5 ms·
> Remember, all this stuff is zero-sum. For every winner, there has to be a loser. That's not how it works. Suppose Bitcoin comes into existence and people mi
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Remember, all this stuff is zero-sum. For every winner, there has to be a loser.
That's not how it works.
Suppose Bitcoin comes into existence and people mine a billion dollars worth of it. They now have a billion dollars worth of Bitcoin. Nobody else has lost anything.
If they sell the Bitcoin and someone else buys it, the buyer hasn't lost anything. They had $100 worth of cash and now they have $100 worth of Bitcoin. Provided the price is stable, their net worth doesn't change. If the price goes up, they make money. If the price goes down, they lose money. That part is zero sum, but the initial mining still created the value that it created.
It would only be zero-sum if Bitcoin goes to zero. Not just 5% of where it is now, actually zero. Because otherwise it would still have created whatever non-zero asset value people still ascribe to it.
- librish 5y agoThe point is that for every dollar someone takes out of the crypto eco-system someone else has to put one in. With miners taking their own cut that means the game is actually negative sum for normal people trading in crypto currencies.
- space_rock 5y agoSpeculation is zero sum ignoring adding liquidity to the market in a positive sum game Everything else is positive sum. Trading, moving money, storing wealth...
- lmm 5y agoBut it's not stable enough to be terribly useful for storing wealth or moving money, at least by the standards of normal legal assets. So most of the value must come from crime and speculation.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoFor miners it's positive sum. For people who buy cryptocurrency with government-issued currency it's zero sum. They don't show up with cash and go home with nothing. They get that amount of cryptocurrency. They only lose something if the value goes down. Which it might, or it might not.
- lottin 5y agoYou're using the term zero-sum incorrectly. Look up zero-sum game.
- tim333 5y agoSame for most things. Guy grow potatoes sells some and uses the money to buy stuff. For every dollar he takes out of his potato ecosystem someone has to put one in. Just how these things are.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoTechnically there is a cost per Bitcoin from the power and other costs that occurred from mining. Some might be not fully lost (GPUs, commodity hardware) but the kWh and custom ASICs are just a sunk cost. If Bitcoin goes to $0.01 or even $5, I bet that makes most mined Bitcoins underwater like how pennies and nickels cost more than their face value.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoNow you're talking about revenue vs. profit. That part of the "value" is still created, it just goes to the power company or the ASIC manufacturer instead of the miner. If you mine $100 worth of Bitcoin, there is $100 worth of Bitcoin created, whether the electricity cost you $20 or $120.
- lottin 5y agoThis is not how 'creating value' works. If you create something that sells for $100 but cost $100 to be produced, you have created zero value, and if it cost $120 you have destroyed value. In economics this is called added value, it's defined as the value of the output minus production costs. The sum of all added value over a period of time amounts to the GDP.
- boc 5y agoIt's still zero-sum - I'll illustrate with an example: Imagine you and your friends collect and trade rocks you find on the beach. The more rocks you pick up and put in your personal baskets, the scarcer they become (just like mining bitcoins), so the work of finding more rocks becomes harder. This makes all the rocks you've already found "worth" more. Let's say for this thought experiment that there are 1000 rocks on this beach total. The value of the rocks is only realized when someone decides they want to pay you dollars for your rocks in your pile instead of going out to pick up rocks themselves. This transaction (say $1 per rock for 100 rocks) now suddenly makes everyone's pile of rocks valuable, because there's someone out there who was willing to pay $1 per rock. If the next person pays $2 per rock for 100 rocks, then everyone's rock piles double in value. This means that the "market cap" for rocks on your beach is $2000 ($2 x 1000 rocks), but that doesn't mean that there is suddenly $2000 of USD in you and your friends' pockets. There's only the $300 that the two buyers paid into the system, but it wasn't generated by collecting rocks. Let's say that the last 100 rocks are super hard to find - they might be buried deep in the beach and not worth digging with your hands. After a few hours the supply of rocks has essentially capped. The only way to get more rocks for yourself is to trade dollars for rocks. You open your wallet and buy 100 rocks from your friend for $500 dollars. Now everyone knows that 1 rock = $5. Market cap = $5000. Someone else wants to buy but it's hard to get anyone to sell. They spend $100 to buy just 10 rocks. Now 1 rock = $10, Market cap = $10,000. Now that each rock is worth $10, people get shovels and try to find more rocks buried. Finally they've all been found. Let's say that 100 people total are now holding at least 1 rock. Let's freeze it here and look at who has won and who has lost. Assume that finding the rocks didn't cost anything. From the perspective of everyone who simply picked up rocks, they hold rocks worth $10 each, but haven't paid anything to acquire them. Great right? Well not necessarily - nobody actually paid them anything yet, so they have realized exactly $0 in gains. Let's look at the four transactions that occurred which gave the rocks value. The first saw $100 go from person A to person B, for a net of $0. The second saw $200 from one person to another, for a net of $0. Third, etc - fourth and final, also net of $0. Within this example, trading dollars for rocks is clearly a zero-sum game. The only reason that crypto "looks" different is that it's a much larger beach with millions of rocks and millions of people trying to trade them and pick them up. But it's the same thing.
- 5y ago
- meheleventyone 5y agoI think Animats is calling it zero sum because the value of Bitcoin is essentially based on speculation rather than use so relies on new entrants to prop it up and the coins are generated within the system. Basically new coins do not represent new dollars coming in and generating new coins all the time is inherently deflationary. So not only do you need demand to outstrip supply to keep the value going up you also need new dollar entrants if you ever want to cash out.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> I think Animats is calling it zero sum because the value of Bitcoin is essentially based on speculation rather than use so relies on new entrants to prop it up and the coins are generated within the system. This really depends on what you think is going to happen going forward. Surely the current value is propped up by speculation, but are the speculators right? Is future-Bitcoin going to be very useful and thus valuable for something, so that the speculators will eventually have someone to sell their Bitcoins to other than just more speculators? It's not impossible for that to happen just because it hasn't already happened. It's also not impossible that it doesn't, in which case the speculators themselves will be the ones left holding the bag. But that's how it goes, isn't it? High reward, high risk.
- meheleventyone 5y agoThat’s the nature of speculation. I was more commenting on why calling it zero-sum makes sense.