4 ms·
Thanks for the link; that’s a great resource! To summarize their current results: Purple Air (especially version 2) is the only one that doesn’t suck at measu
by hedora 5y ago
Thanks for the link; that’s a great resource!
To summarize their current results: Purple Air (especially version 2) is the only one that doesn’t suck at measuring PM 2.5. None of the consumer-targeted gaseous sensors they tested work.
Did I miss something? Is some other third party running more comprehensive tests?
- Gatsky 5y agoThe Sensirion does pretty OK for the price and form factor.
- DannyBee 5y agoAssuming you care PM1.0/PM2.5 (which are what are truly harmful), and want R^2 >0.9: Atmotube pro Elitech (for PM2.5) Purpleair The field evaluations have good expositions of the underlying data in slide form. For sure the purpleair is the best bet that i can see. Note that they are pragmatic as well - if you read field evaluations, AQMD folks generally think >0.8 R^2 is very good. Which probably makes sense comparing a $50-$250 device to a several thousand dollar reference instrument. Note that one serious issue is that a bunch of the sensors aren't just uncorrelated, they are often dramatically undercounting. It would be one thing if they were dramatically overcounting, and told you air was horrible when it wasn't. But they are actually telling you air is fine when it isn't even close to fine. I actually went down the same path as OP about 6 months ago. I have used a dylos meter in my old woodshop, and was building a new one, and wanted to see what the the best thing to do was. After a bunch of looking, i found these folks. I am not aware of others doing this breadth of testing. (It turn out the dylos meter is either accurate, or overcounts, depending on temperature/humidity. This is actually acceptable since it won't tell me things are good when they are bad, but it also turned out the purpleair was consistently good for the same price :P)
- formerly_proven 5y agoSo the two purpleair devices are using PM1003 and PM5003 sensors, respectively. These are available off the shelf as well. I suppose the salient question is: does purpleair calibrate / select these themselves or add anything to them (e.g. filter), or can you just use a PMS5003 for 30 bucks and get similar results?
- genewitch 5y agoAfaik you can use the $30 module and be within acceptable tolerances, but you really should have at least a temperature and humidity sensor as well, because as that changes the other sensors will report differently. I've noticed that even being exposed to pure carbon dioxide the sensors I have will increase the counts of CO, VOC, and HCHO, which is unlikely and a false read. I only care about CO2 for my devices, so my two $30 sensor based devices are fine.