5 ms·
Hacked Cryptocurrency Platform Begs Hacker to Please Return $119M
- tomhunters 5y agoI guess Defi is not quite safe as one expects.
- tuyguntn 5y ago> The hacker was able to steal an API key that gave them control of BadgerDAO’s account on Cloudflare, the project’s content delivery network for its site. This gave the hacker the ability to inject a malicious script on the site that prompted users to give up wallet permissions, which then allowed the hackers to steal customers’ cryptocurrency. If your use case involves being able to control user accounts centrally, why do you need blockchain for that? UPD: if hacker didn't do it, BadgerDAO could do it anytime in the future, when money is much more than now, so it is good that they were hacked earlier, smaller impact on end users
- pjc50 5y ago> why do you need blockchain for that? As Willie Sutton said, that's where the money is. https://www.nytimes.com/1979/08/26/archives/willie-sutton-said-it-first-thats-where-the-money-is.html https://www.nytimes.com/1979/08/26/archives/willie-sutton-sa... (Imagine having to go to the trouble and risk of walking into a bank with a gun for a mere thirty thousand 1979 dollars, when you could steal one hundred million dollars by compromising some software!)
- gruez 5y ago>If your use case involves being able to control user accounts centrally, why do you need blockchain for that? AFAIK the accounts are not controlled centrally. How it works is that the project owners set up a site/webapp, which has javascript that interacts with wallet extensions installed on the user's browser. Members of the DAO uses the site to do various actions, for instance buying tokens or making votes. The site sends the request to the wallet extension to be signed, and then it gets broadcasted to the ethereum network. At the end of the day, the wallets are still controlled by the user, it's just that hijacking the site allows them to fool a massive number of users that don't pay close attention.
- carlosdp 5y ago^ this is correct, BadgerDAO has no control over user accounts, this is purely a frontend that was manipulated. You could redploy the frontend from source somewhere else without asking Badger and it would work just as well.
- mushufasa 5y agoif a single point of failure impacts the actions of a large number of users, that would count as central control in my book
- carlosdp 5y agoYou don't have to use the frontend they host, it's not an actual single point of failure. Their frontend could go down, and as long as someone else is hosting one (or you download the source from github and host it locally) you can still use Badger.
- mikeheaton 5y agoIf the failure of this single point led to the loss of $114m, that counts as a SPoF in my book regardless of what the platonic ideal user “could” or “should” have done.
- diveanon 5y ago
- Finnucane 5y agoYou’d think the sort of people who buy crypto tokens wouldn’t be the sort to trust others to hold their ‘money’, but I guess consistency is no one’s strong point.
- PretzelPirate 5y agoThere’s a group of people in the cryptoasset space who hold their own assets, understand how the system works, and know how to secure their own funds. Then there are people who don’t care about decentralization and flood every discord server asking “wen token” and are just around to make free money and would happily do it on a centralized platform. The second group has grown in size over the last few years and will put money into things that are clearly scams in hopes of a payout, and will click “sign transaction” anytime they’re prompted. This is why the UX for blockchains needs to improve. There’s no reason that tooling can’t warn people when they’re authorizing funds to an unknown address. There is at least one hardware wallet that’s building out visualizations to help users understand what they’re doing.
- nraf 5y agoYeah, it's a massive problem. We're working on a tool to solve that in the DeFi space: https://app.agentsinu.com/bsc/tokens https://app.agentsinu.com/bsc/tokens Just launched a week ago and there's a ways to go yet but we're working on things like honeypot detection, dodgy tax fees, issues & changes of contracts, etc. The amount of scam tokens out there and unscrupulous tactics is outstanding (though unfortunately not surprising).
- jollybean 5y ago"understand how the system works, and know how to secure their own funds." "don’t care about decentralization and flood every discord server asking “wen token” and are just around to make free money a" Please ... both groups are rife with hustlers and pyramid scammers. Crypto as an asset class is entirely a grift irrespective of the few 'legitimate backers' beliefs or actions. If it were not for the big pile on of grifters, crypto would not have inflated prices and would therefore be the purview of a small number of hobbyists. Finally, the notion that people should have an advanced understanding of computing, crypto, security and the various pitfalls, would imply technology is accessible to less than 0.01% of the planet who have both the will and ability to do so, thereby rendering the nill as any material opportunity for true 'decentralization'. If people had to live in that world, they would be begging for some trusted institution in which they could safely place those funds, which are called 'banks'. Anyone can found one so long as they follow the regs, and those regulations are fully open and transparent. It represents just thee right amount of 'decentralization' necessary to keep a system with very high integrity afloat.
