4 ms·
One of the problems with modern society is that too many people see these services as essential. When it comes to utilities, I absolutely agree. But not a spec
by Waterluvian 5y ago
One of the problems with modern society is that too many people see these services as essential.
When it comes to utilities, I absolutely agree. But not a specific email provider or social media site or video site, etc.
- skohan 5y agoI would argue for certain career paths, not having access to Twitter essentially makes one non-competitive. Also my friend went to a university where the official communication for course-work happened through Facebook. I'm not sure how someone without access to Facebook would be able to participate in that program.
- throwaway6734 5y agoWhich career paths? I imagine "not getting banned from Twitter" is an important skill to have for any job that requires twitter. That's absurd and a failure on the university's part. What country was this in.
- skohan 5y ago> Which career paths? I imagine "not getting banned from Twitter" is an important skill to have for any job that requires twitter. Well this is moving the goal-posts isn't it? The comment I responded to said that the effect of being denied access to a certain social media platform is overstated. I would argue for media professionals it's basically a requirement. > That's absurd and a failure on the university's part. What country was this in. This was a masters program in Germany
- chriswarbo 5y ago> This was a masters program in Germany Witholding access to course materials, unless a student enters a contract/relationship with a third-party (Facebook or otherwise), is coersion. I would certainly kick up a fuss: start politely with those running the course (who probably didn't give it much thought); go up the chain as necessary. At each step, make sure the focus remains on the coersion: the University is retroactively adding terms (e.g. whatever is in Facebook's policies) to the contracts agreed during enrollment. It is threatening to impose penalties (e.g. lost marks) on those who don't accept such unilateral changes. Do not allow the issue to get derailed into tangential concerns, especially money (e.g. price of the service, or provision of equipment/connections, etc.). Those things could be solved by signing a cheque; but would not address the real problem. If concrete reasons is really needed, there are a bunch to choose from that aren't easily solved (and are not under the University's control): for Facebook/Meta there are a whole bunch, from real name requirements, privacy concerns, non-consentual psychology experiments, etc. Personally I would just say I find the company, their products and their business practices unethical. (I had a similar experience when my Physics course tried to make me use Microsoft Excel)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gunfighthacksaw 5y agoPersonally, I think getting banned from various technology communities can be a badge of honour. Obviously not just crude flaming, but going counter to the narrative. If I find myself agreeing with the average Redditor or Twitter user (god-forbid a blue check!) it’s usually a sign that something is missing from my thought process and I should shake things up a little.
- skohan 5y agoAre you sure you're not being contrarian for its own sake? There are times to go against the grain, but surely the consensus must be correct a lot of the time right? Can it really be the case that most people are wrong most of the time?
- Forge36 5y agoTwo of these are similar to a mailing address. If I move I need to a dozen different websites and services with my mailing address. Since it's not often I don't remember to track where this needs to happen. If I was forced to change my email address, I might not be able to recover some accounts. Some don't support changing username (which is my email). I don't want to count the number of websites I'd need to update.
- cosmodisk 5y agoOur daughter started going to a kindergarten across road. Guess how all the communication happens? In a private Facebook group. My wife has an account,while I deleted mine like almost 10 years ago. It's not very hard to extrapolate from such a simple example to the point where restricted access to such services can make life very difficult to individuals.
- codingdave 5y agoThis is exactly why public schools have accessibility requirements for any of their communications. Take it to the school board, and if they do not help, take it to a lawyer. The only way corporations will take control of our society is if we let them. I am continually amazed by how much people let corporations and attorneys bully them. There is this pervasive attitude that they control everything and it is dangerous to fight back. If that attitude continues to prevail, then yes - that is when we will have serious problems.
- Loughla 5y ago>This is exactly why public schools have accessibility requirements for any of their communications. I am not sure you have an accessibility case regarding a facebook group. It is accessible for individuals with disabilities, via the use of electronic aides such as screen readers. Accessibility does not mean, "I get whatever I want whenever I want." It means, "I can access this without my disability impeding that." Not having facebook is not a disability. I'm very, very confused by what you're saying.
- codingdave 5y agoI was thinking of people without any connection at all - homeless families who have no mobile phones or internet connection. Those communications aren't about disability, just simple lack of access. But that is missing the forest for the trees - the specifics of this anecdote are one small point. Standing up for yourself is the bigger point. I could be 100% wrong about the accessibility in schools, but that doesn't change my larger wish - that we would all stand up and push back when we see problems... not just dismissively say, "well, we'd never win that fight, so don't even try."
- zivkovicp 5y agoI guess it depends. A lot of people who sell crafts and bespoke items will probably rely on access to various marketplaces and payment processors; and arguably the social media platforms could be considered essential for marketing. Drivers and people working delivery gigs would rely on their own platforms like Uber or Deliveroo, etc. For personal use, I would be inclined to agree with you; many of the platforms are more of a nuisance than anything else.