5 ms·
There's something called "left turn hardening". This involves minor barriers to channel drivers into making wider left turns. New York City does a lot of this.[
by Animats 5y ago
There's something called "left turn hardening". This involves minor barriers to channel drivers into making wider left turns. New York City does a lot of this.[1]
[1] https://www1.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/pedestrians/turn-calming.shtml https://www1.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/pedestrians/turn-calming....
- jimbob45 5y agoI never knew that's what those were for. Thanks for sharing. I know you see a lot of concrete (+ grass) road medians in the South. Do those have a similar effect or do the cones need to extend out to really work?
- selimthegrim 5y agoMobile, AL has some pretty big left turn channels they dug out the median for. New Orleans tends to make U turns past the intersection.
- azundo 5y agoThe linked page describes exactly that - "Left Turn Calming" projects. > At SFMTA, we’re working hard to help drivers make left turns the right way. We’ve installed Left Turn Guide Bumps at designated intersections around the City, with painted safety zones and raised bumps to remind drivers to slow down and make squarer left turns. We’ll test how well these treatments make left turns safer, with a long-term goal of installing calming project at other intersections where they are needed most.
- mlex 5y agoThere’s one of these at 10th Street turning left onto Folsom.
- baybal2 5y agoWhy US can't simply install left turn signals onto traffic lights more widely? I noticed how few of them are there in North America.
- wahern 5y ago1) Because pedestrians walk against the signal all the same. 2) Because if it's a dedicated turn signal, you dramatically increase cross-traffic wait time. To compensate you need better signal timing to minimize the number of stops, but that tends to increase speeds, which is not good for pedestrians. If the signal isn't dedicated, it doesn't actually make it easier for the driver to see pedestrians as their attention is still split. The problem with San Francisco is its reliance on surface transportation, both cars and buses. I live in the city but I can drive downtown 2x faster in a car then if I took the bus, whether there's traffic or no traffic. And while I'd prefer to take public transit, I don't prefer spending 45m-1h in a bus (the "rapid" line) when driving only takes 20-30m. That's an additional hour out of every work day, and an hour spent sitting at that. (I wouldn't mind walking 15m to a subway that would speed me downtown, but that's just not in the cards here. They're even discussing cancelling the Geary BRT project after only building a few bulb outs and painting some lanes, which in actuality saved 10 minutes at the very best.) As a pedestrian I hate cars. However, in this city I can't only be a pedestrian. To get from one part of the city to another, I need to take surface transportation, which to be efficient needs fast, smooth flowing traffic. (And to be most time efficient for me, that means driving a car, at least to any place where there isn't a direct bus line.) Doing things correctly requires a comprehensive solution which includes building new infrastructure rather than simply tearing down old infrastructure. Unfortunately San Francisco politics is too paralyzed. One the one hand you have the people who want to tear things down--close streets, etc. On the other hand you have people who don't want anything to change. And on the third hand... well, there is no third hand.
- Gwypaas 5y agoAll those examples are honestly still awful. What is needed is traffic/refuge islands so you has a pedestrian only have to deal with the possibility of crossing traffic coming from one direction and no chance of getting stuck in a unprotected position. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refuge_island https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refuge_island
- ARandumGuy 5y agoThose can work on areas with lower speed traffic, but they can be very dangerous on wide roads with faster vehicle traffic. Poorly designed refuge islands give pedestrians very little protection if a vehicle looses control at an intersection. Even if the pedestrian is paying attention, the only escape option is likely straight into traffic.
- Gwypaas 5y agoGood then that I can't remember the last time I saw a bent light pole due to a car losing control. I actually haven't seen it happen in my life. I have seen bent light poles, but I couldn't tell you when or where last. Escape shouldn't be an option, it won't work on the sidewalk either. Optimizing for that is optimizing for failure.
- ARandumGuy 5y agoAnecdotally, I've seen several bent "walk button" poles located right in the middle of refuge islands. When you live in a place that gets snow and ice in the winter, cars slide out of control frequently.
- Gwypaas 5y agoI think that comes down to mandating winter tires, effective snowplowing and drivers education including driving in slippery conditions, if such conditions are regularly encountered and expected. Important is enforcing it also, let people slide out of control in a controlled fashion so they know to be scared of it. I literally drove all around town yesterday, a nice cool -5C (23F) with about 30-40 cm of snow which came in the last week, no problem at all. No bent poles anywhere (anecdotally). Always fun feeling the ABS kick in at the slightest too hard touch of the brake pedal, even with studded tires.