- pjc50 5y agoPreviously on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29414924 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29414924
- kranke155 5y agoJust to preempt the usual HN misconceptions. There are lots of crypto projects who have never been hacked - Compound, Balancer, AAVE - etc. Banks need top grade security, and making a bank in crypto is hard. Because of the absence of regulation, what you’re getting right now is a lot of DeFi projects that are poorly secured. You take the risk you’re willing to take really.
- raesene9 5y agoThe problem with crypto users "taking the risk they're willing to take" is that there's very little reliable information about which projects have better security than others. Every project will say that they have great security, but without external validation or regulation, how do you know which of them are mistaken or outright lying.
- kranke155 5y agoThere are audits that most projects do with crypto auditing software firms. These are usually announced publicly. That gives you some credibility in the space. IMO security just comes from time spent operating vs amount of hacks. If you've been operating for a couple of years with no known hacks then I trust the team behind the project.
- raesene9 5y agoaudits are a signal for sure, but can an end-user tell a good audit from a bad audit? Also as monox (who got hacked this week) shows 3 audits this year are no guarantee https://docs.monox.finance/library/audits https://docs.monox.finance/library/audits
- awr 5y agono audit's going to pick up every possible issue or potential exploit, but it does help weed out the obvious scams. The entry to creating your own token is so low that people with little to no coding experience are attempting to add/modify functionality. Community insistence to get audited is useful to pick up on these.
- zephyr9 5y agoTechbros: we don't ask permission, we don't play by the rules, we move fast and break things, the world is our libertarian playground. Also Techbros: pls look in ur heart and do the right thing for us pls.
- cableshaft 5y agoSo the same mentality as startups then, like Uber's CEO "Innovators Shouldn't Have To Ask For Permission Or Forgiveness"[1] or Facebook's original motto for developers being "Move fast and break things"[2]. Also here's a list of 11 startup entrepreneurs who "broke all the rules and achieved great success" according to this article[3]. Also found several people claiming that "Disrupters don't play by the rules"[4][5][6], and startups love to consider themselves "Disruptors for X technology"[7] to the point of parody in the HBO's Silicon Valley tv show, and even an entire startup convention named after it (TechCrunch Disrupt)[8]. Unfortunately, I think it will be tough to pin down anyone claiming anything is their "libertarian playground" (including the techbros that you're pretending are saying that), so I have to leave that one untouched. Also, if getting hacked is all that's needed in order to get the mockery and derision of HN, then you pretty much all should be mocking yourselves, since the past few years have shown that there's almost no company of any decent size that doesn't eventually get hacked, and there's a good chance you're working for a company that has been hacked or will in the next five years. In the last few years I alone have gotten notifications of having possible leaked data from Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitch, Netflix, Target, Michael's, Equifax, and probably at least a dozen more companies, and I'm sure probably at least a dozen more on top of that never bothered to notify me. [1]: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130130/18445721832/ubers-ceo-innovators-shouldnt-have-to-ask-permission-forgiveness.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130130/18445721832/ubers... [2]: https://mindmatters.ai/2018/10/facebooks-old-motto-was-move-fast-and-break-things/ https://mindmatters.ai/2018/10/facebooks-old-motto-was-move-... [3]: https://www.entrepreneur.com/slideshow/328085 https://www.entrepreneur.com/slideshow/328085 [4]: https://twitter.com/accenturetech/status/575606603644272640 https://twitter.com/accenturetech/status/575606603644272640 [5]: https://youtu.be/NRjVcogNRac https://youtu.be/NRjVcogNRac [6]: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/disruptors-dont-play-rules-reuven-gorsht/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/disruptors-dont-play-rules-re... [7]: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jan/11/disruption-silicon-valleys-buzzword https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jan/11/disruptio... [8]: https://techcrunch.com/events/tc-disrupt-2021/ https://techcrunch.com/events/tc-disrupt-2021/
- newacc9 5y agoThis has to affect the large returns on stablecoins, right? These counterparties are going bust left and right. 9% for GUSD for example https://blockfi.com/rates/ https://blockfi.com/rates/
- quickthrowman 5y agoA yield above the risk free rate implies that risk does in fact exist for stablecoins.
- kordlessagain 5y agoDon’t do it, hacker. If you do, consensus will always be whack.
- webinvest 5y agoCelsius had several hundred Bitcoin lost in this BadgerDAO phishing attack.
- bdcravens 5y ago"we are willing to work with you and compensate you for identifying this vulnerability in the systems" I'm pretty sure they have already been compensated, to the tune of $119M. If they are serious they'll offer to sign an agreement indemnifying the hacker from prosecution, and still give them a substantial sum (at least $30M)
- sneak 5y agoThe victim of a crime doesn't decide if they get prosecuted or not, and cannot indemnify them from criminal liability (only civil), at least in the USA. There's no such thing as "pressing charges".