4 ms·
I'm in my 20s, but I definitely think so. Back in the day redesigns were well thought out and kept as many of the previous design decisions as possible. Ever s
by jeroenhd 5y ago
I'm in my 20s, but I definitely think so.
Back in the day redesigns were well thought out and kept as many of the previous design decisions as possible. Ever since things started moving to the web, this seems to have changed.
Layouts, methodologies, subscription model, payment options, login options, core application design, it can all change from one month to the next. Everything is constantly being A/B tested, there is no clear release cycle anymore.
Now that iOS and Android finally seem to have settled down on a design, Windows changes their UI style again. Web frameworks seem to stagnate (finally) but there is already a slow move back to integrated server side rendering frameworks.
Modern software development is based on "move fast, break ad many things as possible, get promoted or bought out by FAANG". The time of cheat sheets, manuals and curated workflows is over, everything is now SaaS/PaaS/IaaS/AaaS and the only way to use a computer is to constantly relearn your work flow. Reading about new features and upgrade documents is no longer optional, because the next update could substitute some of the old features you rely on with the new ones.
Your computer,tablet, phone or TV could update tomorrow and you'll need to learn the entire contacts manager or file manager or settings menu from scratch and there's nothing you can do about it. And those are the systems that undergo relatively infrequent UI redesigns.
There are some things you can do. Stick sith LTS software if you can. Stick with single purchase, self-hosted software if you can. Avoid anything with buzzwords ending in aaS on their homepage like the plague, and try to switch to something else when your favourite self-hosted tool switches to an aaS model the way Atlassian did. You'll still end up using tons of crap that switches designs because the design team got bored again, but at least it'll affect as small a part of your floe as possible. Oh, and consider disabling automatic updates until security patches get released. I'd be the last person to advice someone to skip security updates, but redesigns often come in small parts and rolling updates, and you can delay them a little bit if you skip the unnecessary updates.
- dmje 5y agoGood advice and thoughts, thank you - much to think about!
- agumonkey 5y agoI think humans have a point where they have to commit to a choice to see what can be added upon. Back in the days everything was a long consequential change, you can't update 1M CDs, 1M cartridges, 1M car unless you bleed. The intantaneous, differential nature of high bandwidth web gave near full freedom. To the point you didn't even started seeing what you can build with a thing as it's already changed. ps: another weird thing, all the engineered methodological lead to incoherent changes. They're not progressing, they're jumping from local maxima to another.. Chrome and Google Apps UX regressed wildly multiple times. It's instability as a service.
- tartoran 5y agoI like the Instability as a Service. We should be more vocal about how costly to the customers these services really are and we should do chargebacks for these costs. If many customers express the concern they’d perhaps do something about it.
- agumonkey 5y agoI think it's pointless, the whole web is a big ship coast on its own inertia, usability doesn't really matter much.
- sandinmyjoints 5y ago+1000 for Instability as a Service!
- datavirtue 5y agoI built a desktop application in Java Swing about 15 years ago. I dropped it because it was cemented in "old" tech. After trying to rewrite the app several times in various cross-platform frameworks for the web and mobile I gave up and went back to the old code. I fired up the project after not touching it for ten years and loaded it in netbeans. It built and ran without a single issue. I was flabbergasted. If I leave my Xamarin Forms app for a month I come back to find failing builds, broken dependencies, dependency version mismatches, and OS related failures induced by updates. I spent countless hours hunting down solutions to these and it happened numerous times for different reasons. Visual Studio changes, OS changes, core framework changes, core language changes, library changes....omg. I'm working in my old crusty Java Swing project and I love it. Each minute I spend working on it moves the application closer to done. There are awesome open source themes available now and it looks great. My old code to remember window sizes and screen/monitor positions still works. Unfortunately, that was surprising as hell. I have the expectation it will work twenty years from now. Web app or mobile? Not a chance in hell.
- fnord77 5y ago[flagged]
- gherkinnn 5y agoThe most irritating aspect of this are "feeds". God, I hate feeds. Especially the wishy-washy clever ones. The only feeds I still use are Twitter and Spotify. The former is cancer and it's contents better be fleeting. But why on earth can't Spotify be predictable? It's start page is essentially useless. And despite all the clever people bing thrown at the problem, the Release Friday playlist is nowhere to be seen on Fridays. This can't be this hard.
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoSpotify's whole UX is a disaster, and it's puzzling to me why that's the case. They certainly have the resources and the high profile to attract people who can fix it. I guess they just don't feel the need.
- gherkinnn 5y agoWho knows what they're optimising for? Other than the start page, Spotify is perfectly fine though.
- datavirtue 5y agoThere are other issues. The random/shuffle has never worked properly. Why can't a billion dollar company figure out that they just played the same song for me a half hour ago? It is so bad we are drifting away from Spotify after subbing for ten years.
- relaxing 5y agoBut again, ask yourself- what are they optimizing for? Entropy, or generating revenue through pushing specific artists?
- systemvoltage 5y agoTry using 2005-era iTunes. Dense interface, everything like a table, clear UX patterns for clicking an album and then listing the songs in that album, no suggestions or lengthening your curated playlist without asking you, no animations or fancy graphics. Ok, it used to crash a lot but that's an orthogonal problem. Unpopular opinion: "Design" is ruining everything that was good. Most suggestions for good "UX/UI" on HackerNews are shit. So are all the articles posted here and advice given. Most UI frameworks suck. The whole thing is rotten to the core.
- toyg 5y agoThis is what "business at the speed of light" looks like. Everything is sped up, including tool development.
- datavirtue 5y agoWhen you use installable/desktop software you can also control network security and therefore application security via your firewalls and other devices. So the user is able to control secure access and contain any possible breeches...cheaply...instead of just pumping all their data to the cloud and hoping the SaaS provider knows what they are doing and has secured every single exploit and leak vector that comes with publishing a web-based solution.