highly recommend reading Shattered Sword or watching any number of the presentations the authors have given.
- InTheArena 5y agoI believe the authors were also consultants on the recent Midway movie.. which is surprisingly accurate.
- kayodelycaon 5y agoFor midway, you might want to watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bd8_vO5zrjo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bd8_vO5zrjo > Ineffective dive bombing at Midway? It was the only thing that was effective! Poorly executed would be a better term. They succeeded by almost pure luck. Two different squadrons managed to accidentally attack in different directions at the same time while the Japanese carriers had fully fueled and armed airplanes in their hangars waiting for an opening to launch an attack. Their hit ratio was terrible, but one bomb on a carrier was enough to destroy it given the conditions. > And, what was poor about the navigation at Midway? USS Hornet's Flight to Nowhere. The carrier completely screwed up launching their squadrons and then went in the wrong direction. Their torpedo bomber squadron mutinied and went in a different direction. The torpedo bombers found the Japanese but without any friendly fighters to protect them, all where shot down. All 10 Wildcat fighters ran out of fuel and ditched in the ocean. The other groups aborted to Midway after getting critically low on fuel and not finding any targets. At least four planes lost from the other groups. Blog post: http://pilotpropwash.blogspot.com/2013/05/the-flight-to-nowhere.html http://pilotpropwash.blogspot.com/2013/05/the-flight-to-nowh...
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> > Ineffective dive bombing at Midway? It was the only thing that was effective! > Poorly executed would be a better term. They succeeded by almost pure luck. If you mean pure luck in finding the carriers, I could agree with you. But... Three to five hits on the Kaga. Only one hit on the Agaki. Three hits on Soryu. No hits on Hiryu in the first attack. Four or five hits on the second attack on Hiryu. That's not just getting lucky.
- csours 5y agoI stated my position imprecisely - the effectiveness of various pilots and squadrons was very UNEVEN, which indicates poor organizational readiness.