3 ms·
> what problems Waterfall presented These are presented in the article. > Analysis, Specifications, Requirement These tend to be inadequate, incomplete, or .
by pjc50 5y ago
> what problems Waterfall presented
These are presented in the article.
> Analysis, Specifications, Requirement
These tend to be inadequate, incomplete, or ..
> Qualification
.. at this point the customer discovers that what they asked for does not actually solve their problem.
You cannot do any kind of exploratory or innovative work in waterfall, because you can't specify that upfront. You can't easily co-evolve solutions by discovering what works and what doesn't. You can't even do A/B testing really, because every time you do your GANTT chart bifurcates.
There is a history of big, spectacular IT project failures, often commissioned by the public sector, but not always. The evolution of non-waterfall systems has been driven by trying to prevent or mitigate these failures.
- boffinAudio 5y ago>> Analysis, Specifications, Requirement >These tend to be inadequate, incomplete, or .. >> Qualification >.. at this point the customer discovers that what they asked for does not actually solve their problem. I disagree. If you are properly isolating your work into an "Analysis" phase, you will properly flesh out the issues and the subsequent specifications and requirements will be complete - sufficient to the task of formulating a development/implementation plan. But if you don't take care to complete a proper analysis - then no, you won't formulate specs or req's properly, either. The important thing is that the individuals involved know the value of a proper analysis - whether they are developers or managers or just paying the bills. Too often, software developers don't realize that they are really providing a social service, and thus they don't deliver proper analyses that can result in action. Alas, that is something other than a tooling/methodology issue and lays more in the motivations of the developer. Its a lot easier to say you can't be responsible for the mess as a developer if you don't allow the mess to be adequately described, in the first place .. so the Agile vs. Waterfall debate is really more of an ethics issue than anything else. Good developers do Waterfall Complete. Mediocre developers do it, and call it Agile. Terrible developers find excuses for not doing the key things, and end up with a failed project on their hands.
- pjc50 5y ago> If you are properly isolating your work into an "Analysis" phase, you will properly flesh out the issues and the subsequent specifications and requirements will be complete - sufficient to the task of formulating a development/implementation plan. But if you don't take care to complete a proper analysis - then no, you won't formulate specs or req's properly, either. But what if that doesn't happen? (This seems to parallel the "C is safe if you don't write bugs" argument. Processes that require infallibility are bad processes.) The level of dysfunctionality that can be achieved is baffling. How can someone fail to deliver a payroll system? https://www.smh.com.au/technology/worst-failure-of-public-administration-in-this-nation-payroll-system-20130807-hv1cw.html https://www.smh.com.au/technology/worst-failure-of-public-ad... - it's one of the oldest applications of business computing, and yet somehow it wastes a billion Australian dollars?
- boffinAudio 5y ago>Australian dollars Perhaps Waterfall (and its cousins) needs an addendum: Check for and Remove Corruption.
- ryathal 5y agoHonestly it's mostly incompetence that is the problem and waterfall magnifies incompetence.
- boffinAudio 5y agoIncompetent waterfall magnifies incompetence. Competent waterfall results in finished software projects.
- yread 5y agoOf course no one is doing the Analysis properly. It's impossible. You plan how to implement something using a library method. But only in the qualification phase you find out that this method actually has a bug on your target platform or is incompatible with another part of your software.
- rubidium 5y agoYour comment is the most accurate assessment of the history. It’s good for people to know.