3 ms·
Indeed, I can think of a few areas of progress where social imperative is much greater, such as agriculture, healthcare and carbon free energy
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
Indeed, I can think of a few areas of progress where social imperative is much greater, such as agriculture, healthcare and carbon free energy
- mediocregopher 5y agoCan you explain _why_ it's so important to you? I literally don't get it, but I've also always assumed Moore's Law would run out eventually, so my worldview has that baked in.
- hinkley 5y agoYou can only solve the problems you understand, and human knowledge and civilization have expanded to the point where people are not interchangeable. I only know enough about the carbon and agriculture problems that I can explain them to other techies. I can't solve them. I can't even be sure my advice on which legislation needs to pass or be repealed is right. It's all a semi-educated guess. We are a giant parallel engine and insisting that we order all work crashes the capacity of the system to a rounding error. It's actively psychologically damaging because it gatekeeps people out of acknowledging that they can help be part of a solution instead of pretending to be silent witnesses to the effort of others.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"insisting that we order all work crashes the capacity of the system to a rounding error" I am not arguing "no-one gets to party untill we solve world hunger", I am questioning the 'social imperative claim' - computer performance has improved what, 3-5x in the last 5 years? It's not clear to me how this has benefitted the average Joe in a measurable way, who is struggling to put food on the table. By contrast, if energy/food prices fell 5x, or became x more nutritious, the impact would be hard to miss. Even reduced prices of space rockets seem to have made more of a difference.
- azeirah 5y agoI personally think it has to do with the belief that improvements in ALL important areas such as agriculture, energy, medicine etc are supported strongly by increased computational power. This is perhaps a belief, an ideology, an assumption or perhaps a theory. It doesn't matter much what you call it. The important part is to understand that computation today plays a similar role as to what mathematics did before we got computation. Interestingly enough, Alan Kay performed a talk a couple of years ago about this topic, questioning why despite sustained growth and investment into computing power in medicine, medicine discovery was actually _dropping_ as a result. I don't recall exactly if it was "medicine discovery", but it was something important related to that idea. So, that's an important topic to discuss if you hold the belief that computation will improve all areas of living in invisible ways by being some sort of mathematical infrastructure or whatever you want to call it.