4 ms·
People drove an hour out of their way to Walmart because it was that much better. Not just the prices, but also selection Sort of. People just shopped differen
by reaperducer 5y ago
People drove an hour out of their way to Walmart because it was that much better. Not just the prices, but also selection
Sort of. People just shopped differently in those days. If your local stores didn't have what you wanted, you ordered from a catalog.
But the difference is that today, people don't bother checking their local stores first. They just go straight to Amazon and put their neighbors or of business.
Walmart was the pioneer of long term hassle free returns
Not really. High end department stores were doing it for generations. Six months later and no receipt? No problem. My mom used to do this all the time.
Walmart just brought it to the masses.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> and put their neighbors or of business People aren't obligated to shop anywhere, and it isn't their fault if their neighbours' businesses aren't viable. You can't say the customers who have nothing to do with your business and no desire to go there are the ones who 'put you out of business'.
- reaperducer 5y agoI just can't even grasp you thinking. Have you never lived in a community? In a society? Have you never gone to a block party? Said hi to a neighbor? Gone to a bar? Cared even a little bit about the neighborhood in which you live? Everything you wrote is perfectly tailored for a misanthrope who wants to live in a cave and do things by remote control and never interact with another human being. When your neighborhood falls apart, crime goes through the roof, the homes are vacant, and homelessness increases, you know who to blame.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Have you never lived in a community? In a society? Have you never gone to a block party? Said hi to a neighbor? Gone to a bar? Cared even a little bit about the neighborhood in which you live? Yes I'm heavily involved as a leader in my local community and spend about 70 days a year volunteering in it and supporting the people who live in it. How does that compare to you? Supporting your local community doesn't mean propping up unviable businesses. It's a luddite argument, like paying people to dig holes and fill them back in again. If I opened a store next to your house selling last week's newspapers and you never buy any is it your fault I went out of business? Nonsense.
- reaperducer 5y agoYes I'm heavily involved as a leader in my local community and spend about 70 days a year volunteering in it and supporting the people who live in it. How does that compare to you? Not very favorably, but points for puffing out your chest in public. The internet loves virtue signaling. I just can't respond to the rest of it because it is victim blaming, tangential, or assumes that the business isn't viable, and that there is a level playing field. Your entire logic seems to be that if small stores can't compete, they should get go out of business. That only leads to a handful of companies controlling all of the commerce in the nation, which is not good for anyone. You: "Hey, Neighbor Bob! Look at these great screws I got from Amazon." Neighbor Bob: "I sell those screws in my hardware store. Why didn't you buy them from me?" You: "Because Amazon delivered them right to my door!" Neighbor Bob: "I can't do that for a $1.99 sale." You: "Then it's your fault for not being a trillion-dollar company. You should go out of business and live under a bridge. That's what's good for our community!"
- chrisseaton 5y ago> points for puffing out your chest in public Lol you asked me if I did anything! I didn't say anything until you specifically asked!
- jackling 5y agoReally not following the HN commenting guidelines here lol. The above commenter was just stating a point on their responsibility to local businesses. From that you assumed way too much about them and their community connections.
- mapster 5y agoThis is why Amazon is better for Main St than Walmart. A mens clothier on Main St gets shut down by Walmart. Owner and employees work at Walmart. With Amazon, they can become Amazon retailers. In theory at least.
- reaperducer 5y agoIt's better for Main Street if the money from the community is spent in the community and remains in the community, improving the community. Buying from Amazon just shunts money to Seattle. Not everyone lives in Seattle.
- BeFlatXIII 5y ago> But the difference is that today, people don't bother checking their local stores first. They just go straight to Amazon and put their neighbours out of business. Amazon didn't become dominant because of their low prices. They became dominant because they are the everything store. It's a single place to buy disparate items rather than needing to check out at seven different marginally-cheaper speciality shops.