5 ms·
If you have a proprietary program, reimplementing it under a FOSS license is a good thing. If you have a copyleft program, reimplementing it under a license tha
by josephcsible 5y ago
If you have a proprietary program, reimplementing it under a FOSS license is a good thing. If you have a copyleft program, reimplementing it under a license that allows proprietary modifications is a bad thing.
- oblio 5y agoWhy? You're allowed to build whatever you want, however you want? Why police people's licenses? Are they misrepresenting something, misleading people?
- loudmax 5y agoIt's thanks to open source that you are allowed to build what whatever you want. You don't have to give back if you don't want to.
- oblio 5y agoBesides the core aspect of your comment, you are aware that this entire subthread is about: * GNU Coreutils: GPL licensed * uutils: MIT licensed right? The MIT license is not only an Open Source license, but it's even a Free Software license according to the FSF itself. So this is nitpicking of the 100th degree at this point.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoNot really. It has to be possible in practise to make proprietary modifications, get them accepted into common use, somehow prevent other people just cloning them, and steal the momentum of the open source project. If someone makes proprietary extensions to "ls", they are just going to be stuck maintaining a fork. There is no realistic threat here.
- sbuk 5y agoFrom the OpenBSD Copyright Policy (https://www.openbsd.org/policy.html https://www.openbsd.org/policy.html) just for a different perspective from another FOSS project: "While this may superficially look like a noble strategy, it is a condition that is typically unacceptable for commercial use of software. So in practice, it usually ends up hindering free sharing and reuse of code and ideas rather than encouraging it..."
- andrekandre 5y ago> it is a condition that is typically unacceptable for commercial use of software whats the reason for that?
- sbuk 5y agoBecause the GPL, specifically v3 is viral. The point being made in this statement is that the requirement to give back is potentially onerous for many commercial entities, and that this hinders open sharing rather than promoting it. It's a differing point of view. Notice that, unlike the majority of pro GPL comments, it doesn't use pejoratives or appeals to emotion to make it's point.
- boogies 5y ago“Viral” is a term with a fairly pejorative emotional connotation and is not a very accurate way of describing copyleft. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viral_license#Criticism_of_the_term https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viral_license#Criticism_of_t...
- sbuk 5y agoThe original statement doesn’t use pejoratives. Viral is the best way that I can describe it, I suppose insidious is better, but that too could be considered a pejorative. I’m struggling to find a word because I view it negatively.
- noisem4ker 5y agoMaybe "self-propagating", or "self-preserving"? The term "insidious" would not be appropriate for sure, as it means "dangerous".
- sbuk 5y agoSelf-preserving is the best. Thank you. I personally don't like self-propagating, when the truth is that it's free, but with a catch. Forcing people to do the right thing, even if the intent is good, is still forcing someone to do something the don't want to, or even can't.
- curt15 5y ago"good" according to whom?
- jjtheblunt 5y agoHow is that assertion not a double standard?