3 ms·
This seems to be missing some details. Are they comparing to only other large retailers, or non-Amazon employers across industries? Are they only comparing wage
by giantg2 5y ago
This seems to be missing some details. Are they comparing to only other large retailers, or non-Amazon employers across industries? Are they only comparing wage increases for minimum wage?
The reason I ask is that the increases could be diluted by including non-minimum wage jobs, or jobs in other industries. A .6-1% increase is way less than inflation. I suppose it's better than 0%, but still not a good thing. It seems many workers don't realize (or have no power to change) that they are being paid less if their pay doesn't rise as fast or faster than inflation.
- fortran77 5y agoPerhaps part of the reason for inflation is the rising minimum wages.
- giantg2 5y agoMaybe a part, at historical levels. Right now it seems to be driven moslty by monetary policy, supply issues (reduction in competition, increased demand), and labor supply issues (plays into minimum wage in so far that more employers are paying above it).
- Workaccount2 5y agoThat's why you also need to take money out of the top to counteract this. A wage crush is ideal, not a wage raise.
- jimmaswell 5y agoWhat do you mean by wage crush? I can't find any definition.
- Workaccount2 5y agoIt's a term I use myself. It's pushing down on higher wages while pushing up on lower wages in effort to concentrate people into middle class. This would also mean that many people who are not even remotely close to "the billionaire class" would get pushed down, so it's not really popular with high-earning coastal liberals, and probably many people here.
- giantg2 5y agoBut what mechanism would that use? Things like taxes would likely make a limited impact due to raising wages to offset the tax until the point that off-shore is more competitive. Legislative restrictions have been struck down in the past (the $1M CEO restriction of the 80s?).
- Workaccount2 5y agoI honestly don't know. I tend to be in favor of using gentle nudges to leverage natural market forces to institute change. Fortunately/unfortunately capitalism is designed to be self reinforcing. Catching more fish enables you to build bigger nets and protect fishing methods. But there isn't really any natural mechanism for incentivizing a reversing of that. Someone smarter than me will have to come up with something. Right now though it's a runaway feedback loop that's going to eventually destroy itself by "doing everything right".
- jimmaswell 5y agoRaising lower end wages coupled with inflation would have the same effect, wouldn't it?
- giantg2 5y agoAt least in my experience, the higher end people understand inflation and would demand higher pay to match or beat inflation. Especially at the executive level.
- wallaBBB 5y agoAnd yet the inflation outdates and outpaces the rise of the minimum wage, even prior to covid [1] If it was to match inflation it would be more than $15 [2] And if it was to match productivity, it would be even more [2][3] [1]https://www.epi.org/publication/labor-day-2019-minimum-wage/ https://www.epi.org/publication/labor-day-2019-minimum-wage/ [2]https://edition.cnn.com/2021/02/21/politics/minimum-wage-inflation-productivity/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2021/02/21/politics/minimum-wage-inf... [3]https://cepr.net/this-is-what-minimum-wage-would-be-if-it-kept-pace-with-productivity/ https://cepr.net/this-is-what-minimum-wage-would-be-if-it-ke...
- dahfizz 5y ago> If it was to match inflation it would be more than $15 Neither of your sources support that claim: > Even worse is that federal-minimum-wage-earning workers today are paid 31% less than the $10.54 an hour they would have been paid in 1968, when the minimum wage reached its highest (inflation-adjusted) value. [1] > The wage hit its peak in inflation-adjusted terms in 1968 at just over $12 [2] The productivity argument is silly, and your third source says as much. Minimum wage has not kept pace with average productivity because minimum wage jobs themselves have not kept up with average productivity. CEPR makes the argument that doctors and software engineers just make too much money, and this somehow hurts the minimum wage earners. Which is a wild bit of mental gymnastics to claim that minimum wage earners should profit from high-skilled productivity, but the high-skilled workers should not.
- sovnade 5y agoTying minimum wage to productivity never made sense to me. Obviously as technology progresses, productivity would increase. There wouldn't be an incentive to invest in productivity-increasing tech if it was directly offset by wage increases. Tying it to inflation though is a no-brainer. We do it for social security payments, congress salaries, etc. There's no justifiable reason for not doing this.
- tyingq 5y ago>could be diluted by including non-minimum wage jobs Wouldn't there be a stair-step effect eventually? For example, licensed vocational nurses are typically in the next tier up, with ~$20/hour entry level pay. But it's hard work. If you aren't paying more than the jobs that used to be minimum wage, but now aren't, you won't be able to hire anyone. Then rinse and repeat that for the 3rd tier.
- dahfizz 5y agoYes, that is called inflation.
- tyingq 5y agoThat's a little simplistic, isn't it? Inflation isn't solely driven by wage increases followed by higher product and service prices. There's "Wage Push" inflation, which is just one of many types. I'm not even sure it's really "inflation" if the wage increases aren't exceeding cost of living increases.
- dahfizz 5y agoSure, inflation isn't solely driven by wage increases. And wage increases aren't solely driven by minimum wage legislation. But a bump in minimum wage which results in higher wages for everyone and a devaluation of the currency is inflation. I don't think that's any more simplistic than your premise of all the "tiers" of jobs getting a raise. What you described is inflation.
- tyingq 5y agoI'd agree if wages (especially minimum wage) had kept pace with cost of goods and services over the years. It hasn't. There was an 11 year period where it didn't change, for example.
- dahfizz 5y agoInflation is never the exact same across industries and across time. Electronics prices have inflated less than the economy average, and even deflated depending on how you measure it. But if changing market conditions meant that electronics prices explode over the next decade, like housing and medical costs have, that would still be inflation. Stagnating prices in recent history does not make something immune to inflation. Labor is no different.
- k2enemy 5y agoThe article links to the actual paper, which would be a good place to look for these details. For example... """ We calculate the bite of the large retailer’s minimum wage as the fraction of job ads by other employers with pre-period wages below the announced minimum wage, within detailed occupation, employer, and commuting zone (“CZ”) categories. This approach mirrors that of papers estimating the causal effect of the federal minimum wage using state-level variation in the portion of the state’s wage distribution under the new higher minimum wage (Card, 1992; Bailey et al., 2021). Here, however, we are able to exploit variation in bite at a much finer level, across tens of thousands of employers and hundreds of occupations and commuting zones. This level of variation allows us to precisely estimate effects and conduct several robustness checks to rule out alternative explanations for wage increases. """
- giantg2 5y agoThanks